Oh boy, I am excited to have found this forum! I've been watching Adam's videos for a while now. I think I discovered him back in 2019 while preparing a trip to Disneyland (for my mom's birthday -- she LOVED it!). None of my friends watch his stuff, though, so until now I haven't had an outlet to discuss it. I have LOTS of thoughts and questions that I've accumulated over the past few years, so I apologize in advance as this post is going to be pretty long (I'll do my best to keep it organized, though).
Personality
Adam is very gregarious and does not appear to be self-conscious at all. That personality type draws people in, and he makes otherwise dry topics (like the backroads "exploring" videos) interesting. I feel like if he had a real job, he'd do well in a role interacting with the public -- he'd be a good concierge or a good salesman (if he could focus enough to learn about whatever product he'd be selling) -- or if he chose to use his powers for evil, he could be a very successful con artist. I have some friends with similar personality types, and they are really fun to be around even though it can sometimes be hard to get a word in edgewise. I wonder how much of his personality is genuine and how much of it is just playing a character for the camera.
He's not as smart as he thinks he is
Adam talks like a 10th grader who got an SAT prep book and just skimmed the vocabulary section. To borrow a phrase I read elsewhere, he sometimes seems like "a dumb person's idea of what a smart person sounds like." He's impulsive and doesn't always think everything through. That can make for interesting content (while I wouldn't personally want to go on a last-minute road trip with minimal planning, I'll admit that it can be fun to watch Adam take one), much of his spur-of-the-moment stuff could be executed so much better with just a little forethought.
But he's also smarter than he seems
Adam understands the YouTube algorithms and ad policies and makes his videos in a way that works best with those. His "walk and talk" videos, for example, could easily be cut down to just a few minutes (heck, the message in most could usually be boiled down to a <240 character tweet), but he drags them out to 30 minutes or more with rambling, distractions, diversions, talking to wildlife, etc to allow for ad placement. His collaborations with other YouTubers help to further expand his already large audience. And he's usually smart enough to show a wide variety of content to appeal to a range of viewers (Don't like the Disney content? He's got you covered with a Route 66 road trip. Don't like those? He's got you covered with a variety of conventions and county fairs.). But lately it seems that he's been focusing on what he likes best (all things Disney!) to the detriment of all the rest.
Finances
I usually don't think about "What does that all cost???" when watching YouTube videos, but Adam's recent subtle (and not-so-subtle) references to money have left me wondering about the financial position of YouTubers in general and Adam specifically. Just how much does he earn from YouTube revenue? How much of that is saved (he's talked about "retirement" at some point), and how much goes right back into content creation (theme park passes, DVC membership, hotel stays, multiple apartment leases, even camera equipment)? The concept of "content creator" being a full-time job is still so new and subject to the whims of YouTube that it's hard to tell what the future might hold, and it makes me wonder what level of future planning he's done.
Self-Addressed Stamped Envelopes
That whole SASE debacle has cracked me up from the start, and I am here for it! His videos see between 50k-100k views in their first few weeks, and his channel has 600k+ subscribers. Even if only 1% of his viewers want a sticker, just stuffing those envelopes will take a considerable amount of time. And, of course, anything heavier than 1 oz requires more than just a single stamp... and anything bulkier than a few pieces of paper will get destroyed in the postal service sorting machinery (I've tried it myself before) if additional packaging isn't included. He claims he "tested" the post office box, but I didn't get the feeling that he actually sent a sticker and pin in that test envelope. Still, I sent him a SASE out of my own curiosity. I will report back if I get it back.
Friends of The Woo
Going back to his outgoing personality, I feel like he is at his best when he has a friend with him in his videos. He's clearly a pretty social guy, so he can really shine when he's able to interact with someone. It's easy to overdo it, though. I recall a video a while back when he went to a theme park (maybe Disneyland?) with a whole gaggle of vloggers, and they were all trying to compete for attention -- it was exhausting to watch. But if it's just him and one other person, the content is a lot more fun to watch. When he's on his own, he devolves into talking to squirrels and spouting off catchphrases, but when he has someone else to bounce things off of, it keeps him on track a bit more.
In particular, I discovered Tampa Jay via Adam's videos. I didn't watch their many baseball videos last year because the only thing I can think of more dull than watching baseball on TV is watching someone watch baseball, but more recently I saw the two of them together somewhere else and found him pretty entertaining. He seems like a "store brand Adam" but I'm finding that, just like with the store brand version of Rice Krispies, I'm starting to prefer him over the original. Oh, and Jay's girlfriend Cris seems sweet and nice, and she doesn't make me feel like I'm going to catch all three hepatitises through my screen.
In all I generally like Adam's videos. At worst they're fun time-wasting content, but at their best they introduce me to new places and things that I otherwise would never have known about. But some of the choices he makes truly baffle me.