The trouble with the guitar shop was...... loads of little bits and bobs!I thought it was very picky of Michelle to say about the guitar shop seating area - 'well you could've put some guitar magazines or something on the table'. I presume the team thought the owner was actually capable of that. He didn't need their 'vision' to be able to grasp the concept of putting a magazine on a table.
Things like in the seating area, all the chairs had arms! If you want to pick up a guitar and strum it to see how it feels, which is what most people will do before buying, you need seating without arms, so you can fit the guitar in!! What about a coffee machine or similar, to encourage people to sit and chat? The acoustic guitar side was where the empty stage was, why not set the stage up more for a gig? With lots more guitars in stands on the stage area? They could easily be moved if you wanted to do a performance? personally I thought the stage area was too empty
Apart from the windows which were great, I thought the guitar shop was a bit generic, very similar to others, so the shop itself didnt feel that designed to me?
The gift shop though was in some ways harder to do, because they had so many different products to sell, and it hard to do this and still make it look coherent. So I thought the pair designing this, did do a better job at designing a space to sell! I wish they had had more time with the tree, as the concept was good, a tree in an ex bookshop, and didnt it also refer to the name of the shop? But I agree the excecution wasnt great, and looked a bit....odd.