Same, there are some YouTubers that I’ve watched for years but they have lost the momentum of growth which is what I meant by “shelf life”. We all have a finite amount of time to spend on the content of these people and, when personality is the main factor, if they pivot, or you do, the connection and value is more often than not diminished. Plus there are new channels popping up all the time, it seems a super risky strategy to me.There are some you tubers I've watched he'd now for years (not travel vloggers) even if there content hasn't changed all that much I still tune in because they have actual personality. I liked Katherine's old travel vlogs because she seemed just like a normal person. Now it's all aesthetic and no substance. She likes Japan but I couldn't tell you from her vlogs if she has a favourite anime or manga, just that she thinks the characters are cute and she likes going to the 'conveeny'
And 100% agree with everything else. I really admired her a few years ago and thought she was authentic. Guess not.