I’ve seen Titanique twice and booked for this production of Ave Q next week, so would obvs recommend either of those

Both very stupid and roaringly funny. Titanique is very much like a cross between panto and a Drag Race acting challenge. (There’s even a lipsync for your life!) Avenue Q is more of a traditional book musical with heart behind the ridiculousness. Lots of nods to other shows. If you enjoyed BoM you should get on well with it.
Producers - how do you feel about the film? I would use that as a good barometer.