People's ability to take in detail and remember it varies wildly, I was mugged at gunpoint, I was completely calm and managed to keep it together to remember the number plate, type and colour of the truck and a description of the driver, my friend was in a similar situation and couldn't recall anything. Police will tell you that not everyone makes a good eyewitness. It is entirely possible that the parents have decided it was Lucy simply because she was the one arrested. Not a single person on here can state how anyone else will react in a set of circumstances, infact most people don't even know how they would react either because we all react completely differently and often surprise even ourselves.