Amelia Liana #6 Money talks, wealth whispers, Amelia screams..

Status
Thread locked. We start a new thread when they have over 1000 posts, click the blue button to see all threads for this topic and find the latest open thread.
New to Tattle Life? Click "Order Thread by Most Liked Posts" button below to get an idea of what the site is about:
Order Thread by Most Liked Posts

Namima

Top tier comment
 
Reactions: 6
A

adobe_liana

Sibyl Vane said:
Friendly reminder that Iraqi is not Persian

Besides, when it comes to Rick Sopher, he's a Martin Scorsese doppelgänger, only with green eyes.
Click to expand...
oh, wow, thanks for the heads up. As someone who travelled to that region, i wouldn’t have known if you hadn’t pointed it out.

I lumped them together because they’re from the same region of the Middle East and I’m bored of the Iraq/Persian question of her hertiage, she’s claiming both so I’ll take it for now. I’m more keen to learn about her dad’s ethnicity, like is she half Jewish/half middle-eastern?
 

Sibyl Vane

First, help yourself to a chill pill, will you?

Second, as someone who travelled to that region would know, lumping two ethnicities together is as relevant as comparing apples and peaches. She's claiming both because she is both. Unfortunately, what should be her pride and joy is the umbrella she cowers behind so that her judaism is never fully in sight, which is her plain right. That's the world we live in, and I don't expect it to change anytime soon.

And third, nothing. I just thought I'd add a third to appear fancier.


---
Namima said:
Top tier comment
Click to expand...
Ta
 
Reactions: 13
N

nastynastya

tbh, she mentioned several times that she is not religious even though her family is. And she mentioned having falling outs/fights with parents.. total assumption on my behalf but wouldn't be surprised if its because of that.
I can totally imagine her parents not being ok with her choices and her lifestyle and that's a journey for all of them to come in terms and get fully along with each other.
And she genially seems to love spending time with her family nowadays, so I can imagine her joining all the religious celebrations for that purpose alone - to spend time with the family, no matter the occasion.
I think honestly she is very lucky to have a family like this, truly supportive, even if it took a while to come to this place.
 
Reactions: 12
A

adobe_liana

kale-supremacist said:
She's fully Jewish and middle eastern. Both her parents are Jewish from the middle east.
Click to expand...
I’m sorry, I’m confused. Leaving her religion completely out of this, how can she be fully Jewish and fully middle-eastern (ignoring specifics at this moment)? Do you mean she’s part Jew, part middle-eastern?
 
Reactions: 1

kale-supremacist

adobe_liana said:
I’m sorry, I’m confused. Leaving her religion completely out of this, how can she be fully Jewish and fully middle-eastern (ignoring specifics at this moment)? Do you mean she’s part Jew, part middle-eastern?
Click to expand...
I don't know if you're trolling or not
I'm still gonna answer seriously, just in case. She can be fully Jewish and fully middle eastern because they're not mutually exclusive.
There's a lot of different ethnicities in the Middle East:

 
Reactions: 26
H

heyjude1223

So annoyed she got to stay in that amazing hotel and she can probably write it off as a business expense because Pia is there. But like what actual business did she conduct there??
 
Reactions: 8
K

keew13

heyjude1223 said:
So annoyed she got to stay in that amazing hotel and she can probably write it off as a business expense because Pia is there. But like what actual business did she conduct there??
Click to expand...
Feel like it's an ad for the hotel? She didn't declare it... but she seemed to go out of her way to introduce details of the hotel. They even planned the boat trip for them that she seemed to be surprised by.
 
Reactions: 10

Sibyl Vane

Do not worry, she didn't pay a thing, it's yet again another undisclosed ad indeed
Amelia Liarna, serial fraudster.
 
Reactions: 11
N

nastynastya

Does it makes a difference maybe if they actually pay you for it?
Maybe if its just "gifted" all paid vacation, but they don't pay her any money, you don't have to disclose it?
Who knows the regulations on the matter?
 
Reactions: 1
D

Denise0211

nastynastya said:
Does it makes a difference maybe if they actually pay you for it?
Maybe if its just "gifted" all paid vacation, but they don't pay her any money, you don't have to disclose it?
Who knows the regulations on the matter?
Click to expand...
No, in that case she has to write #gifted or #supplied. And since she has followers from the US, she has to adhere to FTC rules even if UK based.
 
Reactions: 4
M

mustbeuni

We go back. We have to deal with apartheid conditions though. And our family home was taken in the 1940s. But we go back.
---
adobe_liana said:
I’m sorry, I’m confused. Leaving her religion completely out of this, how can she be fully Jewish and fully middle-eastern (ignoring specifics at this moment)? Do you mean she’s part Jew, part middle-eastern?
Click to expand...
There are Arab Jews and Christians too.
 
Reactions: 7
A

adobe_liana

I really appreciate this, thank you, honestly, as it’s made me realise the gaps in my knowledge too.

My apologies for going on and on about this, but how can anyone claim to be fully two ethnicities? How can someone claim to be Persian and Jewish (leaving religion out of this) It’s not possible. She must be half Jewish, half Persian, right? So her mum is Persian and her dad is Jewish (assuming, I don’t know). So she’s definitely not fully Jewish and fully Persian.
---
mustbeuni said:
We go back. We have to deal with apartheid conditions though. And our family home was taken in the 1940s. But we go back.
---

There are Arab Jews and Christians too.
Click to expand...
I know, I specified to leave religion out of it.
 
Reactions: 1
M

mustbeuni

Persian is like a country designation, mainly Iran. Jewish is a cultural and religious designation.
 
Reactions: 13

Joannabloggs

If her mum is Jewish she is fully Jewish, it doesn't matter that her father also is Jewish

Whilst Jews originate from Israel from centuries ago, due to persecution, many of us have lived for centuries outside of Israel. There are Jews all over the world which is why we have group names such as sephardi, ashkenazi, mizrahi, Ethiopian etc. Due to my maternal grandmother many generations back, I'm am technically Jewish despite not being religious not having known family in Israel. I'm sure a 23andme would show only a small sliver of middle eastern heritage.

Considering your knowledge of Judaism is severely lacking, I think it's a bit ridiculous you come to tattle, a gossip site rather than reputable history/ news site. Amelia is a fashion influencer not a rabbi nor imam and does not owe anybody her opinion on a deeply complex and upsetting situation, particularly since she may have family directly involved/ hurt/ killed. Palestinians not being able to live freely across Palestine and israel as well as their persecution for years is not Amelias fault and she as with every person should be able to travel without justification. Many people who's heritage is outside of Europe, have family living in countries with human rights issues. I'll be damned if I cannot visit and see my family due to the actions of the govt in which there from. Despite everything that's happened in the past few days, many Israelis do not approve of the Netanyahu nor his govt and were protesting their actions before the attacks
 
Reactions: 26
Status
Thread locked. We start a new thread when they have over 1000 posts, click the blue button to see all threads for this topic and find the latest open thread.
Menu
Log in
Register