I‘m sorry, that’s on me, I wasn’t talking about Lizzie particauly although I’ve worded it badly so it looks like I was. I did genuinely mean I understand why she’s looking, I should have left a gap for the next sentence.
Monique, in my opinion, had a very sad ending as she never stop pursuing treatment. Her pain was never controlled, and she never accepted her fate. I feel that Lizzie is much more realistic about her prognosis and destinyDoctors have a duty of care and to do no harm, that’s why treatment is stopped. I agree totally with knowing when to say enough. We all die and sadly some die younger than others. I think Lizzie having a bit of hope is wonderful, however I don’t think she’s buried her head in the sand, I think she’s aware this could be the end of options. I remember poor Monique in hospital still searching for treatment, when in reality I feel being in hospice would have been so much better for her. I guess ultimately people have to handle it however they are able to.
It was awfulMonique, in my opinion, had a very sad ending as she never stop pursuing treatment. Her pain was never controlled, and she never accepted her fate. I feel that Lizzie is much more realistic about her prognosis and destiny
When you've still got most of your life left to life with children keeping focused and not giving up is your priority (well it is mine) I have stage 4 incurable cancer. I live my life every 3 months knowing one day I could get that result of it's progressed meaning a change of treatment and worse side effects and another line I've had to cross out and I'm slowly moving down that ladder of being told there's no more treatments left. Any infection is worrying because of our immune systems being shot to put. We fight to stay alive each day that sometimes we know when the time to give up. I'm not saying Lizzi should give up I'm just saying that sometimes we know ourselves when to stop!I’m going to disagree, I think giving up is actually a very valid thing to choose. Our society frames life/death as a battle and couches it in language like ‘battle’ ‘fight’ ‘give up’ etc but actually, they co-exist.
I think they valuing of existence over everything means we push and push to keep people alive when maybe we shouldn’t.
Lizzy is currently well, I understand feeling the need to extend that. But there are plenty of times where treatments cause weakness which cause infection which then get treated but can’t be overcome fully and leave the person battling horrific infections alongside their cancer. Sometimes it’s better to say “I’ll have the rest of my days fairly well till the time comes” than “I’ll spend my time on IV antibiotics, sometimes not lucid because the infection keeps screwing my blood chemistry, mostly tired and confused about what’s happening to me”
I‘m not saying either option is wrong or right, I’m not having to make that decision so it’s fine for me sit here saying that stuff. But i also think valuing our continued existence over limited time actually living sometimes does us a massive disservice.
I agree with this. I think there is a fine line between wanting to stay alive (or wanting a loved one to stay alive) and pursuing fruitless treatments; raising GFM money to line the pockets of crooks, for example.I’m going to disagree, I think giving up is actually a very valid thing to choose. Our society frames life/death as a battle and couches it in language like ‘battle’ ‘fight’ ‘give up’ etc but actually, they co-exist.
I think they valuing of existence over everything means we push and push to keep people alive when maybe we shouldn’t.
What a moving video, especially the end. She seemed like a lovely lady, thanks for sharing.I found this video to be really powerful, apologies if this has been shared before. Donna Mason lived in a state in America that has assisted suicide. She had terminal pancreatic cancer and this is her last video before taking the solution:
The assisted suicide debate is interesting to me. From everyone’s experience here and people I know in real life, cancer takes so much from you that maybe being able to choose exactly when you go gives you the chance to make one last decision
This was so moving, she was incredibly brave. My dad had a horrific death from pancreatic cancer, you wouldn’t let an animal suffer that way. Had this solution been offered to him he’d have ripped it out of their hands. We need to do better really & let people make an informed choice if that’s what they truly want.I found this video to be really powerful, apologies if this has been shared before. Donna Mason lived in a state in America that has assisted suicide. She had terminal pancreatic cancer and this is her last video before taking the solution:
The assisted suicide debate is interesting to me. From everyone’s experience here and people I know in real life, cancer takes so much from you that maybe being able to choose exactly when you go gives you the chance to make one last decision
I’m so sorry to hear about your Dad. The loss alone is awful without watching loved ones suffer. I completely agree, the whole assisted suicide issue needs a huge rethink and I think whenever possible, the option should be given. This lady had the opportunity to see everyone she wanted to, rehomed her horse and picked the time to take the solution in her own time. That’s priceless when far too many people are dying in horrific painThis was so moving, she was incredibly brave. My dad had a horrific death from pancreatic cancer, you wouldn’t let an animal suffer that way. Had this solution been offered to him he’d have ripped it out of their hands. We need to do better really & let people make an informed choice if that’s what they truly want.
Thank you @LennyI’m so sorry to hear about your Dad. The loss alone is awful without watching loved ones suffer. I completely agree, the whole assisted suicide issue needs a huge rethink and I think whenever possible, the option should be given. This lady had the opportunity to see everyone she wanted to, rehomed her horse and picked the time to take the solution in her own time. That’s priceless when far too many people are dying in horrific pain![]()
Agreed, also thisOn this subject, one of the most interesting and engaging books I ever read.
View attachment 3013932