There was a survey years ago about what people thought was fiction and what was real.
A small, but very real percent of people surveyed thought that -
- the Titanic a fictional story
- War Of The Worlds really happened
- the Battle Of Helms Deep was a real historical event
This topic is fascinating. And I agree that fictional battle names can sound realistic, eg Culloden, Marston Moor, Stamford Bridge battles were all real but Helms Deep sounds like it just about could be, if a bit of a stretch. The fact that most historical battles are the actual places where they happened is a big giveaway I guess.
What concerns me more about that list of what people think was real is the lack of education behind this. It shocks me tbh that a person would reach young adulthood without their parents, teachers, grandparents (or just their own natural curiosity to look it up) telling them the Titanic sank in 1912 and there have been several subsequent feature films re-imagining its tragic story. It's such a massive event in British history and subsequent popular culture, especially James Cameron's 1997 film.
A different case with HG Wells' War of the Worlds, as this time it isn't a real event but is a renowned classic of English literature. If you reach adulthood without having come across one of the film or radio versions, or not having read the novel, but then you do see a film version, surely then that sparks the looking it up, discovering its literary origins, or if you're still at school, asking again teachers, parents, family, about it? The fact it might feel real means it's great story-telling, and great filmmaking, but if the context around it is missing then research is needed. Better still read the novel and understand it's just that, a novel. Gobsmacking tbh that people don't bother to seek out context, look up to find the writers of screenplays and films, find out if it's based on real events or use common sense when it's the sci-fi genre. The internet can be a wonderful thing and it's so much easier now to look things up/check facts, compared to when you had to go to a library and pore over hefty encyclopaedias, etc. But readily accessible online information isn't always reliable as we well know on this thread, and its constant availability doesn't necessarily make people more discerning or informed.