Oh, I'm afraid CBS Reality don't have the first three seasons - they were made under a different network (TNT from memory) and originally here shown on Really, who
never repeat them - I think because Amazon now have the rights. When we first got Prime, I watched all three seasons again but now, season 1 and 2 are "unavailable" and I can only access season 3. Pah.
CBS Reality only have and show from season 4 onwards, when it was saved from cancellation by Oxygen (although season 4 is technically season 1 with Oxygen I suppose) They are just incorrectly detailed on the listings and it's confusing
Been a fan from the start - can you tell?
EDIT - found it on YouTube for you