I was surprised to be honest, because she lied and continued to lie about it later on in the years. When Kyle confirmed it, everyone just pushed it aside and said the same thing. But what i've noticed with the GS cast is that, they pick and choose. If that was someone else, who did that to holly... they would have been shunned! I also find it interesting how chloe said it was never bought up in conversation and yet we have a whole season showing when it was and holly talking to chloe about it. The gas lighting with the GS Cast is the only thing that is real on that show.