For me, it wasn't the plan that 'caused' food issues.
I already had plenty of food issues but for me, it was the actual meetings and the way they are done.
Starving myself all day because I needed to make sure I didn't gain because then I'd basically be shamed infront of everyone in group after for gaining with things like, "Oh, you gained 1lb. What did you do wrong this week?"
"Let's go around the room and get you some advice for ways to help you lose next week"
Absolutely this. So it may well be class specific as maybe not all consultants are the same and thats why we dont all have the same experiences.
Im not saying I didnt overeat prior to SW because I did but the binge / restrict cycle due to the public nature of the classes and discussions was certainly introduced to me there. The jokes would be banded about regularly about wearing the same clothes to weigh in, dont drink after x time, dont eat after lunch.
Ultimately yes it was my choice to do this but I couldnt cope socially with the shame of gaining or maintaining or losing *just 1lb* as it was said in my class. When you were asked what you wanted to lose next week if you said 1lb it was always 'oh c'mon you can do better than that' youd have to give the ins and outs of your menstrual cycle to justify it. I know I hold weight more when I ovulate than on my period. 'Oh is it your star week?' No Brenda my ovary is popping out an egg.
Its never actually explained to you just how much you need to overeat to gain 1lb of fat. The age old muscle weighs more than fat is banded about a lot. Not that its just more dense and 1lb of feathers weighs the same as 1lb of metal.
Ive said it before on this thread CBT helped me so much more than any diet classes or coaches ever have.
Ive also said on this thread before that if you have lost weight with SW and its worked for you and continues to work thats amazing, being genuine here. Different strokes for different folks. If you go every week and dont need to pay a penny and its what keeps you on track Im never going to fault that.