I think the coercive controlling behaviour comment from the police, sealed that it was him, it points to something that was ongoing in the home before it all kicked off .... I have no doubt there was some fight between them, but do think both gave as good as they got, she is not the innocent that she is portraying, yes ` IF ` he punched her in the face, of course thats wrong, but what injuries did she give him? ... we are only hearing her side ... and if substances were involved, means they would have been off their nut .... its not unknown for couples, who are heavily under the influence, to knock six bells out of each other ..... the fact she was pictured almost immediately on release from hospital, does not sit ok with me ... surely if she were that upset, she wouldn't be able to have a camera in her face so soon after such an incident, I know from personal experience, after a beating, this is not something I could have done ... as always with her, there is something else going on here, it seems quite orchestrated