100%.
I completely agree, some people are never going to BQ due to their body shape/natural max capabilities, and someone who may have never previously run a day in their life will BQ by a huge margin in their first marathon. As we’ve said before on this thread though, a BQ is not the be all and end all, and everyone should have their own goals that make sense for THEM. A good coach would help you figure out if they are achievable or not, and would be honest with you, rather than letting you chase a pie in the sky dream where you inevitably crash and burn at every opportunity.
I fully agree as well that a fast runner does not equal a good coach, and I’ll go as far to say that if their website shows a complete obsession with their PBs and own capabilities (*cough* Lloyd Kempson *cough*), run for the hills. People like WR and that ilk just dole out the training that works for them without regard to the individual. Makes me angry, as I’m a coach myself and I spend so much time making individual plans for my clients and being available all the time for them! And because of these insta coaches’ antics, people might be wary of hiring coaches and then be less likely to work with someone like myself who actually gives a tit!