Gender Discussion #54

Status
Thread locked. We start a new thread when they have over 1000 posts, click the blue button to see all threads for this topic and find the latest open thread.
New to Tattle Life? Click "Order Thread by Most Liked Posts" button below to get an idea of what the site is about:
I said I wouldn’t keep mentioning Brianna but it just keeps getting worse the more I read. It’s maybe not appropriate since this poor soul was murdered so please call me out if I’m in the wrong. This child was very troubled and there should be a discussion about how kids like this get swept up in the cult of trans. Eating disorder, severe anxiety, self harm, excluded from school. Projecting all of that onto being born male and thinking it can be fixed by wearing a costume. The poor bairn probably did feel better with full makeup and cute outfit because it was covering up the person he couldn’t bear to be. It doesn’t fix what was wrong inside though. Brianna’s poor mum has worked hard campaigning for better mental health support in schools, I saw a news film about her and she didn’t mention trans once, she’s obviously switched on and I hope she isn’t getting harassed at all by the TRAs.
I agree with you. We are deeply failing children that instead of seeing safeguarding red flags like PP mentioned about signs of particular types of porn that Brianna was possibly exposed to at a young age, people just turn a blind eye and describe the behaviour and appearance as stunning, beautiful and brave. They are not concerned with the actual root cause of the distressed child.

‘Transitioning’ doesn’t appear to resolve the mental health issues. The focus of the continued mental health issues just turn to being blamed on transphobia / GC women. I’ve probably oversimplified that though.

Anyway it took less than two days for the trial thread to descend into gender identity politics chaos. So hard not to respond but it isn’t the place because at the heart of this is a 16 year old child who did not deserve to die, and in such a brutal way.
 
  • Like
  • Heart
  • Sad
Reactions: 34
I agree with you. We are deeply failing children that instead of seeing safeguarding red flags like PP mentioned about signs of particular types of porn that Brianna was possibly exposed to at a young age, people just turn a blind eye and describe the behaviour and appearance as stunning, beautiful and brave. They are not concerned with the actual root cause of the distressed child.

‘Transitioning’ doesn’t appear to resolve the mental health issues. The focus of the continued mental health issues just turn to being blamed on transphobia / GC women. I’ve probably oversimplified that though.

Anyway it took less than two days for the trial thread to descend into gender identity politics chaos. So hard not to respond but it isn’t the place because at the heart of this is a 16 year old child who did not deserve to die, and in such a brutal way.
Social media, and 24/7 internet-accessible smartphones have really ducked us up as a species in such a short space of time, and I don’t mean just regarding the trans contagion issue
 
  • Like
  • Heart
Reactions: 34
Opening of tonight’s bbc1 The Met doc. Caller SA’d on her own street by a man feeling her up. Says he was wearing lacy tights and a tutu. There it is, that thing that never happens, happening AGAIN
ETA: they’re up to 11 victims now of this perv
---
Actually feel sick they caught the perp and of COURSE he’s an AGP 🤢🤢🤢🤢
---
Here’s the press release from CPS. Suspended sentence. He’s steal roaming the streets of London. Our justice system does not give a duck about women. https://www.cps.gov.uk/london-north...-sexually-assaulting-women-streets-late-night
 
Last edited:
  • Angry
  • Like
  • Sick
Reactions: 29
I can't stay long on the Brianna trial thread, and I'm not particularly enamoured of the press reporting of this trial either. A young man (a confused, possibly mentally unwell, probably gay, young man) has been murdered, and him wearing a dress and using a female name doesn't change the fact that he was a boy.
Every single news report states that he was a "teenage girl".....no, he wasn't. His parents have lost their son (more than once), but will he ever be acknowledged in the reports? I really feel for his mother, she's been gaslit into mourning for a daughter, will anyone recognise her actual loss?
I don't even know her deceased son's name ☹
 
  • Like
  • Sad
  • Heart
Reactions: 43
It's honestly abysmal that people are more concerned with making a young teenager a trans martyr so that they can finally say someone has died from transphobic attacks in this country, than they are about the fact some other teenagers are so deeply disturbed to have not only made a list of peers to kill, but actually carried out the attack.
 
  • Like
  • Heart
Reactions: 55
Why is it there is a ‘non binary look’ though? Is it because it’s simply a fashion trend? (Make yourself look as rank as you can). We can all spot them a mile off.

Hair must be:
Short
Mullet
‘Wacky’ coloured - pink, blue, green…

Face:
Massive Deidre Barlow glasses preferably with a clear or light coloured frame,
Absolutely no make up but if you do wear it it has to be really extra and ✨out there ✨
Look like your face could do with a good wash 🧼

Clothes:
Giant toddler zibezz
Baggy button up shirts preferably 50’s style
Baggy trousers
Knitted tank tops over shirts

Attitude:
Notice meeeeeee!
Respect my pronouns!
I’m better than everyone!
I’m neither male nor female! (99% of them are female)
I’m the chosen one!
Pick meeeee!



That was fun 😇

PS - I missed out multiple piercings and tattoos. Have I missed anything else?
This is so true. I know a few like this.
The pronouns lectures and non Binary stuff gets thrown into conversations very quickly. Annoying as F£%K
 
  • Like
Reactions: 13
In my wider work circle there are a few parents who have transed their kids. I think they need locking up.
 
  • Like
  • Sad
  • Angry
Reactions: 22
I can't stay long on the Brianna trial thread, and I'm not particularly enamoured of the press reporting of this trial either. A young man (a confused, possibly mentally unwell, probably gay, young man) has been murdered, and him wearing a dress and using a female name doesn't change the fact that he was a boy.
Every single news report states that he was a "teenage girl".....no, he wasn't. His parents have lost their son (more than once), but will he ever be acknowledged in the reports? I really feel for his mother, she's been gaslit into mourning for a daughter, will anyone recognise her actual loss?
I don't even know her deceased son's name ☹
I believe it was Brett.

Anyway, I agree 100%. The whitewashing (transwashing?) of the reporting here gives me a visceral reaction. I feel so uncomfortable about it. Because it feels false - it IS false.

The fact he was a screwed up, mentally unwell boy, with an obvious eating disorder, crying out for attention (possibly even help at times) on multiple social media accounts is SO relevant to the story. And absolutely at the core of his trans identity!
 
  • Like
  • Sad
Reactions: 34
I can't stay long on the Brianna trial thread, and I'm not particularly enamoured of the press reporting of this trial either. A young man (a confused, possibly mentally unwell, probably gay, young man) has been murdered, and him wearing a dress and using a female name doesn't change the fact that he was a boy.
Every single news report states that he was a "teenage girl".....no, he wasn't. His parents have lost their son (more than once), but will he ever be acknowledged in the reports? I really feel for his mother, she's been gaslit into mourning for a daughter, will anyone recognise her actual loss?
I don't even know her deceased son's name ☹
I’ve unfollowed it now. It was inevitable it would end up the way it has. Terfs were trending on Twitter earlier. (I don’t care about being called a terf but it’s the anger and hatred towards women that goes with it). There is literally nothing that could come out of this trial to make people with a certain agenda think it was anything but a hate crime.

His name is Brett Spooner. I don’t know why the surname changed, is the mum’s surname Ghey? Would this also most likely just be a social name change or could the parents have legally changed it? I’ve seen the judge has been criticised for using the name Brett in court when the history was explained to the jury. And the press criticised for repeating it. Again they tie themselves in knots insisting we don’t mention anything pre-transition, but we acknowledge this person is trans even though trans girls are female. So we must pretend they are the same as biological girls even though they are different, stunning, brave, but what makes them different must never be mentioned 🤫 🥴
 
  • Like
Reactions: 30
I’ve seen the judge has been criticised for using the name Brett in court when the history was explained to the jury. And the press criticised for repeating it. Again they tie themselves in knots insisting we don’t mention anything pre-transition, but we acknowledge this person is trans even though trans girls are female. So we must pretend they are the same as biological girls even though they are different, stunning, brave, but what makes them different must never be mentioned 🤫 🥴
Honestly, the rage and self-righteous over repeating his given name, sorry “dead name”, is ridiculous. It’s so performative.

It sounds as if his name hadn’t been changed officially since he was still a child, so the judge (being bound by tradition and common sense rules as they are) is using his legal name. That’s all 🤷‍♀️
 
  • Like
  • Heart
Reactions: 26
Nobody would even know about the dead name if the TRA's weren't screaming about it. I hadn't read it in the press anywhere.

Juries need a full and factual background to be able to reach a sound verdict, irrespective of the fragile feelings of opinionated Twitter bleeps.
 
  • Like
  • Heart
Reactions: 26
The whole ‘deadnaming’ thing is bonkers to me. How can you wipe out your whole life like that and expect everyone else to as well? As a mum I find it so upsetting to think of being told I could never call my child the name I gave him ever again and have been saying for 11 years. Thankfully I’m not in that position but lots of other parents are. I don’t want to say too much on the Brianna story as I find it very upsetting, but just thinking about his poor mum it’s just awful the whole thing.
 
  • Like
  • Heart
Reactions: 37
Opening of tonight’s bbc1 The Met doc. Caller SA’d on her own street by a man feeling her up. Says he was wearing lacy tights and a tutu. There it is, that thing that never happens, happening AGAIN
ETA: they’re up to 11 victims now of this perv
---
Actually feel sick they caught the perp and of COURSE he’s an AGP 🤢🤢🤢🤢
---
Here’s the press release from CPS. Suspended sentence. He’s steal roaming the streets of London. Our justice system does not give a duck about women. https://www.cps.gov.uk/london-north...-sexually-assaulting-women-streets-late-night
Melissa Garner, from the CPS, said: “Ali Ay accosted his victims whilst they walked alone late at night in north London.

“He wore women’s clothing to lure his victims and make them initially feel at ease in his company. He told them that he was gay and that they should not be frightened. He then took the opportunity to sexually assault a number of them.

“The prosecution case included CCTV footage and strong witness testimony. We were also able to present a number of the items used by Ay in the attacks including tights and tutus.

“Women should feel safe to walk the streets without fear of attack. The CPS remain committed to prosecuting sexual offenders.”


And yet all he received was a 20 month suspended sentence. How does that equate to women feeling safe to walk the streets without fear of attack? Nothing has changed except for a measly slap on the wrist. There were multiple victims, so every reason to suspect he will re-offend. He was cleared of 10 counts of indecent exposure because he exposed prosthetic genitals rather than his own :mad:. Found this article with more info.
 
  • Angry
  • Sick
  • Sad
Reactions: 30
It's honestly abysmal that people are more concerned with making a young teenager a trans martyr so that they can finally say someone has died from transphobic attacks in this country, than they are about the fact some other teenagers are so deeply disturbed to have not only made a list of peers to kill, but actually carried out the attack.
Some people definitely want it to be the fault of the Evil Terfs. And that will just make other poor confused teenagers convinced that they could be next. It's a shocking thing to do.
 
  • Like
  • Sad
  • Angry
Reactions: 21
I can't stay long on the Brianna trial thread, and I'm not particularly enamoured of the press reporting of this trial either. A young man (a confused, possibly mentally unwell, probably gay, young man) has been murdered, and him wearing a dress and using a female name doesn't change the fact that he was a boy.
Every single news report states that he was a "teenage girl".....no, he wasn't. His parents have lost their son (more than once), but will he ever be acknowledged in the reports? I really feel for his mother, she's been gaslit into mourning for a daughter, will anyone recognise her actual loss?
I don't even know her deceased son's name ☹
I was just thinking of that when I saw this:

IMG_5295.jpeg
The media coverage has been very respectful, as you would expect because Brianna was ultimately a child who was horribly murdered in a way no one deserves. They have all used his chosen name and referred to him as a girl. You can’t expect them to not even mention the fact that he was trans because it came up in the evidence of the case. And society … well again people are rightly horrified by this and see it for what it is, a very tragic murder
 
  • Like
  • Heart
Reactions: 29
Melissa Garner, from the CPS, said: “Ali Ay accosted his victims whilst they walked alone late at night in north London.

“He wore women’s clothing to lure his victims and make them initially feel at ease in his company. He told them that he was gay and that they should not be frightened. He then took the opportunity to sexually assault a number of them.

“The prosecution case included CCTV footage and strong witness testimony. We were also able to present a number of the items used by Ay in the attacks including tights and tutus.

“Women should feel safe to walk the streets without fear of attack. The CPS remain committed to prosecuting sexual offenders.”


And yet all he received was a 20 month suspended sentence. How does that equate to women feeling safe to walk the streets without fear of attack? Nothing has changed except for a measly slap on the wrist. There were multiple victims, so every reason to suspect he will re-offend. He was cleared of 10 counts of indecent exposure because he exposed prosthetic genitals rather than his own :mad:. Found this article with more info.
This has made me feel physically sick.
Threats of incarceration for not using preferred pronouns but a dangerous and clearly mentally ill man is let loose to terrorise women.
 
  • Like
  • Angry
  • Sad
Reactions: 30
Melissa Garner, from the CPS, said: “Ali Ay accosted his victims whilst they walked alone late at night in north London.

“He wore women’s clothing to lure his victims and make them initially feel at ease in his company. He told them that he was gay and that they should not be frightened. He then took the opportunity to sexually assault a number of them.

“The prosecution case included CCTV footage and strong witness testimony. We were also able to present a number of the items used by Ay in the attacks including tights and tutus.

“Women should feel safe to walk the streets without fear of attack. The CPS remain committed to prosecuting sexual offenders.”


And yet all he received was a 20 month suspended sentence. How does that equate to women feeling safe to walk the streets without fear of attack? Nothing has changed except for a measly slap on the wrist. There were multiple victims, so every reason to suspect he will re-offend. He was cleared of 10 counts of indecent exposure because he exposed prosthetic genitals rather than his own :mad:. Found this article with more info.
The fact they had the cheek to say that about women feeling safe whilst HE IS STILL OUT ON THE STREETS!! You can’t make this tit up
 
  • Like
  • Angry
  • Sick
Reactions: 24
Status
Thread locked. We start a new thread when they have over 1000 posts, click the blue button to see all threads for this topic and find the latest open thread.