In my book if someone turns up asking for help, you help them. To decline someone help because of 'their privilege' is quite repulsive.
If you want to see it that way, then fine. As I’ve already explained, their focus is on a marginalised community who suffer from being left behind. This isn’t an opinion, it’s a statistical fact. Your ‘privilege’ is showing
Focusing on these people isn’t a bad thing. As also mentioned by a previous poster, a person outside of this community is likely to have been given resources on where to find help better serve them. Nobody is left behind this way, it means people are given the opportunity to receive care that best suits their needs.
Life isn’t black and white. Nuance is key. The world isn’t colourblind, nor should it be. Different people have different experiences and needs and care reflects that.
This if someone has experienced dv colour shouldn’t matter. I donate clothes / makeup etc to a local safe house who took anybody in who needed help. You are not privileged in any way if you are experiencing dv and it is just encouraging acceptance of division/resentment in society based on colour.
You wouldn’t be turned away though, they would lead you to somewhere that can help you as they are focusing efforts on black women. Nobody is saying that white women are privileged if they are experiencing DV, but are more likely to be understood in a variety of charity settings as they’ll share the same culture as the people running it. Black women don’t have this. There are often a lot of cultural issues at play that a lot of non black people don’t understand, so SS focuses on this, and due to this wouldn’t necessarily have all the resources to deal with everyone. It’s like wanting to go to black therapist because a white one would be able to sympathise but not necessarily empathise with specific cultural issues you have. It’s not divisive, it’s just being acutely aware of a specific issue. Much like the fact you wouldn’t go to an OBGYN to deal with male issues.