Or it is working and IF she gets down to her lowest weight she will either be honest about the true weight gain and the knob heads that believe she is a size 14 will be like you have done so amazing well done for being 'honest and open' or she won't be honest how much she actually gained! Or she will just regain all the weight.She doesn’t mention weigh ins anymore? Surely if calorie counting was working for her she’d be shouting it from the rooftops