I wasn’t thinking that Ella was trying to sexualise Hosanna, more than she is trying to make a look like a woman, rather than a child, or as near to it as she can…because of this obsession of making them be mature instead of just letting them act like children. It’s a bit of contrast really, because she has a husband who dresses like a child, and she doesn’t try to do anything to rectify that.
Also, I’m not sure many families have reached this stage yet, but when YouTube children reach adulthood…is there a chance they could sue their parents for exploitation? The Grimwade’s in particular I’m thinking of, because firstly, if they finish education without qualifications or struggling to get some basic gcse, they could claim that was because their schooling wasn’t regulated. When kids have an entertainment consent to work, that is supposed to be regulated so that education doesn’t suffer. How many times have they cancelled ‘school’ because one sibling has an audition, needs a new outfit, needs a haircut…or just that Tim wants vlog content?
We are all seeing as of late that inappropriate things people say years before come back to haunt them. With the views expressed on gender roles and homosexuality for example, if Heze does receive fame as an adult pro football, he could end up backed into a corner over resurfaced videos and apologising for views he held as a child and having to blame is upbringing. The girls could end up blaming their parents for their lack of career prospects when advert roles dry up once they reach adulthood. One of the videos where Tim ‘interviews’ Hosanna, she talks about how she will need to be submissive to her husband, and Tim agreed with that and basically says that if he agrees with her choice of husband, then once she is married that she will then just obey him. I can see these girls marrying young to please their parents, as the ambition to be wives has been drummed in, and then feeling they are in a situation where they can’t leave if the relationship turns sour, due to the deep rooted belief that their husband has to be obeyed.
The kids obviously know they are being filmed and possibly just the youngest 2 don’t properly understand who is watching and why their parents are doing it. But even for those who understand, have they genuinely understood and consented to the long term implications of having their family life on record? Even when videos get deleted (such as the baby kidnap), they can’t delete stuff like chat forums that mentioned it. There’s also the videos where the kids are being forced to take back their genuine thoughts after being rehearsed, such as Heze claiming he didn’t actually want his own bedroom. The audience aren’t being told that this is scripted and manipulated, Heze isn’t playing a character, so he should need to have to act out lines that aren’t his true opinions.
There’s also the question of the money, assuming YouTube, channel 5 and Nike is what is funding their day to day and their house move (and not Tim’s parents), then it is mainly the kids who have earned the money. Although Tim does the filming…the viewers are there to see the kids, he has no income without them. Presumably when children generally earn money from things such as acting, the money is paid to the child and not the parent? The parent then takes from that the costs they have incurred associated with the child’s job (travel, hotels etc). Unless a child is earning millions, surely they should not expect to have their money used to fund their parents basic living and housing costs? When the kids reach 18 and ask for their share of the money they have earned to get returned to them, Tim and Ella won’t want to do that, because they will have spent it all on designer clothes, raising the earning child’s siblings, and it will be held in the property they are living in.
There are so many ways that the children may look back on this and feel exploited, embarrassed or aggrieved by either their parent’s behaviour or their own being made public.
It could even start happening sooner than that, if for example Heze has told his friends at the academy about the YouTube channel, young boys can easily bully or isolate another boy whose own lifestyle is different to theirs. Imagine the group of 11-13 year olds he meets with at the academy have watched the video of him discussing his sisters upcoming menstruation…and that the other boys probably have mobile phones, whatsapp etc, and have much more ability to discuss Heze and his family behind his back due to how he is already excluded from that kind of social interaction himself.