Ok so your post makes me cross. Cross at the unfairness of unwarranted opportunities handed to certain individuals on a plate.Also I had a skim through the excerpt and gave the first paragraph my best attempt at a rewrite, I spent all of five minutes on this but it was quite a fun exercise, I suggest you all give it a go (see my attempt at improvement below:
"There was something about the small hours of the morning, something in the still and silence that cleared the mind. Call it the clarity that came from the fog lifting from yet another bad dream or call it the blessed quiet that came from the soft snores that drifted from Joanie's room, but five o'clock in the morning was Lorelai's sweet spot. The sharpness from her nightmares dulled to mere gruesome echo, but the tiredness from yet another broken night's sleep yet to settle in her bones.
At five o'clock in the morning all Lorelai needed was her notebook and her favourite pen. When she was once again chased from her dreams they would always be found on the worn old kitchen table. With pen in hand Lorelai was free, she could slip into any world, weave any tale. At five o'clock in the morning, Lorelai was free. "
Yours says succinctly, in a couple paragraphs what C bored on about for unreadable pages. Sentences that a teacher, never mind a supposed editor would’ve slashed through with a red pen. Yours makes me want to read more.
That this guff gets passed by Carrie/a ghostwriter/an agent/an editor (at an actual publishers) and then people actually buy it and fawn over it is just ridiculous.
I think the typo at the start of this extract tells you all you need to know about the quality of the publishing house. If I didn’t know better I would say this was a self published vanity project.
It’s a cash grab plain and simple.
I would love to see actual figures of how many are sold before it ends up at The Works