I would say the majority of people on here have zero issues with anyone who feels they have been born a different gender than the one they identify with. The concern is how the SJ family have shared a journey that wasnt theirs to share. They posted multiple videos where E2 was adamant they were a boy and didn’t want to be a girl. They seemed to associate wanting to be a girl with wearing floaty dresses, having long hair and posing for the camera. They knew they received attention. Their parents changed the narrative of the story they’d told, and forgot they’d shared this to millions. Edie had a gender reveal party, which they wanted a cake and pizza, Which they were more excited about than announcing their new name. They even forgot their name when jonny was attempting to tease us with clues. Edie didnt choose their name, Anna did. Jonny constantly shows videos and photos of Edie when they were known as Eduardo and still has Eduardo written on their bedroom wall. All of those things, im certain are not how to help a child transition. It appears that Edie has been coerced into thinking being a girl gets them attention. It concerns many the detrimental effects this will have on edie as their journey is thoroughly documented, and will always be there. They can not consent to their story being shown, as they don’t understand what that means. Thry did not need to share every detail, reply to comments regarding surgery, and pretend Edie is writing diary entries to their boyfriend, and talking about their sexual preferences. This and much more is what most of us have concerns over. If E2 feels like they want to be a boy or a girl is absolutely fine. I just don’t feel they should be doing this so publicly. Why did jonny title their videos with “trans daughter...” in every video? I could go on with the red flags from the SJ’s. I have friends who’s siblings now identify as a different gender, and they find it really worrying how Edie is being used by their parents.