Well technicality Caroline Flack was presenting it well into her late 30s and I never thought of her as too old. But Amy is not remotely cool in any way and she has absolutely zero charisma to pull any sort of podcast off. I still fail to see why they chose her for it. It makes love island look like a joke. And I agree with you as well, love island has definitely passed its peak.Shes too old and frumpy for the podcast. Im a little older than her but i think the last series i watched/had any interest in was probably the series she was in (I thought she was a sad dick in that too). Ive grown out of it and it just seems full of kids to me now. She must seem so old for anyone that even listens.