Jason Arday #3

Status
Thread locked. We start a new thread when they have over 1000 posts, click the blue button to see all threads for this topic and find the latest open thread.
New to Tattle Life? Click "Order Thread by Most Liked Posts" button below to get an idea of what the site is about:

This is a VERY long but forensic analysis of Arday’s claims. What’s really interesting is that the author points out that the autism dx doesn’t appear until quite late in the story. And that as we’ve already discussed, Asperger’s is not a dx that is consistent with being non verbal.

There is also detailed comparison of some of the more lurid episodes with Home and Away and Neighbours storylines. And Pinball Wizard
 
  • Like
  • Heart
  • Wow
Reactions: 27

This is a VERY long but forensic analysis of Arday’s claims. What’s really interesting is that the author points out that the autism dx doesn’t appear until quite late in the story. And that as we’ve already discussed, Asperger’s is not a dx that is consistent with being non verbal.

There is also detailed comparison of some of the more lurid episodes with Home and Away and Neighbours storylines. And Pinball Wizard
Interesting read.

(I posted that quickly so I could get post 666 😈🤘 continuing...)

Joe's quote compared to Jason's statements, and Joe's ACCOMPLISHMENTS compared to Jason's, makes me think the lies and embellishments were plain ole sibling rivalry, and Jason was just not that bright, especially compared to Joe, so had to grift his way to the top.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 20
Well that was always our theory about Jack Monroe - that the bad mentals and history of rehab meant that no one wanted to touch her. Shattenstone inadvertently finished her grift off in the end. It was a slowly deflating balloon rather than anything more dramatic though and whaddya know, she survived it, got a job and became a contributing member of society.

We should always question liars. If you don’t want your lies questioned, keep them to lies that don’t propel you into the public eye.
Absolutely. And if she closed the bloody Patreon she wouldn't have a Tattle thread. Although I suspect that's the point now. She's only famous to us 😂.

But, if she didn't have that and was just living her life then, fair play to her, just let her get on with it. What's the point in calling out liars if we don't give them the opportunity to change?
 
  • Like
Reactions: 16

This is a VERY long but forensic analysis of Arday’s claims. What’s really interesting is that the author points out that the autism dx doesn’t appear until quite late in the story. And that as we’ve already discussed, Asperger’s is not a dx that is consistent with being non verbal.

There is also detailed comparison of some of the more lurid episodes with Home and Away and Neighbours storylines. And Pinball Wizard
That's a great read, I really agree with this part:

Screenshot_2026-08-27-12-03-49-003_com.duckduckgo.mobile.android.jpg
 
  • Like
  • Heart
Reactions: 25

This is a VERY long but forensic analysis of Arday’s claims. What’s really interesting is that the author points out that the autism dx doesn’t appear until quite late in the story. And that as we’ve already discussed, Asperger’s is not a dx that is consistent with being non verbal.
The enmeshment of two protective characteristics is what has been so protective for the individual in this debacle. It has neutralised, obscured and deflected critique.

Dolezal was globally pilloried for claiming a Black identity. Would neurodivergence have protected her from condemnation?
Which protected characteristic is the Trump card?

The coherence of the autism claims are forensically disentangled, and the point is appropriately made that an autism diagnosis is not a free pass to be poor /incapable at the job. Adjustments have to be reasonable not bespoke and holistic to the extent of never applying a quality standard. In my view those with a Neurodivergent diagnosis should be concerned about a spin of ''Why autism is blamed for everything". It will be hugely damaging for those who do not have a fallback protection characteristic.

Cartrarian's article has undertaken an excellent analysis of trying to unpick the autism claim and analyse the other claims of Aspergers Global Development Delay/Learning Difficulties diagnoses.

If an unsupportable claim of a protected characteristic has led to benefits the individual would not have received in the absence of this identity there should be a reckoning.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
  • Heart
Reactions: 16

This is a VERY long but forensic analysis of Arday’s claims. What’s really interesting is that the author points out that the autism dx doesn’t appear until quite late in the story. And that as we’ve already discussed, Asperger’s is not a dx that is consistent with being non verbal.

There is also detailed comparison of some of the more lurid episodes with Home and Away and Neighbours storylines. And Pinball Wizard
This is a really interesting article - thanks for posting. I was hoping someone would investigate the autism / GDD claims because it’s never rung true to me.

It’s also interesting that his older brother Joe has spoken about how he (Joe) had speech delays as a child, that he (Joe) couldn’t “properly communicate” until he was around 8 - although he doesn’t claim to be entirely non-verbal - and that he (Joe) had a SEN statement. The writer of this article does suggest that Jason could have had some kind of learning delay as well, albeit not the diagnoses he claims, but I wonder if he’s also used elements of his brother’s story as well.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 18
If Cofnas wasn't the best applicant, then Ghent staff have embarrassed themselves. Cambridge hired a man with a plagiarised PhD, fabricated back story and woeful academic output, presumably as they wanted a great poster boy for post-Floyd corrections. Yet Ghent hired Cofnas, and either knew about his controversial writings or didn't bother looking into why he left Cambridge. If he wasn't the best man for the job, who allowed him to trump better candidates? Were 'race realists' under-represented?

They think they are smearing Cofnas but are actually making themselves look worse.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 13
I'm just sat here laughing in my local comprehensive GCSEs intellect that higher education is such a cesspit of flickery.
 
  • Haha
  • Like
Reactions: 11
I'm just sat here laughing in my local comprehensive GCSEs intellect that higher education is such a cesspit of flickery.
That should be fuckery but my dumb witch status has been well and truly cemented 🤪
 
  • Haha
  • Heart
  • Like
Reactions: 10
I'm just sat here laughing in my local comprehensive GCSEs intellect that higher education is such a cesspit of flickery.
I've seen the phrase 'only clever people could be this stupid' more in the last fortnight than before.

I was at a relative's house when Arday's vigil popped up on the TV. My relative wanted to know what it was all about as she'd seen it in the papers but not read it. She spent 30yrs woking in schools, moving from dinner lady to classroom assisant to working with disabled children. I told her to tell me when something struck her as odd. I got as far as 'he was dxed with global delay and Aspergers at 3 and was non-verbal until 11' before her BS detector declared a full blown 'COW CHUTNEY' incident.
 
  • Like
  • Haha
Reactions: 21
I worry that this will make the media and public even less likely to question someone when a story doesn't seem right.
The Salt Path exposure never lead to all this handwringing and self-recrimination. The stakes were far less with exposing those frauds though. They weren't professors at the most prestigious university in the country that people pay a lot of money to attend, expecting to receive a first rate education.

Just to echo what was said by someone said on here, reading the extracts of the memoir was like reading The Diary of Adrian Mole. Him getting as far as he did in academia is exposing how corrupt the entire university system is. That has widespread ramifications for society.
 
  • Like
  • Heart
Reactions: 20
Status
Thread locked. We start a new thread when they have over 1000 posts, click the blue button to see all threads for this topic and find the latest open thread.