Gender Discussions #2

Status
Thread locked. We start a new thread when they have over 1000 posts, click the blue button to see all threads for this topic and find the latest open thread.
New to Tattle Life? Click "Order Thread by Most Liked Posts" button below to get an idea of what the site is about:
There's even a derogatory word for trans (transsexual) people who believe you can't be trans without gender dysphoria. The term is "truscum" 🙄
 
  • Like
Reactions: 8
Must be a slow day in lockdown for these morons who feel the need to publicly denounce someone’s work before actually checking it out for themselves. All they see is a controversial headline and a way to increase their likes and followers. Nothing better to talk about?

Also, on the subject of JKR’s new book, I wonder why there wasn’t the same uproar over Thomas Harris’ novel, “Silence of the Lambs” when it also featured a serial killer who dressed as a woman (and made a “woman suit” from the skins of his female victims). Oh that’s right, because it was published in the 80’s and the “woke” generation didn’t exist then. 🙄
 
  • Like
Reactions: 16
Must be a slow day in lockdown for these morons who feel the need to publicly denounce someone’s work before actually checking it out for themselves. All they see is a controversial headline and a way to increase their likes and followers. Nothing better to talk about?

Also, on the subject of JKR’s new book, I wonder why there wasn’t the same uproar over Thomas Harris’ novel, “Silence of the Lambs” when it also featured a serial killer who dressed as a woman (and made a “woman suit” from the skins of his female victims). Oh that’s right, because it was published in the 80’s and the “woke” generation didn’t exist then. 🙄
It’s so annoying. And Carrie is supposed to be an author herself. Aren’t authors supposed to read books first before judging the book. As the saying goes, NEVER JUDGE A BOOK BY ITS COVER! Clearly Carrie can’t even read the book. She hasn’t made any comment about other books like silence of the lambs. And I bet soon she will post any tweet saying some bull about her being bullied and getting hate
 
  • Like
Reactions: 12

This tit is being blown way out of proportion. No one cares about Stephen King and him writing about literal children being involved in an orgy.

Edit; for some reason by spoiler tag isn’t showing up but basically the cross dressing bloke isn’t the only suspect in her book from the sounds of it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 15
Yes, I believe these days transgender is the word used regardless of whether someone MTF or FTM has had surgery. But basically someone choosing to live as/identify as the opposite 'gender'. As per some googling, I understand the distinction used to be that if you got surgery you were Transsexual. So the very early people to do so still use that world (and are, obviously, of an older gen) and younger TRAs see it as a bit perjorative these days?

Then I think Transvestite is someone who just enjoys dressing up as the opposite sex. Grayson Perry refers to himself as a transvestite. See also: Rocky Horror Picture Show.

It’s so annoying. And Carrie is supposed to be an author herself. Aren’t authors supposed to read books first before judging the book. As the saying goes, NEVER JUDGE A BOOK BY ITS COVER! Clearly Carrie can’t even read the book. She hasn’t made any comment about other books like silence of the lambs. And I bet soon she will post any tweet saying some bull about her being bullied and getting hate
oops! I've judged her books by their covers and decided to definitely not read them. :LOL:
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: 3
It’s so annoying. And Carrie is supposed to be an author herself. Aren’t authors supposed to read books first before judging the book. As the saying goes, NEVER JUDGE A BOOK BY ITS COVER! Clearly Carrie can’t even read the book. She hasn’t made any comment about other books like silence of the lambs. And I bet soon she will post any tweet saying some bull about her being bullied and getting hate
It's really irritating me the number of people judging this book without reading it! There are conflicting reviews, how can you have an opinion about it when you haven't read it yourself. It's sheer stupidity. Also not sure how people on the TRA side don't think it's a slippery slope from here, making judgements about people and their books based on hearsay alone, and all this talk of book burning. And we're meant to think this is progressive?

01B68BC6-1D17-4B91-9FD2-A17F32ABA5D4.jpeg

Already seeing other trans people turn on her on Twitter for this.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: 10
Look at Carrie fletcher starting a witch hunt on JK Rowling on a book she hasn’t even read. She annoys me
Ok I’m so confused about this book issue. I thought the potential serial killer was transvestite, which I think isn’t transgender? I’m honestly confused by the terms transvestite and transgender because I’ve read contradictory things.
Even if the serial killer was a member of the trans community, it doesn’t mean it puts them at grave risk? Wouldn’t this excessive negative publicity actually put the community at more risk? I don’t know.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 6
Ok I’m so confused about this book issue. I thought the potential serial killer was transvestite, which I think isn’t transgender? I’m honestly confused by the terms transvestite and transgender because I’ve read contradictory things.
Even if the serial killer was a member of the trans community, it doesn’t mean it puts them at grave risk? Wouldn’t this excessive negative publicity actually put the community at more risk? I don’t know.
Another thought I have is what about the millions of books where males kill males, where is the outrage for a fictional loss of life then?! Same for women killing women in a book? Where is the outrage for all crime books? Why is it only an outrage when the suspect is a cross dresser?! Where is the outrage for a male character going on a serial kill hunt killing several women? Where is the outrage and boycotting on books and hatred for the author then?! You killlllled lots of people in that book you wrote and that's a hatecrime. Ffs.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 11
This is a provisional opinion as I haven’t read the book so I’m going solely by what I’ve seen others say about it: but I don’t see what this has to do with the trans community at all, yet. Seems like the character everyone is complaining about is a transvestite - so crucially, not transgender at all - but a man who dresses up as a woman to prey on women. So this seems to me like it’s more of a comment on the dangers of self ID and not about anything to do with transgenderism? But interestingly, trans people who have (claimed to have) read the book are saying this is still offensive to them. Yet I thought transgender people aren’t just ‘men in dresses’ so why would they even think this applies to them? Pretty telling if you ask me. Anyway could be wrong as I’ve not read it but it doesn’t sound like that character is even transgender 🤷🏻‍♀️
 
  • Like
Reactions: 10
TRAs love to twist things to suit their agenda. One minute they'll screech "trans is not just about men in dresses, there's more to it than that!" The next minute: "JR Rowling has a book and there is a man wearing a dress who is a murder suspect, this is a DIRECT ATTACK and LITERAL VIOLENCE against the trans community"

It's embarrassing how they tie themselves up in knots and anyone with an ounce of critical thinking can see through it
 
  • Like
Reactions: 13
20 minutes, they gave the debate. It’s terrifying.

I had a referral to a gynaecologist recently. I chose one with a female name, then Googled the crap out of her to try to establish, er, how long she’d had that name. (Because I wanted a woman specialist, not somebody who simply likes to dress like one.)
 
  • Like
Reactions: 16
Status
Thread locked. We start a new thread when they have over 1000 posts, click the blue button to see all threads for this topic and find the latest open thread.