Notice
Thread ordered by most liked posts - View normal thread.

vi555

Member
does her weight have anything to do with the quality of her content or the way she handles the topics of the videos? its not relevant to any of us ngl and if she did get a sleeve she's clearly working on herself and her health so good for her. she's a true crime youtuber not a lifestyle influencer and her appearance has nothing to do with her content. just mind ur own business someone elses weight isnt your problem
 
  • Like
  • Heart
Reactions: 41

Viewer1901

VIP Member
I watch her crime videos. A lot of them are just her basically reading the Wikipedia article out.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 33

Blueblue123

VIP Member
EN irritates the hell out of me… she seems like a typical fat lazy person who does the bare minimum and earns off it.
Fat people are lazy? Is that necessary?

Eleanor is very much like many social media people, fat or thin. Plenty slim social media personalities are as bad as Eleanor or worse.
 
  • Like
  • Haha
Reactions: 32

FJones

New member
Cba with her using clickbait titles for her videos. It’s a true crime video, not a fkin drama performance. I wish she would show some damn respect.
She covered one of my family members death and titled it “murdered over changing her Facebook status” the comments on there are heartbreaking for me because of the misinformation she spread, half facts then half entertainment factor of exaggerating facts into lies, we can’t do anything about it we have tried, I don’t know how she gets away with it
 
  • Like
  • Sad
  • Heart
Reactions: 31

mochibean

VIP Member
She is such a pick me - tbf any weird behaviour from this elephant worked out in her favour as she’s got an apartment in london
Bit harsh and uncalled for imo.

It's just the profiting off of people's deaths for me. The way she presents and puts their stories out there it's such a turn off.
Not a single unsponsored video, splitting them into multiple parts needlessly for more money, starts with 'don't mean any disrespect' but I don't find her particularly respectful to the families at times either.. I'm just put off by her these days.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 29

xxxxxxxxx123

New member
Has she responded to this or has anything else been said?
I wouldn't at all be surprised if this is true.
as someone who knows both people (Eleanor and the OP) I can confirm this isn’t true and Eleanor was never a bully

I know a lot of people were really shocked to see that posted on Facebook because Eleanor was so quiet in school but the OP was an attention seeker in school and the fact she set it to public so it would get shared around says a lot

we are from a small town and people hate to see others succeeding round here, really cruel tbh but not true at all
 
  • Like
  • Heart
Reactions: 28

l2mhb0

Member
Eleanor Neale doing a sponsorship with gymshark has absolutely finished me off 😭 the message about being safe whilst running was the only good thing to come out of it but she could have made that message clear without doing a GYMSHARK sponsorship when her channel is about true crime, NOTHING TO DO WITH BEING ACTIVE OR SPORTS!!!

If anything it’s also put me off gymshark and I’m not surprised actual fitness gurus like Natacha Oceane left when they’re sponsoring people who are nowhere near the ambassadors they need for their brand.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 28

bellasmith86

Chatty Member
78A4B588-3346-42E7-A22B-6883167432CF.jpeg

It’s not just her dramatic weight loss, it’s her whole appearance, even her hair! Not that anyone ever needs makeup etc but she seemed to be really into her makeup and tanning and it’s all suddenly stopped. I hope she is ok, however annoying she is.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 27

ariawyn

Active member
In her video about Bianca Devins she even says how she finds it disgusting that a documentary crew started doing a piece on her death and how it was disgraceful that they were cashing in on the murder of this seventeen year old girl…I couldn’t cope with the hypocrisy. Does she hear herself speak? Funnily enough, within 10 seconds of her saying that, YouTube gave me a set of ads on the video. But sure Eleanor, go be disgusted.
 
  • Like
  • Wow
Reactions: 27

Tippingpoint23

VIP Member
I don’t like gymshark anyway there’s much better sport brands but what an insensitive advert for a 14 year old girls death. The message was ok like don’t run the same route don’t listen to music too loud, but has Eleanor ever been on a run? (Not shaming her) but she’s never expressed any sort of interest in fitness/running/exercise so what a random pairing. No wonder credible athletes are jumping ship. A refreshing change to see just one video instead of two parts!
 
  • Like
  • Heart
Reactions: 27
Youtube started recommending her videos to me during lockdown. She's almost compellingly awful at her so-called job.

She radiates smugness and a kind of awful, treacly insincerity, and its obvious she just pastes swathes of material from wikis or news reports to read out. She shows a total lack of interest in anything that even requires the most basic research, such as pronunciation of foreign names or even English words that are clearly well above her educational grade. Typically mangles a word, smugly notes she doesn't know how to say it, then shrugs and smirks and moves on. It's called google, bitch. You can even find soundfiles for most non-English or just difficult words to model the correct pronunciation. Give it a go. Her grammar or rather lack of it makes her sound really tragically thick at times. If it's your job to talk to camera surely you should try a bit harder to sound more prepared? Plus she often presents two entirely contradictory claims regarding the events of the crime, clearly taken from different sources, and fails to note or try to explain the discrepancy which points to either her inability to truly parse what she's reading and regurgitating or just how lazy and uninterested she is in accuracy or quality. Or both.

I did hear her mention her main viewer demographic is pre-teens though, which explains a lot about her lack of quality and overall mediocrity versus her crazy amount of views. The comments are full of 'omg you look beautiful today's too, which also suggests an audience with a rather low bar for content who just see her as some unthreatening big sister type with a lot of cool make-up who talks about random, titillating gory crap for fun, like scary fictional bedtime stories. Although knowing that a lot of very young kids watch her, she might want to moderate some of her content. Not sure Peter Scully - one of the videos I watched and was kind of shocked how she got right into the facts of the grisly torture-rapes of toddlers and creation of extreme child pornography etc without really showing much more than a kind of suppressed glee at the awfulness of it - and that sort of shit is really suitable content for pre-teens. I wonder if someone presenting crime with her attitude really causes more harm than good, turning it into some weird form of entertainment with no thoughtfulness, redeeming or educational worth beyond that. Annoying girl.
 
  • Like
  • Heart
Reactions: 26

Tippingpoint23

VIP Member
In her most recent video (which once again she has done 2 parts to make more ££££) she says 'you will want to watch the second one because thats where the gory stuff is' or something along those lines. I had to turn off at this point because that is an incredibly disrespectful way to describe real life people being brutally murdered. Comments like that make it seem as though true crime is for entertainment rather than anything else and dramatises real people. I was so shocked she said it and kept it in.
 
  • Like
  • Wow
  • Angry
Reactions: 26
I created an account so I could say she is one of the most overrated true crime YouTubers imo. I tried to watch her new video and had to stop when she was explaining indecent exposure and giggled awkwardly about it. Grow up, maybe? I also recommend Georgia Marie. She doesn't beg for money like Eleanor and maybe other true crime YouTubers do.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 25

Nottsgirl

Chatty Member
I watched her Ana Kriegel videos a few days ago and they keep playing on my mind. It’s too soon to be talking about it so sensationally, and to be talking cheerily about streaming services and the like, it’s just not say well with me at all.

Ana’s case was incredibly traumatic to follow. I remember clearly being in university and the whole country was sickened and upset by it. Stuff like that doesn’t happen in Ireland. For Ana to be used as fodder to pad out an advert for a streaming service to keep a callous, insensitive young woman in an expensive London flat, makes me sick.
 
  • Like
  • Sad
Reactions: 25