How did Wynona Ryder come back?
He must address it, people will continue to 'discover' the news article and ask questions. Leaving it unanswered would lead people think to think for what it is. What I'm going to say next is highly inmoral, so don't come for me
He should address that him going AWOL from the military, and this thiefing business were all connected to his sisters suicide.
Emphasize how much he loved her, and looking up to her while growing up (make the audiance feel this strong sibling connection and the loss of it)
When she was gone, he fell into this black hole where he was angry at God for not looking after or healing his sisters difficulties.
Fueled with abuse of anti depressant pills, he made this big big mistake.
However getting caught was the best thing to ever happen to him. Because it gave him time to rethink his actions and suddenly he could see how very wrong it was. How he feels very embarrassed and that him stealing those items from churches wouldn't bring his sister back, nor heal the wounds. Instead he decided to turn his life arround and make a living of which his sister would be proud of him.
Also he should mention he made peace with God and the church now and his way of repaying for his sins was to restore the convent and help kick start the funds for the new organ in Norwich.
'I sincerely apologies for my actions and hope for your forgiveness'
He should then continue making flogs as if nothing happened and pick up the pace of renovations for a couple of weeks involving all family members. Mom trotter, sister and MPK clearing the garden/planting, Pa Trotter, Billy & crew swiftly moving in the library.
He would still loose some subscribers but he would also gain new ones. Especially the church goers would be all forgiven (It's a virtue, right) since he has been working incredibly hard these pasts couple of years and it looks like he has build himself a lovely little family.
P.s. I agree with Tattlers, that someone is out there to take the Pethericks down. It's a personal vendetta and they will not stop until all the dirty laundry is out.