Preston Davey Trial #5

Status
Thread locked. We start a new thread when they have over 1000 posts, click the blue button to see all threads for this topic and find the latest open thread.
New to Tattle Life? Click "Order Thread by Most Liked Posts" button below to get an idea of what the site is about:
I think JMF will walk free…
I worry that he'll get away with the SA charges despite the jizz on the cot mixed with Preston's saliva, but I don't think he'll get away with causing or allowing Preston's death because he saw all those pictures & videos and did nothing to save that baby.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 32
The fact that he opened the timer app on his phone on that last afternoon suggests to me that he'd restricted Preston's airways before, he was probably gradually extending the time seeing how long he could get away with 😔
...but..but..but...he was timing the seizure! 😡
 
  • Sad
  • Like
Reactions: 5
This is one of the most heartbreaking trials I’ve read about. My son is a similar age to what Preston was when those monsters killed him and everytime I look at him it makes me feel so sick and sad for him and his foster Mum too 😔
 
  • Like
  • Sad
  • Heart
Reactions: 18
Highly unlikely it was the same social workers. Once final care orders are made, the child is moved to the child in care team / looked after child team. So no they wouldn’t have noticed a difference.
This wasn't the case for us. My son had the same social worker from birth to adoption order and that was the same for every one in my circle. My son's social worker visited weekly and we had our social worker who also visited weekly.
My son's social worker would visit at various times too, so she could see him eating, playing, waking up etc.
Honestly, it was a pain in the a, but I obviously understood why.
 
  • Like
  • Heart
Reactions: 26
I don’t think JMF will walk.
The ‘as long as he’s safe’ text solidified his guilt for me. He KNEW!!
 
  • Like
  • Sad
Reactions: 32
I worry that he'll get away with the SA charges despite the jizz on the cot mixed with Preston's saliva, but I don't think he'll get away with causing or allowing Preston's death because he saw all those pictures & videos and did nothing to save that baby.
Why is he lying about the roast and saying he was downstairs the whole time? And going along with an unnatural sleeping position? If he were truly innocent he would have said omg my freakish former partner sexually assaulted my baby while I was making a roast. Instead he's making up excuses to try and say nothing untoward happened at all. Guilty as sin
 
  • Like
  • Heart
Reactions: 30
I do vaguely remember hearing something about the swings and whether it was age appropriate but definitely not heard anything about a pram on a rocky path.
That only seems to have come out in the summing up, assume it’s videos. Weirdos. Whoever called them vampires was spot on.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 8
I don’t think JMF will walk.
The ‘as long as he’s safe’ text solidified his guilt for me. He KNEW!!
Yes! It just sticks out doesn’t it. Why wouldn’t he be safe, they're at home with stupid Moana playing, and he needs to go to his bed.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 15
I do still wonder about the dynamics between the two of them.
I definitely get the impression that JV had zero interest in raising a child. I think possibly they are both as bad as each other, cooked up the idea together, and JV fancied a year off work on adoption leave, with extra cash coming in for adopting. That’s why he is resentful to JMF getting out and about whilst he’s stuck with a baby who is only interesting for about 30 mins a per day for abusing. I also think JMF realised early on that JV was a bit out of control.
I wonder whether JMF went for JV as he worked in a school. I wonder whether JMF was the pdf and JV was just a sadist and their interests merged.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: 14
I think the previous team should definitely make a visit or even better a joint visit with the new team. The foster carer, on the one time she was allowed to visit, noticed he was stiff, pale, withdrawn. A SW said he couldn’t smile and when he tried he would cry. This is so different to the baby that was in the loving arms of his foster family. That doesn’t take a medical expert, it takes leading with safeguarding at all times.

All well and good in principle however, if you took a look on Google there are hundreds of vacancies. Social work is underfunded, stretched & people leave the profession in droves. There is a current crisis in social care that is not being reported on - I worked in a team where 15 social workers left in a month. The same team is now only young inexperienced social workers, people don’t want to do it anymore. I was a social worker for 12 years and left.

The resources aren’t there, there’s no staff & things get missed as it’s over stretched and underfunded. All the comments Iv seen online show how out of touch people are with regards to the reality of the crisis in social care. I saw a comment where someone said every visit should be with 2 social worker. They don’t have time in their week to visit the 40 children on their case load let alone doubling up
 
  • Like
  • Heart
  • Sad
Reactions: 41
This wasn't the case for us. My son had the same social worker from birth to adoption order and that was the same for every one in my circle. My son's social worker visited weekly and we had our social worker who also visited weekly.
My son's social worker would visit at various times too, so she could see him eating, playing, waking up etc.
Honestly, it was a pain in the a, but I obviously understood why.
That’s good. There has been a recent change with child protection which will make things even more difficult with regards to following things from assessment to placement however some teams (in the minority these days) do assessment all the way to final care order then transfer to looked after child but most teams are now split into assessment, child protection (including court) then looked after.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 6
Just read that Jv was in the bath with Preston over an hour. What the hell?? What baby would be comfortable in the bath for that long? I’m currently taking care of an 18 month old family member who loves a bubble bath but even he gets bored after 15 minutes! I feel sick.
 
  • Like
  • Sad
Reactions: 30
Why is he lying about the roast and saying he was downstairs the whole time? And going along with an unnatural sleeping position? If he were truly innocent he would have said omg my freakish former partner sexually assaulted my baby while I was making a roast. Instead he's making up excuses to try and say nothing untoward happened at all. Guilty as sin
This is it for me. If JMF is as innocent as he says, there isn't enough anger. I'd be blaming myself regardless, saying I should have known, I've failed. I'd be raging, telling the judge to lock JV up. But he's very passively cooking a roast and being beautiful. Fuckkkk off!
 
  • Like
  • Haha
  • Heart
Reactions: 46
Listening to the new pod. Jeez they even used the word “sassy” in his defence in regard to him having all those inappropriate pictures. So sassy 🙄🙄 I did like that he also described his character as “annoying” though 😂 yes we know he is an insufferable wick but that doesn’t mean he’s not a murdering rapist too.
 
  • Like
  • Sick
  • Haha
Reactions: 27
That’s good. There has been a recent change with child protection which will make things even more difficult with regards to following things from assessment to placement however some teams (in the minority these days) do assessment all the way to final care order then transfer to looked after child but most teams are now split into assessment, child protection (including court) then looked after.
It's the "looked after" section I'm referring to. We had three social workers really. Mine and my husbands, who assessed us for adoption, got us to panel and went through matching with us. My son had his social worker from birth, who visited him in foster care and then visited us post placement up until the adoption order was granted. We also had a family finder who straddled both sides. And then an IRO who oversaw everything.
Even when children are placed, they are still "looked after" aren't they.
Preston was still pre-AO and would have been having regular social worker visits.
But, regardless, Preston was in front of social workers, doctors, nurses, extended family and friends of JMF and JV. Nothing works if there isn't joined up thinking. Added another professional wouldn't have helped Preston at all - that's been my point all along.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 19
I do vaguely remember hearing something about the swings and whether it was age appropriate but definitely not heard anything about a pram on a rocky path.
I think these could be used by the judge to illustrate the sadistic element at sentencing. He was terrorising that child for his own amusement.
Exactly. If the medical experts say it’s accidental - for social workers it’s incredibly difficult to then argue against their opinion. It gets overturned by managers
Maybe in the “lessons learned” there could be a suggestion for a social worker who has knowledge of the child and family to have a “gut instinct” clause, where they are allowed to exercise their judgement of the wider situation to trigger further investigation despite medical professionals saying accidental. There probably is something already, like stepping up visits but if it was an official avenue they would be given the time to do it as we know resources are scarce so without an official acknowledgment of their right to do this their hands are tied. I’ve said it before, lots of our hopes and ideas aren’t practicable but we are desperately trying to imagine a timeline where Preston was saved and where this couldn’t happen to another child. It must be soul destroying for the social workers to realise they’ve either a) been taken in by a monster or b) been prevented from following their gut (by time constraints, manager veto, protocol or whatever).
 
  • Like
Reactions: 13
Leeds murder trial for child killer Kyle Bevan murdered in Wakefield prison. Three other inmates accessed his cell and killed him.
JV's future.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 16
Status
Thread locked. We start a new thread when they have over 1000 posts, click the blue button to see all threads for this topic and find the latest open thread.