We are the same, water and milk suits him fine and I do think, he doesn’t know what he’s missing, if he’s never had it except a sip or something from my cup but each to their own in that department. I just think it’s some damage limitation, fast food, juice and a baby bottle? Everything in moderation, not just every bad thing thrust at him!It’s what we’ve always used too. Mine is 2.5. We’ve never given him squash either but that’s just our decision