And yes to this also!let’s be real, trans ‘rights’ aren’t human rights, they’re human WANTS. They WANT access to spaces designated to the opposite sex. They WANT access to sterilising and disfiguring medical care, where there is no medical need. They WANT to control how others feel, speak and think about them.
The last is more complicated, but the rest are not rights that any of us are entitled to. An anorexic does not have the ‘right’ to starve herself to death - in a truly free/liberal/whatever society we could argue that she is free to do so, but not to the point where the state enables her mental illness. As a mentally ill person, she does have the right to appropriate care for her mental illness which, funnily enough, isn’t facilitating her self-starvation.
‘Trans rights’ completely obscure the intended purpose of human rights. Yes, a trans identified person has the same rights the rest of us do - freedom from harassment, persecution, discrimination etc. I can even concede that those who have transitioned may require additional discrimination protections in a protected characteristics sense- the toothpaste is out of the tube, so to speak.
But they didn’t have the ‘right’ to make themselves that way. It was a choice, and one they should be encouraged to take responsibility for. It’s how you help mentally unwell people get better.
I gotta stop launching in here with my thoughts, when I'm just pontificating to the already converted and knowledgeable choir!
Or however that saying goes