Lucy Letby Case #6

Status
Thread locked. We start a new thread when they have over 1000 posts, click the blue button to see all threads for this topic and find the latest open thread.
New to Tattle Life? Click "Order Thread by Most Liked Posts" button below to get an idea of what the site is about:
Surely if it was the trust against her it would be a disciplinary rather than a grievance.

Grievance implies behavioural/treatment issues rather than procedural.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 9
Killed what on purpose though? She could be talking about her plants for all we know from that note.
Oh aye cause she would write about the police on her notes because she wilted some Lillies 🥱 cba
 
  • Haha
  • Like
Reactions: 22
I’m just thinking would she have had the balls to make the grievance if she knew she was guilty? Would it not have been better to do as she was told and not kick up a fuss
so I had a member of staff put in a grievance against me when I had to go through disciplinary procedures for gross misconduct with him (he’d violently threatened myself and other members of staff… we had video recorded evidence of this which he knew about) and he claimed in his grievance that I was bullying and harassing him. He was 100% guilty but I think he used the grievance procedure to A) buy time in the investigation into his unacceptable conduct and B) discredit me as a manager

didn’t work, though, but it took 12 months for it all to be resolved. Grievance was thrown out in the end due to lack of evidence but still took a considerable amount of time!!

I guess what I’m getting at is if she’d been in the nhs a while (which I think she had been) and knew the procedures it’s plausible to me that she’d put a grievance in even if she was guilty in order to play the system a bit.
 
  • Like
  • Heart
Reactions: 23
Note to self : next time i inevitably chuck away yet another house plant that was gifted to me that I’ve failed to keep alive because I always forget to water it and so it shrivels up and dies, make sure I don’t write down my feelings of anguish and despair and panic about it just incase I’m ever accused of murder and the police search my house.
 
  • Haha
  • Like
Reactions: 45
Surely if it was the trust against her it would be a disciplinary rather than a grievance.

Grievance implies behavioural/treatment issues rather than procedural.
The grievance at the time was probably complaining about her competency rather than murder - otherwise they wouldn’t keep her on the team and move her to a non clinical role. A grievance can lead to a disciplinary it’s the first stage of investigating the complaint. It’s important a complaint and allegation is investigated before being disciplined.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 7
so I had a member of staff put in a grievance against me when I had to go through disciplinary procedures for gross misconduct with him (he’d violently threatened myself and other members of staff… we had video recorded evidence of this which he knew about) and he claimed in his grievance that I was bullying and harassing him. He was 100% guilty but I think he used the grievance procedure to A) buy time in the investigation into his unacceptable conduct and B) discredit me as a manager

didn’t work, though, but it took 12 months for it all to be resolved. Grievance was thrown out in the end due to lack of evidence but still took a considerable amount of time!!

I guess what I’m getting at is if she’d been in the nhs a while (which I think she had been) and knew the procedures it’s plausible to me that she’d put a grievance in even if she was guilty in order to play the system a bit.
Sorry you had to go through that, that sounds tit. Maybe she thought it would make them back down against her if she kicked up a big enough fuss? It is so hard to comprehend it’s just such big accusations made about her that I believe they have had to come from somewhere.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 9
Note to self : next time i inevitably chuck away yet another house plant that was gifted to me that I’ve failed to keep alive because I always forget to water it and so it shrivels up and dies, make sure I don’t write down my feelings of anguish and despair and panic about it just incase I’m ever accused of murder and the police search my house.
I’d like to confess here that I am a prolific plant murderer. You may use this evidence against me in court. I am very good at keeping human beings alive but plants not so much.
 
  • Haha
  • Like
Reactions: 23
i think it’s these explanations from Prof Hindmarsh

1. the same bag was transferred over the line
2. The replacement stock bag was contaminated
3. Some part of the giving set was contaminated by insulin from first bag and continued to flow through even with new non-contaminated bag

but it sounds like 1 and 2 are going to be ruled out because the first bag wasn’t transferred to the new line, and the problems with the baby started before the second bag was put in place.

I don’t recall if they said where bag 2 came from because I do remember they said there were stock bags in the fridge. So I suppose it’s possible both bags could have been contaminated separately but that hasn’t been mentioned so maybe they ruled that out somehow.

View attachment 1653427
Thank you. A nurse upthread explained TPN procedures. She said if the TPN bag was taken down it would be replaced with an ordinary fluid IV bag. She said that the babies blood would be tested daily and a new TPN bag would be made by pharmacy depending on blood results.
If that’s the case then the second bag could be just a standard IV bag from the fridge. Maybe?
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: 5
Note to self : next time i inevitably chuck away yet another house plant that was gifted to me that I’ve failed to keep alive because I always forget to water it and so it shrivels up and dies, make sure I don’t write down my feelings of anguish and despair and panic about it just incase I’m ever accused of murder and the police search my house.
Have you ever wondered if you are evil because of all the shrivelled up plants in your bin?
 
  • Haha
  • Like
Reactions: 16
Surely if it was the trust against her it would be a disciplinary rather than a grievance.

Grievance implies behavioural/treatment issues rather than procedural.
Her note did state “police forget slander , discrimination, victimisation” - I took that as she thinks the police are only concerned with what she has been accused of and they have forgotten all about the slander, victimisation and discrimination she is has experienced. So perhaps she had put in a grievance complaint 🤔. I guess the question is, was this just because of the allegations or was she always a target so to speak. I think the former she would know how to play the system I expect, but who knows.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 12
Sorry you had to go through that, that sounds tit. Maybe she thought it would make them back down against her if she kicked up a big enough fuss? It is so hard to comprehend it’s just such big accusations made about her that I believe they have had to come from somewhere.
Honestly it was pretty tit at the time. During that time I found out I was pregnant as well so I was having to deal with all that drama whilst growing a baby! I’m very fortunate my partner is an obstetrician so I got constant reassurance in terms of my health worries!!

Perhaps she thought they’d pay her off to go away quietly. Unfortunately that does happen quite often… but I doubt in the case of murder!! Perhaps she thought they didn’t have enough evidence to link her to so many deaths so therefore complaining about her ‘ill-treatment’ by management might scare them into paying her to resign and sign an NDA or something.

I’m just speculating, of course, until we get more information on the matter! But unfortunately for me as an nhs manager I’m quite experienced in grievance procedures!!
 
  • Like
  • Heart
Reactions: 15
I don’t think we know anything about her childhood yet do we? I think people presume because her parents are still together and holding hands that she must have had a good upbringing but it means bugger all (not suggesting anything about her parents personally just that we literally have no idea).
My parents are still together and married 40+ years but all us children are ducked up emotionally due to my mothers controlling narcissistic behaviour and my fathers enabling of it. Not to say any of us are murderers or committing crimes but having married parents means nothing about the emotionally wellbeing of their children.
Fully agree.
I had awful childhood even if my family looks so "normal" from outside. My father is functional alcoholic, he used abuse towards me and my mother and my mother never really had the balls to leave him. They still together- 36y of marriage.
I moved home ad soon as I finished high school.
 
  • Like
  • Heart
Reactions: 15
Thank you. A nurse upthread explained TPN procedures. She said if the TPN bag was taken down it would be replaced with an ordinary fluid IV bag. She said that the babies blood would be tested daily and a new bag would be made by pharmacy depending on blood results.
If that’s the case then the second bag could be just a standard IV bag from the fridge. Maybe?
this is the bit from the reporting but I’m a bit unclear about where the second bag came from.

i *think* this is saying that TPN bag 1 was taken off temporarily at 11am

but the next TPN bag wasn’t delivered until 4pm.

So between 11am-4pm it could only be TPN bag 1 or a stock bag. But Lucy wasn’t on shift at this point. If it was the stock bag then that could easily have been contaminated anyway as it was stored in the fridge with the insulin.

7DF9D2E9-2B00-47F2-A98D-3041ED323235.jpeg
 
  • Like
Reactions: 5
Honestly it was pretty tit at the time. During that time I found out I was pregnant as well so I was having to deal with all that drama whilst growing a baby! I’m very fortunate my partner is an obstetrician so I got constant reassurance in terms of my health worries!!

Perhaps she thought they’d pay her off to go away quietly. Unfortunately that does happen quite often… but I doubt in the case of murder!! Perhaps she thought they didn’t have enough evidence to link her to so many deaths so therefore complaining about her ‘ill-treatment’ by management might scare them into paying her to resign and sign an NDA or something.

I’m just speculating, of course, until we get more information on the matter! But unfortunately for me as an nhs manager I’m quite experienced in grievance procedures!!
I’m wondering if she was going to claim bullying etc which I don’t doubt as I know bullying with in NHS is real but surely theres a line between bullying and accused of murdering babies🤔
 
  • Like
Reactions: 3
Thank you. A nurse upthread explained TPN procedures. She said if the TPN bag was taken down it would be replaced with an ordinary fluid IV bag. She said that the babies blood would be tested daily and a new TPN bag would be made by pharmacy depending on blood results.
If that’s the case then the second bag could be just a standard IV bag from the fridge. Maybe?
One question I have is that I understand bags were changed but what about the tubes that go to the baby. At what point do the bags connect to the babies feed/cannula tubes?

I'm not sure if you can 'taint' a tube with insulin and if you’ve injected it into the babies feed/cannula tube you’ve made a hole that would be evidenced BUT if the bag was injected with insulin and you change the bag would the tube still cause contamination problems?

hope that makes sense
 
  • Like
Reactions: 3
I’m wondering if she was going to claim bullying etc which I don’t doubt as I know bullying with in NHS is real but surely theres a line between bullying and accused of murdering babies🤔
I think I’d need to see a proper timeline really and more details of the grievances. It’s plausible that the stuff getting back to her at the beginning was surrounding her being incompetent so that could be why she got angry and potentially went down the “I’m being bullied” route. Perhaps she thought she wouldn’t get caught if she didn’t know the full extent of the picture they were building up to hand over to the police. If she’s genuinely a serial killer there’s got to be something not quite there in her brain to begin with. Maybe she was actually a bit of a narcissist?
 
  • Like
Reactions: 7
The grievance at the time was probably complaining about her competency rather than murder - otherwise they wouldn’t keep her on the team and move her to a non clinical role. A grievance can lead to a disciplinary it’s the first stage of investigating the complaint. It’s important a complaint and allegation is investigated before being disciplined.
Any question of her competency wouldn’t fall under any sort of grievance procedures though… it would fall under performance management guidelines.

Might be the terminology but I have never heard first stage investigations into conduct or fact finding right up until suspension ever called a grievance - it’s always just been an investigation and or normal performance management and only when the PM isn’t working or there’s evidence of misconduct agreed by HR that it would formalise to disciplinary proceedings.

A grievance is usually an individual feeling aggrieved about something rather than a trust or firm taking action to performance manage an incompetent member of staff.

Maybe just different terminology people use but I’ve worked across private and public sector for over 20 years in various management capacities and I’ve never heard any sort of performance management called a grievance and have only ever heard it in the context of an individual taking a grievance against another individual or management structure where they feel they’ve been treated unfairly.

That’s why I’d made the assumption that her grievance was against management within her trust presumably because she’d been challenged and/or heard the allegations made against her.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 13
Status
Thread locked. We start a new thread when they have over 1000 posts, click the blue button to see all threads for this topic and find the latest open thread.