The Moscow/Idaho Murders #2

Status
Thread locked. We start a new thread when they have over 1000 posts, click the blue button to see all threads for this topic and find the latest open thread.
New to Tattle Life? Click "Order Thread by Most Liked Posts" button below to get an idea of what the site is about:
Xanas dad and sister spoke at an early stage. Maddies Dad recently spoke to the press. I think Kaylees Dad is an alpha male who was driven by grief and rage and was determined to make sure they got justice.
 
Reactions: 16
Dylan is pretty tall - you can really see it in photos of her with the rest of the housemates. If BK saw her (it's not entirely clear in the PCA if he did), maybe that could be a reason he left her alone?

She might have been too much of a challenge physically for him after he killed four people (and especially Ethan).
 
Reactions: 4
Desperate to hear those poor kids were awake and in terror...really sad to read those details.

To anyone that is judging poor Dylan...please understand this as I went through an event which terrified me when I was that age (20)..fight or flight is a myth for most people...this type of fear will absolutely paralyze you in a life or death situation..you won't be able to move.I think the girl probably did process the scene and went into a state of deep shock...you would often hear some people say when they go through something traumatic that it feels like an out of body experience..that you're in the room watching it unfold but unable to scream/move.she had no clue whether he was gone for good that night,if he was coming back,had an accomplice etc...that house was horror story material....
Kudos to the police/FBI they were on him since day 1...he was very sloppy I wonder if he wanted the infamy of being caught.
 
Reactions: 38
I also think there is a chance that he genuinely didn’t see her. It was dark, he had just murdered 4 people in 20 mins and was making his escape. I would imagine that by that stage his mind would have been totally focussed on what he’d just done and getting out of there.
 
Reactions: 24
Xanas dad and sister spoke at an early stage. Maddies Dad recently spoke to the press. I think Kaylees Dad is an alpha male who was driven by grief and rage and was determined to make sure they got justice.
interesting how Xanas mother was arrested and jailed for drugs related offenses days after the tragedy and there is talk that Bryan uses drugs....
 
Reactions: 13
interesting how Xanas mother was arrested and jailed for drugs related offenses days after the tragedy and there is talk that Bryan uses drugs....
BK hadn’t been in the area that long. I doubt there is any connection there. Also his drug use was reported to be historical, I don’t think I’ve seen any suggestion that he is still using.
 
Reactions: 8
Your first point is correct, this horror isn’t over for her yet as she will most likely have to stand up in court - poor girl
interesting how Xanas mother was arrested and jailed for drugs related offenses days after the tragedy and there is talk that Bryan uses drugs....
also isn’t this just Twitter speculation. Fa not been confirmed the woman mentioned is actually her mum?
 
Reactions: 3
BK hadn’t been in the area that long. I doubt there is any connection there. Also his drug use was reported to be historical, I don’t think I’ve seen any suggestion that he is still using.
Yes maybe no connection, I had read somewhere here that he did heroin, I never looked into the timing, just wondering was he 'paying' off a drug debt. Also he was no longer enrolled in college, so maybe was too distracted or actively using so could not continue his phd?
 
Reactions: 1
Unless he wants death, he will plead NG and fight tooth and nail.

Absolutely amazing police and forensic work.

My chest felt tight reading that PCA, and I shuddered when BK spoke only to confirm his understanding in court.

Utter devastation from top to bottom. Those poor kids.

I doubt we will ever hear BK's "why".
 
Reactions: 10
I think his heroin use was years ago and when he was living 2500 miles away from Idaho. Where did you read that he was no longer enrolled in college? My understanding was that he continued as usual until the end of term and didn’t show any concerning signs to other students.
 
Reactions: 11
interesting how Xanas mother was arrested and jailed for drugs related offenses days after the tragedy and there is talk that Bryan uses drugs....
But Maddie mom was arrested on drug charge before the murders, I think that they were at the same jail or in the same county too and maybe it was a related to Xana's arrest, but I'm sure about that. I'm just sure that Maddie's mom was arrested for drugs.

Xana's mom was in jail on a $50,000 bail and then got out and was interviewed on Newsnation

Your first point is correct, this horror isn’t over for her yet as she will most likely have to stand up in court - poor girl


also isn’t this just Twitter speculation. Fa not been confirmed the woman mentioned is actually her mum?
who is Fa?
 
Last edited:
Reactions: 3
This is an irresponsible thing to be spouting off.
 
Reactions: 13
This is going to sound weird but I totally understand Dylan staying in her room for hours and not calling the police. Twice I've had traumatic occasions where I have just completely shut down and gone to sleep to escape the terror, blacked out/closed down/in abject shock, or a combination of these. One incident, I was on holiday with my partner and he beat me, badly. Some lads from the room next door could hear and started kicking the door down to get at my boyfriend and beat the shit out of him. It was absolutely terrifying and my boyfriend had no option but to jump over the balcony. We were on the 6th floor. The lads broke down the door, looked over the balcony and said "looks like he's dead anyway, good". The trauma and shock from it all absolutely crippled me, I had no idea what to do. So I got in bed and went to sleep as I couldn't handle consciousness and reality. Someone came to fix the door and some girls came to check if I was ok apparently, slept through it all. I only "came to" when my boyfriend crawled into the room with two broken legs.

No one knows what they would do in a trauma situation until it happens. No one. Anyone criticising Dylan needs to have a serious word with themselves.
 
Last edited:
Reactions: 42
Looking at the floor plans online of the house Dylan’s room appears to be opposite the sliding doors in the kitchen and directly next to the stairs leading up to the 3rd floor. Xana’s room is around the corner and next to the stairs leading downstairs. This means he would have walked past Dylan’s room multiple times!
 
Reactions: 11
Reactions: 2
This is really chilling
 
Reactions: 2
Reactions: 10

Just stumbled upon this video and I can see why Dylan didn’t call 911 straight away. It looks like random people would go in and out of that house constantly. Not to mention all the screaming being heard.
 
Reactions: 6
The court room video is scary. He looks so normal. His demeanor is so calming. It's actually terrifying to think people like him live among us and we could walk by them every day.
 
Reactions: 12
Status
Thread locked. We start a new thread when they have over 1000 posts, click the blue button to see all threads for this topic and find the latest open thread.