I haven’t been following the ins and outs of this particularly, but my observation as someone that has read the email and read a few of AE’s tweets:-
-IG isn’t present as a father, clearly hasn’t been for a while, if we believe what AE has described.
- his email re the Wizard, should have been written on the Wizard? No?
- he overreacted to AE trying to facilitate a conversation over FaceTime about their daughter’s school.
All of the above screams selfish man child to me. He doesn’t want to engage with or about his children. Condescendingly asks AE to use the Wizard to communicate, but it’s ok for him to send her an email asking her to do this.
Don’t forget, his status quo is preserved - off gallivanting round the globe acting, whilst his wife stays at home and has to cope with the fall out. He doesn’t want to nor does he have to engage in the fallout.
That aside, AE’s reaction is, to me, typical of someone who has been the victim of emotional abuse. She has a strange obsessive bond to IG, and her reaction is of someone who is the victim of that person breaking that bond on his own terms.
AE needs to use what strength she has left, stop with the public posts, and rebuild her life on her terms. I feel very sorry for her. I also can see why she may not have been easy to live with, but I do wonder why…
I don’t recall AE ever truly complaining about IG as a father prior to the separation. She likes to remind everyone how much he’s been away (working) and that’s shes taken care of them herself (with a five day a week, 8 hour a day nanny…), but he seemed pretty attentive when he was home (loads of cute pictures and video clips posted to her Instagram in which you can see how much the girls adore him) and I remember her posting “thanks for working so hard for our family! We’re so lucky to have you” in the not so distant past.
So I take what she says about the relationship with him and the girls post separation with a grain of salt because 1. I have no reason to believe he went from loving father to someone who doesn’t wish to engage with his children and 2 her story is ever changing. She implies he doesn’t see them at all, but corrects to say he does seem them multiple times a week at his house (the eldest began refusing to see him there and AE supports that). also remember her complaining on video about collaborative, something about if he was supposed to have them but she wanted to keep them home she was going to do
She said he doesn’t seem to care to reach out, then complains that his DAILY texts are too generic, and I’ve seen her complain twice about him reacting negatively when he’s been on FaceTime with them and she walks in (most recently chimes in).
To me it seems he doesn’t want to engage in what would probably be a very accusatory, unproductive, hostile phone/FaceTime conversation with ALICE at this time. Since he can’t see them in person right now (again. Because he’s working. Someone needs to provide), he wants the communication he does have with the girls to be as pleasant as possible and uninterrupted. What’s wrong with that?
he didn’t say he was unwilling to discuss the children. He asked her to follow what’s been agreed upon (whether she wanted it or liked it or not) and message him through Wizard (which I believe he did. That screen capture doesn’t look like any email I’ve ever seen). Sad they can’t speak on the phone or in person at this time but I believe her behaviors caused him to draw that line. With the way she goes off online I can only image how she’d be speaking to him directly. That wouldn’t be a healthy way of communicating.
has AE been somehow abused? Maybe. Or maybe he has. Maybe they’ve been abusive to each other. Who knows. The relationship is certainly toxic at this point, we can all see that, and I’m sure it’s not easy for either (any) of them.