Elena Handtrack

New to Tattle Life? Click "Order Thread by Most Liked Posts" button below to get an idea of what the site is about:
I feel like sometimes she comes across as arrogant, especially in the gifted video.

Also, she said her parents are not rich, but she made them pay for her private education anyway, when Germany already has great public schools. Same thing with Cambridge, she's doing a year abroad in Germany, where she could be studying for free, but instead, she's paying Cambridge.

And all her expensive clothes... Idk, she seems like a great person and a hardworker, but she's not my cup of tea. My favorite is definitely Paige.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 6
i like her, she seems to have very firm ideas and ideals, she doesn't take anything for granted and it looks like she's definitely making the most of her cambridge experience
she even talked very openly about her mental health during her first year at uni which i find very genuine

however her video on "the actual cost of having a 'gifted' child" came across (at least to me) as she felt some sort of superiority? like...i'm brighter than the rest or i'm more ambitious than the average student so i had to spend all this amount of money to receive an education according to my ambitions and purposes in life...(studying at UWC in hong-kong and so on)
maybe i'm wrong (i must say she wrote the term gifted in quotation marks and explained that she doesn't consider herself as somebody above the average) but i found it a bit annoying. as i said, maybe i didn't fully understand it!
i like her, she seems to have very firm ideas and ideals, she doesn't take anything for granted and it looks like she's definitely making the most of her cambridge experience
she even talked very openly about her mental health during her first year at uni which i find very genuine

however her video on "the actual cost of having a 'gifted' child" came across (at least to me) as she felt some sort of superiority? like...i'm brighter than the rest or i'm more ambitious than the average student so i had to spend all this amount of money to receive an education according to my ambitions and purposes in life...(studying at UWC in hong-kong and so on)
maybe i'm wrong (i must say she wrote the term gifted in quotation marks and explained that she doesn't consider herself as somebody above the average) but i found it a bit annoying. as i said, maybe i didn't fully understand it!
To be honest, while I can imagine how this may seem arrogant, I personally understand where she’s coming from. If she is brighter and more ambitious than average then all the power to her and I think she should indeed receive an education according to her ambitions. I can see how the title of the video etc may make her seem arrogant or narcissistic but at the same time I don’t think there’s anything wrong with being aware of your strengths and getting the opportunities that you worked for (and making a video about the costs).

I love Elena, she’s one of my favorite people on YouTube and I also feel very sorry for her when she gets hate about her appearance cause girl 👏🏻you👏🏻are👏🏻gorgeous!
 
  • Like
Reactions: 6
I feel like sometimes she comes across as arrogant, especially in the gifted video.

Also, she said her parents are not rich, but she made them pay for her private education anyway, when Germany already has great public schools. Same thing with Cambridge, she's doing a year abroad in Germany, where she could be studying for free, but instead, she's paying Cambridge.

And all her expensive clothes... Idk, she seems like a great person and a hardworker, but she's not my cup of tea. My favorite is definitely Paige.
Yes Paige definitely strikes the perfect balance! I've never even noted a hint of arrogance from her. She seems extremely down to earth and I can't find much to fault tbh.
 
  • Like
  • Heart
Reactions: 8
Yeah I think there are other lower profile ones out there who are decent, Astrid Franciszka (Paige's friend) comes to mind, but the common threads for all the likeable ones are: they're aware of their own privilege, they don't just study but get involved with other things and they're passionate about what they're learning (and this comes through in videos).
I also really like Nayna Florence and Moya Mawhinney - their content is good because whilst they're both uni students I wouldn't call them "studytubers" and their content doesn't revolve around studying in an intense way. Can't lie, their videos are also really aesthetically pleasing!
 
I thought Elena had won several scholarships for her education in Cambridge. Can't remember the details unfortunately but I imagine it takes the weight off the expenses. Personally if I had the chance to get an education at Cambridge rather than some other good uni, especially with the help of bursaries or scholarships, I'd be mad to refuse it. Can't judge her for choosing a Cambridge degree.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 7
I used to be like her with the humble-bragging. But I've stopped now that I realized how cringey I came off. I don't need external validation.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 5
And the award to the most self-aware and responsible your uber goes to Elena Handtrack!

My one rebuttal to her piece is that she says Ruby Granger and (the old) UnJadeded probably don't spend everyday studying for 15 hours and it's only the snippets of their lives that we see that we build our assumptions around. However, I argue that it's the responsibility of studytubers such as these to actively dispel these assumptions by showing more variety in their channels or at less tin the description of their video that it is not representative of a typical day/ life.

 
  • Like
  • Haha
  • Heart
Reactions: 8
And the award to the most self-aware and responsible your uber goes to Elena Handtrack!

My one rebuttal to her piece is that she says Ruby Granger and (the old) UnJadeded probably don't spend everyday studying for 15 hours and it's only the snippets of their lives that we see that we build our assumptions around. However, I argue that it's the responsibility of studytubers such as these to actively dispel these assumptions by showing more variety in their channels or at less tin the description of their video that it is not representative of a typical day/ life.

I agree, props to Elena for the self-awareness. I would like to add that I believe this also somewhat depends on your audience – after all, most YouTubers are aware of their age demographic and I think studytubers whose audience is mainly minors should indeed make sure their audience realizes this may not be how they live every day, they also rest etc. While Elena's audience is a little older, and most adults usually don't need the clarification that someone's life doesn't have to be like theirs or that people showing their studying process don't study all day every day, children are generally more impressionable – and it seems to me that some studytubers have a really young audience in comparison to themselves (or at least it seems so from their comment section).
 
  • Like
Reactions: 5
Not going to lie, I just died a little bit of jealousy. 18 points is insane. That‘s the equivalent to getting 100% in the U! No one gets 18 points - with the exception of Elena of course! At least her crazy amount of studying payed off but wow ...
 
  • Like
  • Wow
Reactions: 6
Not going to lie, I just died a little bit of jealousy. 18 points is insane. That‘s the equivalent to getting 100% in the U! No one gets 18 points - with the exception of Elena of course! At least her crazy amount of studying payed off but wow ...
Holy cow! She definitely deserves it though, I'm lowkey proud of her. It looks like she has to work hard to get the grades she does and I really respect that.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 3
Holy cow! She definitely deserves it though, I'm lowkey proud of her. It looks like she has to work hard to get the grades she does and I really respect that.
Yeah, me too!
I‘ve just had a look again (i‘m a sucker for pain 😂) and it seems like this was a special type of class with a test and oral exam, so not a typical German law exam. Very curious to see how she‘ll do in those!
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1
Not going to lie, I just died a little bit of jealousy. 18 points is insane. That‘s the equivalent to getting 100% in the U! No one gets 18 points - with the exception of Elena of course! At least her crazy amount of studying payed off but wow ...
Just what I thought when I saw it! One of my friends studies law (currently preparing for her first Staatsexamen), and she's trying to get 9 points.
Just to put this into perspective for non-Germans: about 10% of students get 9 points, anything above is insanely good! I think only about 0,1-0,5% of people get full 18 points! and you're basically considered a God when you get 16.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 4
The amount of study with me videos she does is excessive. I think people have trouble finding her other videos because when you click on her channel there are like 10 study with me videos in a roll.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 3
ehh She only shows some grades, the ones she wants to show. grades are also arbitrary. she took a semester off school her first year because she thought it was "too much." She probably wasnt doing too well. Grades also have nothing to do with intelligence in the real world. the girl reads harry potter books ffs.

I feel like sometimes she comes across as arrogant, especially in the gifted video.

Also, she said her parents are not rich, but she made them pay for her private education anyway, when Germany already has great public schools. Same thing with Cambridge, she's doing a year abroad in Germany, where she could be studying for free, but instead, she's paying Cambridge.

And all her expensive clothes... Idk, she seems like a great person and a hardworker, but she's not my cup of tea. My favorite is definitely Paige.
It doesnt surprise me. Oxbridge takes a certain type of student. These students are usually intelligent and meet the criteria, but they are also overwhelmingly children who grew up with immense privilege and fit a certain type of profile that guarantees that they will continue to maintain a high profile later in life as well. (usually these are well-connected kids).
 
ehh She only shows some grades, the ones she wants to show. grades are also arbitrary. she took a semester off school her first year because she thought it was "too much." She probably wasnt doing too well. Grades also have nothing to do with intelligence in the real world. the girl reads harry potter books ffs.
such a weird take cause she’s gotten funding all throughout her undergrad (and already got it secured for an MA as well) so her grades are clearly fine; and she’s shown enough times that she reads non-YA books as well (since when are we judging people for what they read for fun anyway).
you can dislike someone without belittling their achievements and interests lol
 
  • Like
Reactions: 8
she was literally clinically depressed
The reality is that she probably felt bad because while she was a big fish in her small school, she is nothing at Cambridge. At Cambridge, these kids are privileged, come from wealthy and high profile families, have all the resources available to them, and/or made top notch grades. About half of them are probably the privileged kind. It strikes me as strange that Elena got depressed in her very first year (probably missed home and couldnt hack the competition), took a semester off, and then resumed studies but at a lesser known school in Germany and in her native German language. Come on. Girl couldnt hack it. It is a lot easier to get good grades at an average school than it is to get grades at a more presitigious school. If she wanted to study abroad, she could have gone to China or one of the other interesting places in the world to expand her horizons, but no she went back to her home town to live with mommy and daddy as a college student. Meh.

And sorry but she reads YA fiction. You would think that a Cambridge student in law who was "gifted" would have moved on to other books besides Harry Potter and Sarah Maas. Her "elena tries to figure out law" channel videos are also very telling. Sometimes people reveal who they are without realizing it... if you watch the video she made on the #metoo movement and how it "hurts men" you can tell that she has no practical experience of the real world and has never experienced having a disadvantage because of something she could not control (i.e. gender, race, etc). In those videos, she repeats several conservative talking points that make her sound like a 65 year old...and they honestly probably came from who parented her. It doesnt sound like she is very self-aware or mature. It is one thing to know how to get good grades in school and know what teachers want for exams, but having actual insight and intellectual curiosity is a completely separate thing and she does not have it as far as what I can tell.

You would also think that she would be networking more, involved in on-campus extracurriculars, and making the most of the breadth of her university's immense resources....but she just stays at home with her mom and sits in her room vlogging study sessions that 100 people join. It's sad because she is afraid to actually challenge herself and seems to want to remain a child forever.

As for her claims about being from a "middle class" family...I don't think that this is true. Clearly, she has travelled around the world from an early age. She went to boarding school in China, did expensive summer programs in the United States at very prestigious schools, applied to 19 colleges, all of which were reach schools and importantly, outside of her home country. I also think that if she is going by the UK class system, middle class is really upper middle-class...and that is probably what she actually is. She actually disappoints me. I think she just uses Youtube as a way to motivate herself to study and probably because she is very lonely.

such a weird take cause she’s gotten funding all throughout her undergrad (and already got it secured for an MA as well) so her grades are clearly fine; and she’s shown enough times that she reads non-YA books as well (since when are we judging people for what they read for fun anyway).
you can dislike someone without belittling their achievements and interests lol
Ah ok. So I am not allowed to have a different opinion and criticise a YouTuber's interests?

Am i on a fan site? I thought this was a gossip forum? That is why i am here anyway. If i wanted to praise her, I would just do so on her youtube channel.
 
Last edited:
  • Sad
  • Like
  • Angry
Reactions: 5
The reality is that she probably felt bad because while she was a big fish in her small school, she is nothing at Cambridge. At Cambridge, these kids are privileged, come from wealthy and high profile families, have all the resources available to them, and/or made top notch grades. About half of them are probably the privileged kind. It strikes me as strange that Elena got depressed in her very first year (probably missed home and couldnt hack the competition), took a semester off, and then resumed studies but at a lesser known school in Germany and in her native German language. Come on. Girl couldnt hack it. It is a lot easier to get good grades at an average school than it is to get grades at a more presitigious school. If she wanted to study abroad, she could have gone to China or one of the other interesting places in the world to expand her horizons, but no she went back to her home town to live with mommy and daddy as a college student. Meh.

And sorry but she reads YA fiction. You would think that a Cambridge student in law who was "gifted" would have moved on to other books besides Harry Potter and Sarah Maas. Her "elena tries to figure out law" channel videos are also very telling. Sometimes people reveal who they are without realizing it... if you watch the video she made on the #metoo movement and how it "hurts men" you can tell that she has no practical experience of the real world and has never experienced having a disadvantage because of something she could not control (i.e. gender, race, etc). In those videos, she repeats several conservative talking points that make her sound like a 65 year old...and they honestly probably came from who parented her. It doesnt sound like she is very self-aware or mature. It is one thing to know how to get good grades in school and know what teachers want for exams, but having actual insight and intellectual curiosity is a completely separate thing and she does not have it as far as what I can tell.

You would also think that she would be networking more, involved in on-campus extracurriculars, and making the most of the breadth of her university's immense resources....but she just stays at home with her mom and sits in her room vlogging study sessions that 100 people join. It's sad because she is afraid to actually challenge herself and seems to want to remain a child forever.

As for her claims about being from a "middle class" family...I don't think that this is true. Clearly, she has travelled around the world from an early age. She went to boarding school in China, did expensive summer programs in the United States at very prestigious schools, applied to 19 colleges, all of which were reach schools and importantly, outside of her home country. I also think that if she is going by the UK class system, middle class is really upper middle-class...and that is probably what she actually is. She actually disappoints me. I think she just uses Youtube as a way to motivate herself to study and probably because she is very lonely.


Ah ok. So I am not allowed to have a different opinion and criticise a YouTuber's interests?

Am i on a fan site? I thought this was a gossip forum? That is why i am here anyway. If i wanted to praise her, I would just do so on her youtube channel.
She went to one of the United World Colleges though, didn't she? For the duration of the IB. Where almost every student gets a scholarship anyway. So - that would give her a good background in terms of connections and prepping for competetive universities, but she also studied in English, lived away from home at a young age and an extended period of time, came from an international environment, amd had experienced a competetive setting. And lots of students went home during lockdown, that's a very legitimate decision.

I believer her when she says she's middle class, though at times she has acted like she doesn't also have quite a bit of privilege - like how she worked to afford her designer stuff. Fair enough, but to be able to spend a large part of one's earnings on that doesn’t deny privilege. Applying to competetive schools and going through scholarship applications would have been much hardee if she'd attended a smaller school where most students aim for a place at local universities and finance their studies with loans and part-time jobs.
And the entire "when the high achiever stops achieving" also had me like... idk. Lots of people struggle with these constraints. Peopple who don't overachieve but simply consistently struggle to meet certain exectations don't have it easier than overachievers hitting a wall. This is one of those "insights" we get from high achievers that isn't insightful at all. But depression can hit anybody, esppecially at a time of rapid change where, yes, somebody used to looking at themselves as a "big fish" might find themselves thrown in cold water, and might struggle to find comfort and support in a new place.

The bottom line is that to me, Elena seems like an intelligent, hard working young person who is genuine and generally down-to-earth. But she may be somewhat sheltered and could perhaps be a little more self-aware when addressing topics like systemic privilege.
 
  • Like
  • Sad
Reactions: 8
The reality is that she probably felt bad because while she was a big fish in her small school, she is nothing at Cambridge. At Cambridge, these kids are privileged, come from wealthy and high profile families, have all the resources available to them, and/or made top notch grades. About half of them are probably the privileged kind. It strikes me as strange that Elena got depressed in her very first year (probably missed home and couldnt hack the competition), took a semester off, and then resumed studies but at a lesser known school in Germany and in her native German language. Come on. Girl couldnt hack it. It is a lot easier to get good grades at an average school than it is to get grades at a more presitigious school. If she wanted to study abroad, she could have gone to China or one of the other interesting places in the world to expand her horizons, but no she went back to her home town to live with mommy and daddy as a college student. Meh.

And sorry but she reads YA fiction. You would think that a Cambridge student in law who was "gifted" would have moved on to other books besides Harry Potter and Sarah Maas. Her "elena tries to figure out law" channel videos are also very telling. Sometimes people reveal who they are without realizing it... if you watch the video she made on the #metoo movement and how it "hurts men" you can tell that she has no practical experience of the real world and has never experienced having a disadvantage because of something she could not control (i.e. gender, race, etc). In those videos, she repeats several conservative talking points that make her sound like a 65 year old...and they honestly probably came from who parented her. It doesnt sound like she is very self-aware or mature. It is one thing to know how to get good grades in school and know what teachers want for exams, but having actual insight and intellectual curiosity is a completely separate thing and she does not have it as far as what I can tell.

You would also think that she would be networking more, involved in on-campus extracurriculars, and making the most of the breadth of her university's immense resources....but she just stays at home with her mom and sits in her room vlogging study sessions that 100 people join. It's sad because she is afraid to actually challenge herself and seems to want to remain a child forever.

As for her claims about being from a "middle class" family...I don't think that this is true. Clearly, she has travelled around the world from an early age. She went to boarding school in China, did expensive summer programs in the United States at very prestigious schools, applied to 19 colleges, all of which were reach schools and importantly, outside of her home country. I also think that if she is going by the UK class system, middle class is really upper middle-class...and that is probably what she actually is. She actually disappoints me. I think she just uses Youtube as a way to motivate herself to study and probably because she is very lonely.


Ah ok. So I am not allowed to have a different opinion and criticise a YouTuber's interests?

Am i on a fan site? I thought this was a gossip forum? That is why i am here anyway. If i wanted to praise her, I would just do so on her youtube channel.
Also depression can just happen there doesn't need to be an underlying reason. I don't care what you think of Elena otherwise but your ideas around mental illness are extremely archaic and problematic for her and the general population. Maybe this is why mental health issues are so stigmatised and prolific especially in a legal field.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 10
I'm sorry @vio but you come across as extremely bitter and you also got some facts wrong. So let me clear some things up.

After Elena took some time off she actually went back to Cambridge for a full year (or at least half) and is now doing a year abroad at a uni in Germany. Regensburg is not as top notch as Cambridge but that was likely the only German uni that they've partnered with and I can understand why she would like to get an introduction into German law. She also was supposed to live in Regensburg but until just about now Covid was still a pretty big deal in Germany, so living at home was a very smart decision (same thing I did. Why would you want to be alone in a small room with not connections and restrictions when you can be at home with at least family for support).

Saying a law student shouldn't read YA novels is something I don't get. She clearly also reads other novels as well as scholastic papers so who cares if she wants to spend her down time reading YA? During term that's all I read because I want something light and fun after reading bloody hard / boring texts (I'm also a law student btw). Are you saying that you never do anything that's just fun?

As far as I remember she was quite involved in a few extracurriculars but again: there is a pandemic, so not much one can do right now.

From what I gathered about her and her family I would say that from a German perspective she is indeed middle class, although with a good portion of privilege but still middle class. She relies quite heavily on scholarships and safes up for expensive things such as handbags etc.

Just because this is a gossip forum does not mean we need to (pointlessly) tear influencers down and in this case it seems like you just want to attack her without even having the correct facts.
 
  • Like
  • Heart
Reactions: 16