I know what you mean. Jilly Cooper heroines were the same. I think it gives an insight into the authors own body hang ups .
I know what you mean. Jilly Cooper heroines were the same. I think it gives an insight into the authors own body hang ups .I think Marian Keyes writes very well - the books are so readable and often deeper than they would appear at first glance. I do have a problem with them though. So many times the main female character starts off as dissatisfied with her appearance. She is usually pretty but plump. She then goes through an upheaval - eg partner leaves her, depression - and she loses weight. She can then fit into fabulous new clothes and everyone is amazed at how attractive and sexy she is. I've read this in several of her books and it really seems so unnecessary and a bit of a downer tbh.
Marian Keyes is great!I think Marian Keyes writes very well - the books are so readable and often deeper than they would appear at first glance. I do have a problem with them though. So many times the main female character starts off as dissatisfied with her appearance. She is usually pretty but plump. She then goes through an upheaval - eg partner leaves her, depression - and she loses weight. She can then fit into fabulous new clothes and everyone is amazed at how attractive and sexy she is. I've read this in several of her books and it really seems so unnecessary and a bit of a downer tbh.
My problem with chick lit is that they all follow the same format. It's either 1) boy meets girl they fall in love have an argument or similar they hate each other for a bit then it all ends well OR 2) boy meets girl they hate each other but eventually fall in love something happens to make each other hate each other for a bit and it all ends well.I wouldn’t be a big fan of Marian Keyes. I think maybe because I’m Irish and expect her characters to be more relatable to me, if that makes sense? I’ve only read a couple of her books but I’ve always thought I don’t know anyone like this character! I suppose it’s a bit like Londoners not liking Eastenders
One thing I will say though is that I hate book snobbery! I hate books being dismissed as only chic lit or only YA ... what does it matter? If you’re reading it and enjoying it, then who cares?! We can learn so much through reading, even if it is “only chit lit”. It’s got to be better for us than sitting in front of a TV or gaming all night.
I’ll get down off my soap box now
suppose it's like a Hallmark film in a bookOne of the things that turned me off what I call “older woman chick lit” is it’s so formulaic you can feel like you’re reading the same story over and over. It’s usually middle aged lady with a lovely home, lovely children flown the nest, lovely hubby and quirky single best friend suddenly finds her life turned upside down due to either her husband dying, leaving her or losing all their money. After a few chapters of crying/struggling, quirky friend usually says something like “but Daphne, you’re a wonderful cook, why not set up your own business cooking for dinner parties/baking cakes OR the heroine has been painting or making pots for years, thinking she was no good, then suddenly gets discovered and her work sells for thousands. Along the way she will usually acquire a cute dog or cat, a run down but charming cottage that she revamps on a shoestring and of course an incredibly attractive new man because OF COURSE our heroine may be any age between 45 and 65 but she does not look it being slim, gorgeous, stylish.
I know it’s nice to escape into fantasy but I wish there was some originality
Yes! That’s exactly it.suppose it's like a Hallmark film in a book
I love the Walsh sisters. Angels is one of my favesSilly question but have you read any by Marian Keyes? I hate the way she's written off as "just" a chick lit author but she's bloody good! The Walsh sisters are great if you're looking for a connection with characters. Rachel's Holiday & Anybody Out There? are two of my favourites from that series. You don't really need to read them in order either.
This Charming Man is also really, really good too. I started re-reading her books when lockdown kicked in last March as a comfort blanket.
I finished watching the series on Netflix last night and couldn't believe the last episode. I'd normally read the book before watching the movie /series and this is the first time I've done the reverse. I have the book on my kindle and am hoping that it's better and draws a proper conclusion.I’m reading Firefly Lane at the moment, after watching the Netflix series. I’m really enjoying it!
I love getting to properly know the characters and feeling an emotional connection to them.
can anyone recommend anything similar? Maybe a series of books?
ive been trying to get back into reading and haven’t connected to many books that I’ve been reading, I think because I just don’t care about the characters, I don’t care what happens to them! I finished the guest list last week and didn’t care about any of the characters at all.
I apologise. In my haste to warn you off a really poorly written book, I made a big mistake!!Can I save you all the tedious task of reading The Housewarming? It didn't grip me at all, story was long and drawn out, over use of character's names drove me mad and the ending was such a let down. I stayed up late last night to finish it and the only positive I can draw from is that it was free on Prime and I didn't waste any money. It got a generous 2 stars from me. Now I'm off to find a good book to cleanse my mind
I've read that and enjoyed it. But it's quite an emotional read. I would say stick with it. Let us know what you think if you finish it.I’ve just started The Salt Path as I have to lead a book group discussion on it. I’m reserving judgement but I’m not loving it right now.
Will do! The thing that is jarring me right now is all the Simon Armitage stuff. Moth looks nothing like Simon.I've read that and enjoyed it. But it's quite an emotional read. I would say stick with it. Let us know what you think if you finish it.
Agreed. #shouldhavegonetospecsaversWill do! The thing that is jarring me right now is all the Simon Armitage stuff. Moth looks nothing like Simon.
Who is magpies by?Just finished Behind Her Eyes and quite enjoyed it, I called the first reveal but not the second. Downloaded another of her books so hopefully the writing is consistent.
Read Magpies a long time ago and it messed me up, something about the psychological warfare in your own home hit a nerve. It still makes me feel sick when I think about it too long.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?