I think the Emily Roses are really quite upset. Yes, they don't have to read here and don't understand this is a gossip forum not hate site and should they wish they can start a rave thread. But reading here and seeing their names have clearly upset them. Whilst I know they've put their names out there as super fans and Jonathan has really broadcast them, it must be hard for them to see themselves discussed in detail here especially when they don't think they're doing wrong and are only young. Unlike the people with threads on this board who's literal business it is to put themselves out there and are paid accordingly.
They're fan girls, just like there have always been fan girls since Elvis and The Beatles, for them it just happens to be YouTubers and this family in particular. The difference is of course these particular Youtubers respond in a way that other celebs etc would be discouraged not to for legal reasons etc. And what does that do? It makes them feel special. It makes their comments and behaviour all the more frenzied, because ahhhh their idols have noticed them. They have inside jokes and nicknames etc. And if they've made other friends in doing so then great. One day they might see the light, but they might not and it's likely the more they feel the SJ's are attacked the harder they'll defend, because that's what they feel super fans should do.
However, the criticism here about Jonathan's behaviour is of course valid. And he should know better. Especially not to single out members, no matter how much they comment etc, who can then be identified and contacted by other older men who claim to personally know him. It's completely irresponsible and a potential disaster waiting to happen.
I know people commenting here mean well and many have tried to advise the girls. I love the Tattle bastards on here. Them getting upset about reading things we say about the SJ's is one thing (and what do they expect reading a gossip forum they don't have to) but as young girls it must be harder to take reading comments about your own behaviour on here when in their eyes they're just supporting their faves and not influencers etc. I know if I'd have got attention from my fave boyband etc as a teen I'd have lost my head a bit and gone a bit ott.
Jonathan, step down from your holy shepherd perch, take a long hard look at yourself and realise what you're doing.