Lucy Letby Case #13

Status
Thread locked. We start a new thread when they have over 1000 posts, click the blue button to see all threads for this topic and find the latest open thread.
New to Tattle Life? Click "Order Thread by Most Liked Posts" button below to get an idea of what the site is about:
I only just caught up with the last thread, so apologies if these points have been raised already.

Thoughts about the texts -

In general, I don't find them strange or incriminating and I'm aware we're only seeing a selection of her messages. It's hard to get the full picture from these short exchanges. The most revealing texts are the ones where the colleagues mention how unusual the deaths were or how Lucy is always the one on shift. Saying ''Not you again? You're having bad luck!''and that sort of thing. The fact Lucy herself referred to the deaths as 'unexpected' might be relevant to the case.

Thoughts about the parents' statements -

I know other people don't have the same view, but I really trust the parents' accounts and think it has relevance. Tbh I trust them even more than the medical reports (Maybe I shouldn't say that? Lol). Thing is, this is first-hand information - they were there in person. I'm sure the parents have good recall because they're unfortunately such traumatic memories; the circumstances of their baby's death is probably replayed in their thoughts all the time. :( And remember, the parents giving these accounts are telling the court how they were feeling at the time - not how they feel about the care retrospectively, but how LL's presence made them feel in the moment.

It's been said that 'hovering' around a patient isn't unusual, but it's clear from the testimony that whatever LL was doing was making them very uncomfortable. Maybe she was staring at them intensely rather than just being in the same room - we don't know! I'm not sure this baby was even her assigned patient at the time? Probably not.

With Baby C, the parents recount feeling ''shocked'' at LL's abrupt manner when she said ''you've said your goodbyes'' and wanted to put their poor baby into the basket* (*don't know if that's the correct term). Then another parent recalls that she ''kept going on'' about giving the baby their first bath. That hardly sounds as if her presence was welcome. A different parent remembers being told their baby was going to die by a nurse who resembled LL, and they were surprised that she was breaking the news rather than a doctor.

So you have a lot of grieving parents who were made to feel deeply uncomfortable by LL's comments or behaviour. And even when these parents (who btw were basically strangers to her) made it clear they didn't want Lucy to be involved, she still searched for them repeatedly on Facebook, including a search straight after her shift ended, the same night their baby died. That is a total invasion of their privacy and a violation of boundaries. She hardly knew these people. None of this fits with the image of her being a star nurse, either. 🤨

Apologies that this post is so long. I just don't think what the parents described can be dismissed as irrelevant. Just my opinion, of course.
To clarify at no.point has it been confirmed that it was LL. Both the situations that you mention the parents have said a nurse they BELIEVE to be LL, thats a huge difference.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 7
So I mentioned something about this in a previous thread; it's really weird to think the text messages, search history and documents in her house will have been found AFTER she was declared a suspect.

Like...imagine the police investigate and they find that there's 2 nurses who were present at every collapse. Lucy Letby and Nurse B. Do you reckon they'd find documents in Nurse B's house? And text messages about going out of her way to look after those kids? And facebook searches for the families? Probably not....because it's a pretty specific/odd profile that I can't imagine many of the nurses fit. When I think about it that way I find it so hard to imagine Lucy just happened to be present at all these deaths, and also happened to partake in so much oddly suspicious behaviour, completely by accident.

On the other hand the text messages about being upset read pretty genuine to me. They're a bit self-focused but so are most people when they're upset. I don't want to believe someone could just put on an act like this, it's horrible.
Exactly...I can't deny I've gone home with the odd handover sheet over the years .....but, soon as found it...which would have been when I got home and emptied my pockets I would have destroyed it immediately, not kept it for years, along with other " "paperwork" she's allegedly kept....just a big no!
Also...I note they wear scrubs...would be interesting to know if they actually go home in the scrubs or get changed?? ( in the days I refer to we didn't get changed)
I just can't understand her keeping this sort of paperwork for all that time...another part of " her" and this whole case that I can't explain away easily🤔
 
  • Like
  • Heart
Reactions: 11
You know the comment about "I killed them on purpose because I wasnt good enough for them"?
Could this mean that because LL wasn't getting placed in Room 1 as she wanted, she was trying to make all the other nurses look bad by having their babies die/deteriorate, so she would be the one "good enough" to be trusted to go back into the area she wanted?

She could have been wanting to make it look like colleagues were missing signs of sepsis or whatever, so that she looked like super nurse in comparison.

Edit: I know it's bonkers, but it's only just occurred to me (slow brain!), but this is probably me being Captain Obvious. I'm basically wondering if the second "them" refers to senior ward staff and not the babies like I first thought.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: 18
Hope it’s ok to do a bit of a ramble (I’m sure most people that don’t like how I post have me on ignore now 🤞🏻)

-if you accept Letby is there with an intervention before each of these near death/fatal events.. that would be hugely compelling if this was a more typical crime. If a man was repeatedly seen talking to female victims in the park they’re found dead say, this would be compelling evidence.

-If you’re inclined to believe that all the babies we’ve heard about so far (imagine how it will look by Q 🙈) were so poorly and were likely to die or have collapses whether Letby was on shift or not..despite that being at odds with a)all the witnesses at the time- both in terms of what they describe medically happening for the baby and their disbelief (including Letby) that they died B) the view of the expert witnesses who are sometimes going as far as saying ‘there is no other possibility other than air administered’ c)the statistical data for the unit in other years - why do their crashes and deaths coincide with Letby being there. Why do they correlate. That is more than bad luck.

  • Despite different circumstances making babies ABCD high risk, different possible other causes- obstruction/sepsis/size etc- why do they all crash in this extremely sudden way, why do they feature similarities such as sudden and unusual mottling, difficulty with resus, surprising and shocking elements that show that whatever was wrong had passed (baby c), were largely on an upward trajectory progress wise (‘but she was doing so well?!’, witnesses didn’t have major concerns, machinery wasn’t alerting people to slow declines etc, parents recognised they were improving. Why for the ones that survived whatever made them collapse so suddenly- didn’t show further that they were going to continue having these problems because it was some condition or illness causing them? Or does it correlate much better with a picture of sabotage - eg that away from the person trying to harm them (factitious disorder on to another) they no longer displayed this issue.
  • Then when we think of the chances of all of that being able to be explained away each time and Letby’s presence is mere coincidence (I cannot see that as possible as it is perfect evidence for this type of crime) that’s when all the other information, searches, her inappropriate/insensitive/fixated behaviour becomes significant. The note becomes significant. The inconsistencies become significant. The police interview discrepancies and oddness become significant.
Well said💖💖
 
  • Like
  • Heart
Reactions: 6
To clarify at no.point has it been confirmed that it was LL. Both the situations that you mention the parents have said a nurse they BELIEVE to be LL, thats a huge difference.
Do you think it’s likely that all the parents are wrong? There are going to be more accounts of this type of thing too.
 
  • Like
  • Heart
Reactions: 17
Exactly...I can't deny I've gone home with the odd handover sheet over the years .....but, soon as found it...which would have been when I got home and emptied my pockets I would have destroyed it immediately not kept it for years, along with other " "paperwork" she's allegedly kept....just a big no!
Also...I note they wear scrubs...would be interesting to know if they actually go home in the scrubs or get changed?? ( in the days I refer to we didn't get changed)
I just can't understand her keeping this sort of paperwork for all that time...another part of " her" and this whole case that I can't explain away easily🤔
I’d say we need to context though to how it’s been kept? Like I think people are imagining this secret file with everything stowed away nicely in it… what if it’s not the case? And say one piece was found in a pile of letters… the other in with her bills etc… I only day this because I’ve done similar, I was a dental nurse up until 4 years ago. I’d often print a second copy of our day patient list so I could mark it up, for example ‘10:30 betty smith extraction’ I’d look on her file and wrote on my sheet ‘UL3’ (upper left 3’ so I knew the tooth in advance so I knew i could prepare the correct forceps for that. Infact I’d look up every patient so I could see if they were noted for example as ‘nervous’ I’d be calmer. Allergies, so I knew what not to put out. Of course the dentist would do all this too prior to them coming in but I always did it and noted it on my second day list so we were doubly sure everything was right. Sorry I eat around the bush when making a point 😂 I’d often come home with that day list by mistake, sometimes I’d bin it, sometimes it went in the letter filer, sometimes shoved in a drawer. Depends where I was or what I was doing when I found it. On reflection, yes I should have destroyed it but there was zero malice in what I did there and sort of tells me how easily it can be done. We just don’t obvs know the context of it all as fully as I can explain myself which makes it harder. But I’ve found day lists randomly when I’ve say sorted out a drawer etc

Edited: ‘eat around the bush’ 😭😂 note to self, check spelling for the grammar police 😉 BEAT 😂
 
  • Like
  • Haha
Reactions: 12
To clarify at no.point has it been confirmed that it was LL. Both the situations that you mention the parents have said a nurse they BELIEVE to be LL, thats a huge difference.
Yes, and I believe the parents' account that it was LL. There are a limited number of neonatal nurses on the wards and I'm assuming they're all different ages, sizes etc. She's fairly recognisable from her height, hairstyle, and so on. I'd be able to pick her out of a line up. So it's not 100% certainty, but I'm inclined to believe the parents. If they weren't sure which nurse was speaking to them, I'm sure they'd say they didn't know rather than pointing fingers at a potentially innocent nurse. The interfering behaviours described by the families sound very alike, so it's not hard to believe they're referring to the same person.

In other news, I think the jurors deserve some kind of qualification at the end of this trial. 😅

1667560270006.png
 
  • Like
  • Heart
Reactions: 14
This baby ‘whose location is unconfirmed’ is confusing. Are they saying she was caring for a 3rd baby but the records don’t show where that baby was? (Room / bed). How likely is that?
 
  • Like
  • Wow
Reactions: 10
I’d say we need to context though to how it’s been kept? Like I think people are imagining this secret file with everything stowed away nicely in it… what if it’s not the case? And say one piece was found in a pile of letters… the other in with her bills etc… I only day this because I’ve done similar, I was a dental nurse up until 4 years ago. I’d often print a second copy of our day patient list so I could mark it up, for example ‘10:30 betty smith extraction’ I’d look on her file and wrote on my sheet ‘UL3’ (upper left 3’ so I knew the tooth in advance so I knew i could prepare the correct forceps for that. Infact I’d look up every patient so I could see if they were noted for example as ‘nervous’ I’d be calmer. Allergies, so I knew what not to put out. Of course the dentist would do all this too prior to them coming in but I always did it and noted it on my second day list so we were doubly sure everything was right. Sorry I eat around the bush when making a point 😂 I’d often come home with that day list by mistake, sometimes I’d bin it, sometimes it went in the letter filer, sometimes shoved in a drawer. Depends where I was or what I was doing when I found it. On reflection, yes I should have destroyed it but there was zero malice in what I did there and sort of tells me how easily it can be done. We just don’t obvs know the context of it all as fully as I can explain myself which makes it harder. But I’ve found day lists randomly when I’ve say sorted out a drawer etc

Edited: ‘eat around the bush’ 😭😂 note to self, check spelling for the grammar police 😉 BEAT 😂
Guess we are all different
Was just saying i would immediately get rid of it...without question....just my observation of it.. , as I say i would immediately bin it! I certainly wouldn't put anything in a drawer...but that's me...sure many would say what you're saying.
It's all about context and how you interpret it.. the messages, keeping the "paperwork", fb searching, the photo of the sympathy card.
 
  • Like
  • Heart
Reactions: 8
Thank you s
I'd like to apologise in advance for what I'm about to post.

''I did it on purpose because I'm not good enough to draw them'' - StatusWoe, 04/11/22

View attachment 1703201
I’m only catching up now. Ahahahaha thank you so much for this. A heavy thread deffo needs some light hearted stuff throughout 🤣🤣🤣this is brilliant. I know there’s no thread titles, and why… but if we ever had them FELLAS would defs have to be in them 🤣🤣🤣

Hope it’s ok to do a bit of a ramble (I’m sure most people that don’t like how I post have me on ignore now 🤞🏻)

-if you accept Letby is there with an intervention before each of these near death/fatal events.. that would be hugely compelling if this was a more typical crime. If a man was repeatedly seen talking to female victims in the park they’re found dead say, this would be compelling evidence.

-If you’re inclined to believe that all the babies we’ve heard about so far (imagine how it will look by Q 🙈) were so poorly and were likely to die or have collapses whether Letby was on shift or not..despite that being at odds with a)all the witnesses at the time- both in terms of what they describe medically happening for the baby and their disbelief (including Letby) that they died B) the view of the expert witnesses who are sometimes going as far as saying ‘there is no other possibility other than air administered’ c)the statistical data for the unit in other years - why do their crashes and deaths coincide with Letby being there. Why do they correlate. That is more than bad luck.

  • Despite different circumstances making babies ABCD high risk, different possible other causes- obstruction/sepsis/size etc- why do they all crash in this extremely sudden way, why do they feature similarities such as sudden and unusual mottling, difficulty with resus, surprising and shocking elements that show that whatever was wrong had passed (baby c), were largely on an upward trajectory progress wise (‘but she was doing so well?!’, witnesses didn’t have major concerns, machinery wasn’t alerting people to slow declines etc, parents recognised they were improving. Why for the ones that survived whatever made them collapse so suddenly- didn’t show further that they were going to continue having these problems because it was some condition or illness causing them? Or does it correlate much better with a picture of sabotage - eg that away from the person trying to harm them (factitious disorder on to another) they no longer displayed this issue.
  • Then when we think of the chances of all of that being able to be explained away each time and Letby’s presence is mere coincidence (I cannot see that as possible as it is perfect evidence for this type of crime) that’s when all the other information, searches, her inappropriate/insensitive/fixated behaviour becomes significant. The note becomes significant. The inconsistencies become significant. The police interview discrepancies and oddness become significant.
I agree with everything you’ve said, there’s just TOO much involving her. I also think as we move through the babies (after what I re read yesterday) the coincidences and evidence will stack up even more. Some of those later things I think people won’t be able to find alternative reasons for, like they sometimes can atm
 
Last edited:
  • Haha
  • Like
  • Heart
Reactions: 10
right, @Bakers put us all out of our misery and please explain exactly who the fella is and why he is not nice?
I feel like I literally NEED to know at this point 😂
 
  • Haha
  • Like
Reactions: 19
Yes this, how
Exactly...I can't deny I've gone home with the odd handover sheet over the years .....but, soon as found it...which would have been when I got home and emptied my pockets I would have destroyed it immediately, not kept it for years, along with other " "paperwork" she's allegedly kept....just a big no!
Also...I note they wear scrubs...would be interesting to know if they actually go home in the scrubs or get changed?? ( in the days I refer to we didn't get changed)
I just can't understand her keeping this sort of paperwork for all that time...another part of " her" and this whole case that I can't explain away easily🤔
Yes this, how many times can there be when you can no longer just explain it away🤷🏼‍♀️
 
  • Like
  • Heart
Reactions: 6
I know there’s no thread titles, and why… but if we ever had them FELLAS would defs have to be in them 🤣🤣🤣
Hypothetical thread title would definitely need to be FELLAS. 😂 Or, ''She's not a nice fella''.

(Disclaimer: I hope no one's offended by these comments. They're lighthearted, but absolutely not wanting to trivialise such a horrendous case here. Just thought I should add that.)

This baby ‘whose location is unconfirmed’ is confusing. Are they saying she was caring for a 3rd baby but the records don’t show where that baby was? (Room / bed). How likely is that?
That's really unclear. The wording makes it sound as though the baby was floating around the ward unsupervised! Is it possible the baby was being moved between rooms or something?
 
  • Like
  • Haha
Reactions: 17
This baby ‘whose location is unconfirmed’ is confusing. Are they saying she was caring for a 3rd baby but the records don’t show where that baby was? (Room / bed). How likely is that?
I’m also confused by this, I don’t understand why this has been brought up, although at least now we know she was only caring for this other baby until 10.45pm, or is it to imply that LL was just very very busy that night🤷🏼‍♀️

Hypothetical thread title would definitely need to be FELLAS. 😂 Or, ''She's not a nice fella''.

(Disclaimer: I hope no one's offended by these comments. They're lighthearted, but absolutely not wanting to trivialise such a horrendous case here. Just thought I should add that.)
Yes I hope everyone agrees, sometimes we need a bit of lighthearted humour on here, or something to diffuse potential tension (don’t mean today) and I hope no one thinks any of us are trivialising anything, because we all know how horrendous it is. But fellas does seem to make everyone laugh a little
 
  • Like
Reactions: 14
Yes this, how

Yes this, how many times can there be when you can no longer just explain it away🤷🏼‍♀️
At the beginning, maybe first couple of weeks i was able to make some sense or reason out of some things...even " the note" I tried
to remain impartial about....there's just so much when all put together that's so difficult to explain away.
I continue to try, as I want to hear all the evidence obviously before making a definite decision...but right now I don't see her as innocent!!
I am so interested if they went home in those scrubs...cos if they didn't and had to get changed for cross infection purposes then she really had no reason that I can see, to still have hold of any of the paperwork that was found at her home🤔
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: 14
This baby ‘whose location is unconfirmed’ is confusing. Are they saying she was caring for a 3rd baby but the records don’t show where that baby was? (Room / bed). How likely is that?
My baby was moved around a lot, sometimes doctors would come to his bed thinking he was someone else vice versa. Not ideal tho
 
  • Like
  • Wow
Reactions: 10
Just had a fourth wiki page created!!! We are going to end up with the biggest wiki on tattle. I couldn’t fit child C on to the same page as child a and b. Just so many witnesses. Do you think this is working (volume of information) or should I start adding links to witnesses instead and keep the wiki smaller?


This is how it’s currently organised:

Lucy Letby case page contains live reporting links, opening statements and the child section where evidence is currently being heard.

Lucy Letby Case 2 page contains evidence heard for Child A & B (twins)

Lucy Letby Case 3 page contains evidence heard for Child C

Lucy Letby Case 4 page contains the child sections where evidence has not yet been heard.
 
  • Like
  • Heart
Reactions: 25
At the beginning, maybe first couple of weeks inwas able to make some sense or reason out of some things...even " the note" i tries to remain impartial about....there's just so much when all put together that's so difficult to explain away.
I continue to try as I want to hear all the evidence obviously before making a definite decision...but right now I don't see her as innocent!!
I am so interested if they went home in those scrubs...cos if they didn't and had to get changed for cross infection purposes then she really had no reason that I can see, to still have hold of any of the paperwork that was found at her home🤔
I think many of us agree on this, it just becomes too much, whether it’s coincidences or explaining things away. There are some valid points that have been given for why LL may have done some things, but like you I feel there’s now just too much. And very good point about the scrubs. Be interesting to see what the prosecution and defence say about these handover sheets when we get to it. I also think the more babies we hear about, the less explaining things away there will be, it will be very hard to explain some evidence soon I think

Just had a fourth wiki page created!!! We are going to end up with the biggest wiki on tattle. I couldn’t fit child C on to the same page as child a and b. Just so many witnesses. Do you think this is working (volume of information) or should I start adding links to witnesses instead and keep the wiki smaller?


This is how it’s currently organised:

Lucy Letby case page contains live reporting links, opening statements and the child section where evidence is currently being heard.

Lucy Letby Case 2 page contains evidence heard for Child A & B (twins)

Lucy Letby Case 3 page contains evidence heard for Child C

Lucy Letby Case 4 page contains the child sections where evidence has not yet been heard.
You’ve done an amazing job with the wiki, so personally I think however you decide to organise it will be perfect. Sorry I can’t give any helpful suggestions, but I really trust your judgment on this one. Just to add, I do think having all the info there though is preferable for me rather than links (especially when trying to find something specific like I was yesterday). But as I say whatever you think is best is good enough for me
 
  • Like
  • Heart
Reactions: 11
I think many of us agree on this, it just becomes too much, whether it’s coincidences or explaining things away. There are some valid points that have been given for why LL may have done some things, but like you I feel there’s now just too much. And very good point about the scrubs. Be interesting to see what the prosecution and defence say about these handover sheets when we get to it. I also think the more babies we hear about, the less explaining things away there will be, it will be very hard to explain some evidence soon I think
I'm going to be like a dog with a bone till I get an answer about the scrubs!!
The whole idea of them is to minimise cross infection..and usually when scrubs are worn..they are changed into and out of before and after shift....and laundered on site ....if that's the case then I'm even more adamant about my thoughts as to how she had paperwork at home!
Maybe they did go home in them..but that's another story🤦‍♀️
 
  • Like
  • Heart
Reactions: 13
Because it's not necessarily a reflection on her guilt/innocence BUT it is on the type of character she is, therefore it can be deemed relevant.

If a lady in her early 20s is dressing like a middle aged woman, then it raises the questions about her social group.

All of us are just speculating on a gossip board, what any of us say has no baring on the trial.
yes, im not saying we can’t discuss it? just offering my own point of view :) if anything i must be the weird one because her looks genuinely haven’t crossed my mind in terms of guilt - instead i suppose i took the naive view at first of “surely a nurse wouldn’t do something so evil” but as has been correctly pointed out, it’s absolutely possible!
 
  • Like
Reactions: 16
Status
Thread locked. We start a new thread when they have over 1000 posts, click the blue button to see all threads for this topic and find the latest open thread.