ohdearyme1029
Well-known member
I feel mean saying it, but if Carrie had taken better care of herself and looked more like her old self, Joel would still be left on read. He is a living version of one of her big ugly coats- something she uses to cover up her insecurities. I don't WANT to wear nice clothes because I'mDisregarding the absolutely redundant Shrek/Magic Mike argument (you cannot compare box office success of films for entirely different audiences to make a point)
Carrie forgets we know her dating history (nobody's fault but her own) so we *know* John isn't her type. Has never been her type. Her previous boyfriends don't all look the same, I get that - but none of them look like John.