I can't stand the Flack, but has anyone considered she might have plead not guilty because there's another version of events?
This whole business of hitting a guy on the head with a lamp *while he's asleep* never rang true for me. I mean, if that's true, then it's not heat-of-the-argument stuff, it's calculated-cold-blooded-murder stuff. Even for a troubled hothead like Caroline, it just doesn't make sense. She's more about the confrontation. EDIT TO ADD: the only source we have for the "while asleep" story is Lewis himself.
Then there's the perfect boyfriend himself, loyally standing by his woman. Is Lewis the truly forgiving type, or does he just want to get back into Caroline's good graces so that she forgives his philandering?
Don't even get me started on Andrew Brady. Anyone who saw him on CBB knows he's a vain fame bleep and a user. He's an Apprentice reject, FFS. He'll say anything to stay relevant.