Long, looooong time lurker and just joined to share my thoughts.
I used to be a huge fan of CHF, I was interested in going into Musical Theatre too and found her videos so insightful, honest and fun. I'd say towards the end of her relationship with Pete, I unsubscribed as I found the content she was producing to be not my cup of tea anymore, but then when she started with Oliver I began to dislike her. I found her attitude and general demeanour changed and it began to rub me the wrong way.. granted, we all grow up and change but I can't put my finger on specifics.
We both got dumped at a similar time this year, mine wasn't as long as Carrie's and it was long distance, my partner ghosted me and then started seeing someone else. In my opinion, that is blindsided and being bailed on. I don't know what happened to Carrie, but I was so torn up the last thing I wanted to do was talk about it, let alone throw a pity party. I started therapy too, and realised there is far more to focus on in myself before I even consider a relationship again, as I realised I tend to go for similar types of men, which I wonder is a similarity myself and CHF have.
The very last thing I wanted to do was start a new relationship. Look, I know we all grow at different speeds, but the fact that around 2 weeks after she was posting about how the lyrics in Cinderella were reminding her of a broken down relationship/feeling unloved (I'm paraphrasing) and then is straight into a 100mph relationship with Joel, is red flags everywhere. I am beginning to think (my opinion, not a professional), her and Joel are both toxic in their own ways. Carrie - as I doubt she has healed from Oliver and is using Joel as a band aid and has the victim-mentality for most things so gives the impression she is quite a good manipulator, and Joel - the love bombing seems to give off a more sinister vibe. I find men that have love bombed me in the past so early have turned out to be too intense, jealous, demanding, and sometimes abusive. (not saying this is what is happening here, just an observation)
At the end of the day, it is Carrie's life, I of course wish her no harm, but watching all of this play out and how she has changed over the years has made me feel a little sad. Her life doesn't seem to be as centred around her passions anymore, it is what guy is in her life.