Should you always go with your gut instincts, or rules you've made for yourself based on past experience?
For context I'm trying to decide who to work with for a project, and in the past two days I've interviewed two guys.
#1 seemed like a genuinely nice guy, but contravened a lot of criteria that I had set up based on years of experience. I won't go into it here, but I've set several targets like "Doesn't say X. Does express an interest in Y." etc. Because I've found that they turn out to be red flags down the line. I feel tempted to think Oh he's great, I'll go with him anyway. But that has definitely come back to bite me in the arse more than once before!
#2 was very chatty and charismatic and sociable, but I was following the advice of articles I'd read about how to avoid hiring narcissists, and I mentioned a legitimate critique I had. I kept my vocal tone nice and said it wasn't his fault as we could smooth it out down the line. But maaaaaan, his face changed. He looked so different after I said it: his eyes kind of squinted and his mouth was held open, stiff. There was like all grief and hurt on his face. It was literally a piece of feedback where most people would go "Oh, ok." and accept that it would be fixed later. In most other instances, he had this wonderful warm easy personality and passed most of my questions. The only marker he didn't hit was praising any women he's worked with (big indicator for whether he will work with a woman or just decide he knows best and steamroll over her). But then it's possible that he hasn't worked with many women, or none noteable enough to come up in conversation.
I also thought to some extent he might be telling me what I wanted to hear. I felt like he was noting what I said and then feeding it back a few sentences later. Like if I said I'd like X for the project, he'd say "I love X, I do it all the time as a hobby." Might be true, but it happened enough times that it pinged in my brain.
But really it's that face, over what was a very lightly-handled bit of critique. Not even criticism, just a "This in your proposal wasn't what I'm looking for, but that's ok because we can talk about it more and gain an understanding." I really liked his warmth and charisma at the time, but when I came off the call, I just had a voice in my head going "No no no."
Any ideas, Tattlers, on either #1 or #2?