Taylor Swift #9 We did it, Joe

[Em28_]

How is everyone not choosing a perfectly good heart at the worst debut song?

Debut - perfectly good heart
Fearless - hey Stephen
Speak now - superman
Red - girl at home
1989 - shake it off
Reputation - so it goes
Lover - me or you need to calm down
Folklore - epiphany
Evermore - closure
Midnights - vigilante tit

I’m sorry — A Perfectly Good Heart, So It Goes AND closure!? also whoever put Mary’s Song as their least favourite, W H A T!?

 

[honkytonkcat]

You had me until “this love”, I don’t understand it’s the best on the album

ha I’m so sorry, I do actually like it but it’s probably my least listened to on the album. It was so hard to pick!

 

[Lilykins]

Debut - couldn’t pick any of them!
Fearless - come in with the rain
Speak Now - Superman
Red - Forever Winter (TV version)
1989 - How You Get the girl (honestly probably my least fave Taylor song ever)
Rep - End Game (but actually wouldn’t take or skip any as actually think it’s one of her most cohesive albums to date).
Lover - it’s nice to have a friend/false god (couldn’t decide and don’t care for either of them equally)
Folklore - mirrorball
Evermore - Dorothea
Midnights - Glitch/Dear Reader/Vigilante tit/mastermind (lol quite a lot from midnights 🫢)

 

[Don't Drink the Kool Aid]

Skipping Debut through Red because Idk them well enough to have least faves

1989 - I Know Places
Reputation - This Is Why We Can't Have Nice Things
Lover - It's Nice To Have A Friend
Folklore - seven
Evermore - cowboy like me
Midnights - Labyrinth (though tbh everything between Bejeweled and The Great War is a skip for me (I have the 3am Edition))

 

[secretyoutubelover]

the lakes is the big shock for me. One of Taylor’s most beautiful songs imo!!

 

[Folkevermore]

the lakes is the big shock for me. One of Taylor’s most beautiful songs imo!!

There’s a couple of lines in the song that just ruin it in my opinion

 

[jedwad87]

Showing my age here but does anyone remember the rumour that Forever Winter is about Taylor’s high school friend Jeff Lang who sadly passed I believe in 2010? For me there are some songs of hers that are too emotional to rank/listen to so they’re not my faves - forever winter, Ronan, SYGB, Marjorie, Never Grow Up, even Epiphany sometimes. They’re beautifully written and great songs I just cry every time lol.

 

[gossipgal21]

Debut - The Outside
Fearless - Superstar
Speak Now - I love them alllll but story of us or superman if I had to pick
Red - Starlight
1989 - Bad Blood
Rep - End Game
Lover - Me!
Folklore - seven
Evermore - ivy
Midnights - Snow on the Beach

I feel like seven, ivy and SOTB will be shockers but I’ve just never warmed up to them

I don’t love Seven either! Almost put it on the list.

But Ivy, wtf

 

[secretyoutubelover]

There’s a couple of lines in the song that just ruin it in my opinion

Which ones?

 

[jobackhorsewoman]

Debut: A Perfectly Good Heart
Fearless: The Best Day
Speak Now: Never Grow Up
Red: Sad Beautiful Tragic
1989 - Welcome to New York (my least fave song of hers ever I think)
Reputation - Look What You Made Me Do
Lover - It’s Nice to Have a Friend
Folklore - hoax (bit boring imho)
Evermore - closure (also a bit boring imho)
Midnights - Sweet Nothing (unpopular opinion?)

 

[dizmal]

There’s a couple of lines in the song that just ruin it in my opinion

Yes. It has some clunkers (and it's boring)

 

[tellmewhy]

I’m surprised only one person has Epiphany down as their worst Folklore song, its soo boring imo, I skip every time

I think it’s lovely but so sad. Really broke my heart listening to it in covid and thinking of all the nurses etc

 

[Folkevermore]

Which ones?

“Hunters with cell phones” and “a red rose grew up out of ice frozen ground with no one around to tweet it”

 

[tellmewhy]

Which ones?

The tweet it line for me. I love the song but just ruins it a bit

 

[Folkevermore]

I think it’s lovely but so sad. Really broke my heart listening to it in covid and thinking of all the nurses etc

Yeah, it’s my least favourite but not a bad song, and the intro is far too long. It’s just too depressing to listen to regularly

 

[jobackhorsewoman]

Debut - The Outside
Fearless - Superstar
Speak Now - I love them alllll but story of us or superman if I had to pick
Red - Starlight
1989 - Bad Blood
Rep - End Game
Lover - Me!
Folklore - seven
Evermore - ivy
Midnights - Snow on the Beach

I feel like seven, ivy and SOTB will be shockers but I’ve just never warmed up to them

I hate Bad Blood too. Almost as much as Welcome To New York.

Snow On The Beach is also an instant skip for me.

Love End Game though!!

 

[emerald]

The Hey Stephens are hurting my feelings I think it's a really cute song!

 

[QueenBW]

Debut - A Perfectly Good Heart. I can't even remember it, off the top of my head.
Fearless - Change
Speak Now - Innocent
Red - Sad Beautiful Tragic
1989 - How You Get The Girl
Reputation - .... Ready for it?
Lover - London Boy
Folklore - Epiphany
Evermore - Cowboy Like Me
Midnights - Glitch

 

[grannypants]

Okay who are the 10 people who voted for Its Nice To Have A Friend as their least favourite song in the poll? Over CLOSURE?? I just wanna talk guys

I bleeping hate closure lol

my least favourite tracks

Debut - A Perfectly Good Heart
Fearless - Love Story
Speak Now - Innocent
Red - Stay Stay Stay
1989 - All You Had To Do Was Stay
Rep - Look What You Made Me Do
Lover - You Need To Calm Down
Folklore - Mad Woman
Evermore - CLOSURE LOL ITS SO BAD
Midnights - Glitch

Ive come to the conclusion that my least favourite are her most over-produced, heavily poppy songs. That’s probably why I don’t like 1989

 

[tellmewhy]

I’m enjoying this version of the thread a lot more we should have a daily question like this