Actually there are some points to this.
1. Ioan could have filed for bifurcation after 6 months regardless of the state of custody etc. He didn't. I think this emboldened Alice and was a strategically bad move
2. He couldn't do anything about leaving the kids with Alice, but he was seeing the kids regularly until the hacking-gate.
3 & 4. He did have options and could have filed for an emergency ex-parte order re: enforcing custody. He didn't but he tried to get the girls to go to therapy. He again had options to act aggressively through the courts once he knew parental alienation was in effect - and he was aware of this as he noted the change in the girls behaviours once he was seeing them
5. He did mess up his own life by choosing to stay with Alice despite enormous red flags. This is not his fault, as anyone who has encountered a dangerously manipulative partner will attest to. But it will ruin your life regardless.
6. Alice is the most dangerous one and the one will completely ruin the lives of their children. But Ioan is also an adult and he has to take some share of responsibility for his choices and the amount of time that this has dragged on for. There were legal channels available to be more aggressive and I am positive Anne Kiley encouraged him to do so.
Not everyone who does not share the 'group view' of "Alice bad, Ioan good" is an FM. I don't believe Alice all bad or he would not have stayed with her for over 20 years - I do believe she has always been problematic but really moved into dangerously unstable territory about 7 years ago. I am also frustrated and annoyed at Ioan's passiveness and willingness to leave his kids with Alice. And don't @ me - there are aggressive measures available to him should he wished to take them and he would have been advised of this.
MOO
I'm not coming for you, just saying I respect your right to your view.
I wrote that reply very quickly and in the very early hours of the morning before bed, had I written it at another time I would have added more info to it. I was just flabbergasted at the original comment I was replying to and the language used.
I think Alice was always a horrible person but it was to a lesser extent, more spiteful and mean than outright dangerous, and agree with you that it only starting badly emerging around 6-7 years ago. I think he did love her for many years. I also think he stayed with her for so long because he's from a traditional background and has strong family values, and he tried to make his marriage work. So IMO I don't think it's fair for people to say he messed up his life by staying with her, or that he is the one who messed his daughters' lives up.
I also agree Ioan should have been more aggressive, because Alice was and is playing on a different level to him. But hindsight is a wonderful thing; he probably didn't think she would stoop to the depths that she has. I don't think anyone on this thread thought she would do what she's done.
Ioan has been advised by some of the best divorce lawyers in California, and Alice has still made a terrible farce out of this, and continues to try and control him, ruin his relationship with his daughters and damage his career, as well as bully his new partner.