jfletcher
VIP Member
I appreciate when Shirley wants to give more technical feedback - because god knows it’s often lacking on that panel - but how she says it can ruin the feedback entirely. There’s a polite way to offer critique and Shirley massively missed the mark with Nigel. I'm assuming she saw that he was talented and wanted to push him but you’re totally right that her feedback and delivery could have easily knocked a contestant.I may possibly be biasedbut with those comments she could have broken somebody less fragile. Only positive is that more people will vote for him to counteract her vitriol.
Also “We’re in week two now” might be one of the most ridiculous things a judge has said on a show filled with ridiculous comments.