The Archie Battersbee case #11

Status
Thread locked. We start a new thread when they have over 1000 posts, click the blue button to see all threads for this topic and find the latest open thread.
New to Tattle Life? Click "Order Thread by Most Liked Posts" button below to get an idea of what the site is about:
Thanks for the info.

I think if I was in disagreement with medical staff & was questioning their motives in such a major decision - a totally independent expert medical opinion would be the first thing I would search out.
Maybe they did but the other medical opinions weren't ones they wanted to hear.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 7
She is so friggin' thick. Parents don't have 'rights', people have rights. Children are individuals in their own right. Nobody owns their child, from the moment the umbilical cord is cut, the child is an individual human being. Parents take the kid home from the maternity unit because it's their child, but it's not their property to do with what they want. You're only allowed to keep it so long as you don't endanger, neglect or abuse it.
She's going to drag it out as long as she can. I'm not sure she really understands the whole concept of children being individual human beings rather than property or some weird extension of the mother.
 
  • Like
  • Sad
Reactions: 20
The family did have an independent doctor, but the judge was very condescending about him and he hadn’t even bothered to examine Archie or view his scans.
Bit of a pointless opinion then? I’m not surprised it was disregarded.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 8
Does anyone know which interview HD discussed the day prior when his sister intervened in another potential suicide attempt? Or him having been supervised that night? Would be interested to see that as there’s v little / patchy info regarding this.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 3
I keep thinking of all the blood transfusions he received, blood is such a precious resource, it literally can’t be bought.

But as with everything else that they did, the clinicians & nursing teams who cared for Archie did so to the highest possible standards. They supported him completely whilst his mother vilified them on a daily basis & made numerous false accusations.
Absolutely agree. They didn’t deserve any of that, I didn’t mean it to come across as any sort of criticism. It was more a “look at what she got for nothing and is still criticising!” Our NHS need protection because people like her are driving more people towards the privatisation brigade, which given the state of our economy is just not an option.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 15
God, all I can think now is the poor staff having to look after, essentially, a dead boy for so long. It must be really traumatic:(
Yes this was my point in my last post. His necrosis would have been so far advanced from the MRI scan weeks earlier.
 
  • Like
  • Sad
  • Sick
Reactions: 9
Just seen this in Daily Mail comments:

The only urgent review needed is what on earth is happening on tiktok.

324 likes, 12 dislikes

Sometimes I really get an urge to thump people on the head to knock some sense into them (not that I would, as I would almost go to jail and have to change my name).
 
  • Like
  • Haha
Reactions: 21
I've had a look at that painhub thing in tiktok. It's full of self harm and suicidal ideation content. Very dark.
This is the thing - there was a really sad case in London where a 14 year old died by suicide and it was found she'd viewed hundreds of self-harm/suicide ideation type posts on instagram in the lead up. Her parents led a really important campaign to change things on SM.

If the family could accept it was potentially a suicide, this would be a genuine cause they could get behind (if indeed SM was involved).
 
  • Like
Reactions: 10
I still don’t understand why this Ella girl was so prominently there at the hospital, hearings, interviews etc but there was no sign of her boyfriend/ the brother at any of them.

Surely you don’t get all this time off work or whatever for the brother of your short term boyfriend.

I’ve just seen a picture of them leaving one of the court dates and it’s the mother, father and Ella. No sign of the other siblings
 
  • Like
Reactions: 25
please can someone help me understand how he kept ‘breathing’ for over two hours if he was already ‘dead’
I will delete this if someone has already answere but - he didn’t. The medication was stopped. The ventilator was still on at 12. My understanding is they don’t simply “stop” it- it’s taped in, and is gently turned down and removed so would take several minutes. He would not have breathed independently, and his heart would have kept going briefly due to residual blood gases but given up within a few minutes of removal as he couldn’t breathe for himself.
I’m not clued up medically, but how did he survive 15 minutes after the vent was removed?
See above
 
  • Like
Reactions: 16
HD is playing the victim card, and the media/public simply lap it up

So I've just discovered this thread (and previous ones) here on Tattle, after following Archie's case for several weeks now, and seeking an alternative discussion forum to make sense of this case. Something never sat right, having read and listened to HD's account of events, and I smelled bull from the outset. For the record, I have a background (degrees/training) in law, psychiatry, and body language. Putting two and two together - observing HD's body language, comparing her various (conflicting and contradictory) accounts of what happened to Richie, and analyzing court documents - it struck me that HD was at the very least hiding something; and worse, peddling complete falsehoods and fabrications.

This past week, the media have painted HD as a loving yet distraught and grief-stricken mother fighting till the very end for her son. However, the extreme/extraordinary lengths to which the family have gone to "save" Archie - widely praised in the press as determination and devotion - actually looks a lot more like overcompensation.

HD is guilt-ridden - and is probably aware of it on some level (denial and all) - and as such is now going above and beyond to: (a) make it up to Archie, in death (having failed him, in life); and (b) prove to the world (and herself too, in all likelihood) that she is indeed a good mother. Unfortunately for her, those of us with a few brain cells can smell a rat.

No wonder the family swiftly converted to Christianity after finding Archie unconscious (or more accurately, on the brink of death). They are trying to process - and diminish - their guilt. And now, it's pretty obvious they're just exploiting the charity Christian Concern for funds, kudos, and publicity to further their own selfish and warped interests. (It's sad that the well-intentioned albeit gullible and misguided members of the charity have fallen for their ruse without further scrutiny.) Besides, if the family are genuinely Christian, they ought to take comfort in the fact that Archie is now in a better place. Why hold onto his soul in a rotting, mortal body in this world? What - and whose - purpose does this serve?

HD's undignified behavior - intemperate comments about the hospital staff who have worked tirelessly around the clock on what is essentially a lost cause, and accusing judges applying the law of being executioners - is utterly despicable and ultimately conceited. She has weaponized the country's sympathy/grief for Archie against medical professioners who have done their utmost to accommodate her unreasonable and nonsensical demands. How utterly reprehensible and diabolical.

And just think of the astronomical costs and countless hours spent on this singular case (to no avail), when there are scores of patients - who are actually alive - waiting in line for medical attention.

HD may be a few sandwiches short of a picnic, but she is cunning enough to channel victimhood culture to milk the public's sympathy and tug on their heartstrings. This vile woman is a total narcissist; even after Archie was confirmed dead on 6 August 2022 (although we know he died months ago), HD offers the following statement: "I know I’ve done a very good job being Archie’s mum. Based on my own childhood I was very determined to be as good a mother as I can possibly be and I feel like I have done that to the very best of my ability. It’s one of the reasons I am here" (see: https://metro.co.uk/2022/08/06/arch...m-says-she-did-everything-she-could-17137610/). Even in her son's death, HD makes it out to be all about her - as if she's the real victim here - and tries way too hard to convince the world how wonderful a mother she is.

At a point in recent history when trust in authority is at an all-time low, we could really do without (in most cases) competent, hardworking, and dedicated members of the medical and legal professions being undermined – left, right, and centre (and yes, that was a political pun too). Everyone loses when this happens. What an absolute clusterfuck.
 
  • Like
  • Heart
Reactions: 58
I've only recently started following this case because it's all over the news. Where is the father? am i missing something. so far all I see is the mum and some other family friends?
 
  • Like
Reactions: 3
Oh 100%. I do verbatim for most of my notes where I can as definitely helps for those occasions where people try to complain about something that didn't happen the way they state!
I agree. Those notes will be very comprehensive. I’m sure the lead nurse will be checking daily to cover themselves. She doesn’t have any chance of suing the NHS and rightly so.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 12
With regard to time of Archie’s death - 12.15. He had nutrition & meds withdrawn at ten, but it was not until noon they began to withdraw the ventilator. He failed to take a breath because his brain stem was destroyed and couldn’t send a signal to his lungs to breathe. Death was not immediate because it clearly states in the letter given to the family that there would be a period of stepping back for the family before they tried to check for a heartbeat. See 10. & 11.
 

Attachments

  • Like
  • Sad
Reactions: 16
This is the thing - there was a really sad case in London where a 14 year old died by suicide and it was found she'd viewed hundreds of self-harm/suicide ideation type posts on instagram in the lead up. Her parents led a really important campaign to change things on SM.

If the family could accept it was potentially a suicide, this would be a genuine cause they could get behind (if indeed SM was involved).
I don't think anyone goes from a happy, carefree child to depressed and suicidal upon viewing some images though - they'd probably already be in that state of mind to be looking at that stuff.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 14
Absolutely agree. They didn’t deserve any of that, I didn’t mean it to come across as any sort of criticism. It was more a “look at what she got for nothing and is still criticising!” Our NHS need protection because people like her are driving more people towards the privatisation brigade, which given the state of our economy is just not an option.
I didn’t think you sounded critical (at all)! I agree entirely with the point you’re making. I find Hollie Dance’s lack of gratitude - for both the exemplary care Archie received & the fact that it cost her nothing - baffling.

I follow a thread on Reddit for medics, most contributions are by doctors (mostly American but plenty of Brits & other nationalities) but some are also from nurses & pharmacists. I’ve come to recognise that unwarranted criticism, stalking, death threats, harassment of every kind and a complete lack of gratitude seem endemic in every healthcare setting around the world.

In the UK, it’s always the NHS that gets blamed when the outcome is not what people want for their relative, friend etc etc but similar behaviour goes on everywhere. If all those who indulge in NHS-bashing & link this to “socialist healthcare” would care to broaden their horizons, they would find out that people die all over the world, even in the most expensive / world-leading US hospitals (I’d argue much of the NHS care in the teaching hospitals across the UK is right up there). People - notably children - die “before their time” & not everyone will respond to treatment.

I’d be horrified if our NHS was privatised & it worries me that this is already happening, by stealth. I hope reform is possible to stop people like Hollie Dance from being allowed to waste precious resources and prolong unnecessary & futile treatment provided to their relatives.
 
  • Like
  • Heart
Reactions: 19
I've had a look at that painhub thing in tiktok. It's full of self harm and suicidal ideation content. Very dark.
Is this Archie’s? I thought his account was deleted

I still don’t understand why this Ella girl was so prominently there at the hospital, hearings, interviews etc but there was no sign of her boyfriend/ the brother at any of them.

Surely you don’t get all this time off work or whatever for the brother of your short term boyfriend.

I’ve just seen a picture of them leaving one of the court dates and it’s the mother, father and Ella. No sign of the other siblings
I’ve wondered the same
 
  • Like
Reactions: 4
I had a hunch come over me last night. What if the reason she keeps changing the times/story is cause at the time she popped off to do a cheeky line when she was supposed to be watching him like a hawk.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 6
So I've just seen on the news that Hollie is asking for an investigation into the way Archie has been treated. Unbelievable! She's definitely going to try suing the NHS.
 
  • Angry
  • Like
Reactions: 28
Status
Thread locked. We start a new thread when they have over 1000 posts, click the blue button to see all threads for this topic and find the latest open thread.