It's really hard isn't it - I think of amazing thoughtful presents for the whole family to buy each other, apart from my boyfriend I help everyone with their present shopping and then when I get my own generic gifts it's a bit disappointing. Like this year my mum knew I wanted a Jo Malone candle (small, £25 or £17 on Black Friday deals) - now this was the only thing I had said I really wanted and in the 3 weeks running up to Xmas mum kept making little comments about how pleased I was going to be with my present - I opened a pack of 4 cheap candles in a box, mum said the jo Malone was too expensive! But she topped my cheap candles up with home bargains tat - I would have preferred the one present that I actually wanted,
I could buy 4 cheap candles for myself any day. I have mentioned it and said there's no point asking what I want if you're going to ignore it but she doesn't seem to get it, she would rather buy presents for the sake of it than what anyone wants! I feel so ungrateful writing that and maybe if I hadn't put so much thought in to everyone's presents for each other it wouldn't be quite as annoying. Luckily boyfriend and mother in law are very thoughtful with gifts.
You're not ungrateful you're absolutely right. Why bother asking if you're not going to buy it and with respect £25/£17 isn't that much when you consider it's all you wanted. I'm the same as you. I'd rather have everything on my list but only those things.
Not to sound dramatic but it can be really heartbreaking when the people who are supposed to be the closest to you don't know well enough or don't care enough to try. I wish I just hadn't bothered. At least when I don't tell her what I want I'm not disappointed. I have to buy it myself anyway most of the time.
My mum is very show-y with money. So she'll spend £100 on presents for me and in her mind she's done a great job cause she's spent all this money in a "look at all the presents I've bought you" way but maybe 2 of those will be things I've asked for or can actually use. The rest of it will be given to charity or thrown out. I've tried to tell her, I tell her every year, I've even tried getting rid of the stuff in front of her so she gets the message. She then had ago at me for throwing out the stuff (see the metal pineapple post above) and I said well I do tell you every year. It's easier now for a quiet life just to let her buy things for the sake of buying.
My dad is great though. He doesn't get me much but the stuff he does get it is things I would actually want and use or he uses his initiative. For example, I'll ask for a book and he'll buy me that one and then one by the same author, or if I ask for concert tickets he'll buy me the calendar of the artist I'm going to see.
Every year as a kid I'd go home from my dad's house and my mum would make some snide comment about how little he'd bought me compared to her and I'd always think "yeah but he gets me stuff I actually want and listens!"
sorry for the life story
Yes I understand. If she goes off the list, she should respect your tastes and health requirements at least. Parenting isn't always easy though but you could be able to speak freely.
In an ideal world, she'd know me well enough or we'd be able to have an adult conversation about it. But in an ideal world, she wouldn't be a lot of things and would actually be a decent mother instead of putting men first
No parenting isn't easy but listening to your child and trying to understand isn't difficult imo.