Gender Discussion #22

Status
Thread locked. We start a new thread when they have over 1000 posts, click the blue button to see all threads for this topic and find the latest open thread.
New to Tattle Life? Click "Order Thread by Most Liked Posts" button below to get an idea of what the site is about:
I like what he says here but why does he call himself a 'theocratic fascist'? What does that mean?
It makes me suspicious of him.
You're right to be. As sensible as he is on the trans topic, he's a horrible horrible human being who is NO FRIEND to women. As a former evangelical American, he's been in my online sphere for many years. I don't hate many people I've never met (or many that I HAVE met!) but I hate Matt Walsh.

This picture makes me want to weep. And I guarantee you that these three young women are going to be harassed for grouping together like this in a show of solidarity. They'll be raked over the coals for not gushing over LT or welcoming him into their winner's circle. ☹😤
 
Last edited:
  • Like
  • Wow
Reactions: 7
I'm quite grateful to Lia Thomas to be honest. The disgraceful scenes of women getting second and third places behind a man at a women's swim meet has properly peaked the men in my household. My husband has been horrified by what he's seen, we both watched the weightlifter at the Olympics, but he didn't realise that men competing in women's sports was actually an ongoing issue, he thought it was just a virtue-signalling gesture at the Olympics, not that young women were going to actually have to compete against a man at their college sports events.

My son and his girlfriend are full-on woke. They have a ftm friend, who has had top surgery, they're full of praise and admiration for his "bravery" etc, etc. I love my son's girlfriend, but I don't want to speak to her about it, she'd probably just think I was an old terf, who has outdated ideas. But my son and I are close and we've had some interesting discussions on this. He was quite shocked to hear about the weirdo p who managed to wrangle a position of authority in the Guides, until outed on Twitter with photos brandishing a gun and wearing fetish clothing. He hadn't heard about the grape crisis centre in Scotland, currently being run by a man. He wasn't aware of the possible long-term damage inflicted onto children by doctors at the Tavistock and other gender clinics around the world. And he does understand my concerns at having men in changing-rooms and public restrooms, spaces that are supposed to be set aside for women to use.

Lia Thomas is doing women a huge public service. Just not in the way that he thinks.
 
  • Like
  • Heart
Reactions: 37
I'm devastated for those young women who have to 'keep quiet' and not complain while LT beats them thanks to a biological advantage. But seeing the three of them arm in arm and smiling warmed my heart.
 
  • Like
  • Heart
Reactions: 19
Am I wrong to say in the swimming it’s just the first 3 places that get a podium place? If that’s the case kudos to the 3 women celebrating 2nd . 3rd and 4th which the majority of the world know it’s 1.2 and 3 apart from the guy in the crowd that asks people if they are biologists.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 18
I googled Sarah Robles to see how she was getting on after the Olympics. Not a lot, but scrolling down Google and there was this. Why are people so nosy? And assume this all the time?
EE57D737-4968-47AA-B70A-7AC093EFAF3F.jpeg
 
  • Sad
Reactions: 1
Am I wrong to say in the swimming it’s just the first 3 places that get a podium place? If that’s the case kudos to the 3 women celebrating 2nd . 3rd and 4th which the majority of the world know it’s 1.2 and 3 apart from the guy in the crowd that asks people if they are biologists.
Yeah they were basically saying “this is what the actual podium should look like”. Good for them.
 
  • Like
  • Heart
Reactions: 19
So when is Lia going to have the op?

Sports need transgender specific competitions for fairness, just like there is the paralympics.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 7
Lia Thomas is peaking the world. Can no longer be such an abstract concept when you them all on the podium. A picture paints a thousand words.
Im so happy to see those real women standing together as a trio. It wouldn’t shock me at all if they’ve been threatened with disqualification if they speak out or act in a way the hard left would describe as “hateful or anti-trans” such as refusing to compete against the man.

The man looks pathetic stood there on first. Almost like a child that they have had to put up with him partake in their game incase he cries.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
  • Heart
Reactions: 28
My partner thinks I have unkind views on trans people. Asked her if she supports self ID: yes. Asked her if she thought it was fair that men who are sexual predators can then ID as women to gain access to vulnerable women in hostels and grape crisis groups, as is happening in Scotland: no, but #notalltranswomen. Then concluded she couldn't argue as I had clearly done more research. Give me strength.
There is an easy reply to this.

When it was decided that women required single sex spaces, there was no suggestion that all men were a threat to women, just a recognition that some men were.

A man declaring his identity as woman does not change this fact in the slightest. We know now that male pattern offences do not change because of identity.

Allowing men into women's spaces makes them mixed sex and as such puts women and girls at a higher risk.

No, not all trans are offenders, but some are and the premise is the same as the original thought process.
 
  • Like
  • Heart
Reactions: 10
So when is Lia going to have the op?

Sports need transgender specific competitions for fairness, just like there is the paralympics.
He won’t. He’ll rinse the trans thing for all he can, staying an intact male, will just bulldoze through life taking advantage wherever he can and he will be celebrated for it. Will probably win sportswoman of the year in the future. It’s all so effed up. It’s such an easy way for men to get the upper hand over women, and if we say anything about it, we’re the baddies. Talk about gaslighting.

*when I say easy, I mean staying intact and just changing your name and pronouns. I’m sure getting your fool chopped off is not easy.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 16
Isn't the solution (although not always logistically or financially possible) to have the regular single sex places but also have a unisex unit too for transgender to feel safe in.
Of course if the sole basis of their argument was that they feel excluded not being allowed in the gender that they identify with loo/place, then my sympathy is less.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 3
He won’t. He’ll rinse the trans thing for all he can, staying an intact male, will just bulldoze through life taking advantage wherever he can and he will be celebrated for it. Will probably win sportswoman of the year in the future. It’s all so effed up. It’s such an easy way for men to get the upper hand over women, and if we say anything about it, we’re the baddies. Talk about gaslighting.

*when I say easy, I mean staying intact and just changing your name and pronouns. I’m sure getting your fool chopped off is not easy.
Even with the said appendage being chopped off it won’t make him anything else but a man with a mutilated pen. They cannot change their gender, they can act/appropriate/remove and add whatever they want. They will always be the male or female that they were born as. Hormones and appendages being removed/added will not change their chromosomes. Simple blood test can help with the “confused”. It should be treated as the mental disorder it is!
 
  • Like
  • Heart
Reactions: 28
Even with the said appendage being chopped off it won’t make him anything else but a man with a mutilated pen. They cannot change their gender, they can act/appropriate/remove and add whatever they want. They will always be the male or female that they were born as. Hormones and appendages being removed/added will not change their chromosomes. Simple blood test can help with the “confused”. It should be treated as the mental disorder it is!
I agree I just thought I should point out for balance that getting surgery to remove body parts surely is not an easy decision to make or to go through. I don’t believe it makes you the opposite sex though.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 8
Status
Thread locked. We start a new thread when they have over 1000 posts, click the blue button to see all threads for this topic and find the latest open thread.