I’m the opposite! Historical fiction - I’m in. Anything based in the future or with any hint of sci-fi - I’m out.In INSERT YEAR ...
If you have to tell me when it is set I am not interested. If that year is in the future you miiiiight not lose me. But if it's anything other than current day (exception for WW2 stuff) I am not reading it.
Also totally agree about avoiding books that sound “twee”, to me that also tends to mean predictable and cliche.