Notice
Thread ordered by most liked posts - View normal thread.

Boogs

VIP Member
Sadly some women prioritise having a man over their kids. My mother is one of them. She experienced CSA and definitely has an undiagnosed personality disorder. She would meet a bloke and bring him straight home getting engaged 2 days later. Despite her childhood experiences (which sadly she doesn’t see as abuse) she had no protective feelings towards her kids. She saw me as a rival. I remember a boyfriend of hers making me really uncomfortable coming and lying on my single bed asking me to read to him. She came into the room and was clearly angry telling him to get downstairs. For a minute I felt grateful until I realised it was me she was angry with when she hissed at me through gritted teeth ‘he’s my boyfriend not yours.’ I was about 10 at the time.
 
  • Sad
  • Wow
  • Like
Reactions: 55
Her mother should have called social services. There’s no excuse. If they removed Isabelle she would still be alive and maybe even placed with family while AW sorted out her mess of a life. She couldn’t even look after herself let alone a toddler. I have direct experience of having my kids removed due to my own alcoholism and though it was traumatic for all it literally saved my life and allowed us to become a family again once I was better. I also have a family member who had a chaotic life with drugs, alcohol and violent men. Her own mother reported it to social and her kids now live with family members and are thriving, she didn’t turn her life around at the time but still had contact so they only saw her at her best. I hate seeing all these videos of “social kidnapped my kids for no reason and I’ve not seen them for six months despite having done nothing wrong”. Sure Jan! It adds to the mistrust around reporting and prevents kids receiving the help they need. We all know SS get it wrong and make mistakes sometimes by not removing when they should but if someone had been contacted on that day the police would have used emergency protection powers to remove Isabelle to a place of safety when they saw the state of the adults in charge of her. There are so many failings among professionals in this case (and others) and each one was a missed opportunity to save that poor little girl. But none of them knew what the family did because nobody told them.
 
  • Heart
  • Like
Reactions: 42

Borrible

VIP Member
Honestly it's not rocket science.

Random bloke (who doesn't want to meet you) moves in with your daughter and then very quickly your grandchild has a broken leg and bruising? Do me a favour
 
  • Like
Reactions: 41

Borrible

VIP Member
Sadly some women prioritise having a man over their kids. My mother is one of them. She experienced CSA and definitely has an undiagnosed personality disorder. She would meet a bloke and bring him straight home getting engaged 2 days later. Despite her childhood experiences (which sadly she doesn’t see as abuse) she had no protective feelings towards her kids. She saw me as a rival. I remember a boyfriend of hers making me really uncomfortable coming and lying on my single bed asking me to read to him. She came into the room and was clearly angry telling him to get downstairs. For a minute I felt grateful until I realised it was me she was angry with when she hissed at me through gritted teeth ‘he’s my boyfriend not yours.’ I was about 10 at the time.
I had a similar parent. My mother kicked me out when I was 15 when her latest bloke took an inappropriate shine to me. She didn't kick me out to save me from him. She kicked me out because she was jealous! Before that, I'd had years of various blokes of hers pinching my arse, offering to give me 'massages', kissing me full on the mouth etc. And she let them. We've not been in contact for decades and we never will.
 
  • Sad
  • Heart
  • Like
Reactions: 40

Tanley

VIP Member
I will never understand why the grandmother didn’t take Isabelle to stay with her that night. Her daughter straight up said she needed a few cans to cope with the stress of looking after her. As far as the gran knew, Isabelle had broken her leg in an accident, had a virus afterwards, and ‘looked like an abused child’ because of all her bruises. Just bring the poor bloody kid home with you for the weekend, let mum drink herself unconscious without the responsibility of a two year old.
AW may very well have refused, not wanting her mother to see the full extent of poor Isabelle’s injuries. But the gran didn’t even try to take her, just said it upset her too much to see her deteriorate like that. She knew Isabelle wasn’t being properly looked after, she knew there was a new boyfriend on the scene, she knew her daughter was planning to drink and even bought the alcohol round for her.
I know she didn’t abuse Isabelle herself, but she certainly didn’t protect her either.
 
  • Like
  • Sad
  • Heart
Reactions: 40

Tanley

VIP Member
The above sounds like it was the mother that caused Isabelle’s fatal head injury.
How cold do you have to be to call your two year old a Cnut when she is in pain from an untreated broken leg :mad:
And then the Nan pops round with ten cans of Stella and says it’s too upsetting to see her granddaughter deteriorating :mad:
Not to mention AW stabbing herself and smashing up the kitchen.
This poor little girl was in a horrible and abusive home situation even without the scummy boyfriend moving in and SA her :cry:
 
  • Like
  • Sad
  • Angry
Reactions: 38
Day 9

Warning graphic details

Read bottom up…TW medical evidence!!!

3:57pm08/07/26
Case adjourned
The hearing has been adjourned for the evening and Dr Hoggard will conclude his evidence tomorrow morning.

3:51pm08/07/26
Internal examination
The jury hears how the pathologist was able to rule out any natural cause of the toddler's death.
Dr Hoggard says a dense bruise were discovered in Isabelle's intestinal tract measuring 11cm by 8cm on the fatty tissue underneath the intestines.
He says the bruising could be the result of a 'very forceful' punch but can't provide a more accurate measurement than that.
Dealing with the toddler's bruising on her scalp, the doctor says there were three injuries on the right hand side of her head.
He says there was a large area of dense bruising covering almost the entire left side of her scalp.
"It will have been significant force to cause bruising across almost the entire of the left side of the scalp," he says.
The image of Isabelle's head showed a fracture running down the centre of the head and was 5cms long, he says.
He says some of the bruising to the right side of head could be associated with the fracture but the bruising to the left side was not associated with the fracture of the skull.
The final injury was to the left knee joint of the toddler which showed large internal bruising measuring 5cm by 2.5cm.

3:33pm08/07/26
Injuries to limbs
Dr Hoggard says there were a series of bruises on Isabelle's shoulders and arms.
On her left leg, there were a series of bruises near her knee and one on her ankle with a large red abrasion on her foot.
Dealing with Isabelle's right leg there are another series of bruises around her knee and a large bruise below her kneecap with a further bruise on her calf.

3:25pm08/07/26
Rear torso injuries
The hearing has resumed after a short break for the jurors.
Dr Hoggard is now dealing with injuries to Isabelle's rear torso.
He is taking the jury through the ten areas of bruising or scratching across the toddler's back, including a series of circular bruises consistent with gripping.
The jury hears how there were signs of some of the injuries starting to heal with scabs forming on the skin.
The doctor confirms that all of the bruising was 'very obvious' to the eye.

2:50pm08/07/26
Bottom injuries - warning graphic details
Jurors are now looking at a computer generated image of the bruising discovered around Isabelle's bottom.
Dr Hoggard says there were a series of five separate injuries in an around her anus, including a tear in her skin.
He says he conducted further investigations in the same area which will be dealt with later in his evidence.
The jury hears that the tear would have been 'extremely painful'.

2:45pm08/07/26
Torso injuries - warning graphic details
Jurors are now looking at computer generated images of the marks and bruising recorded on Isabelle's torso.
The image shows several large bruises on the front of her chest including nine separate scratches measuring up to 9cm long.
Dealing with injuries on the lower section of Isabelle's torso, Dr Hoggard says there were multiple bruises on the right side of her body around the abdomen area, including circular bruises which are often caused by forceful gripping of the torso.
Dr Hoggard tells the jury that all of the injuries were 'very obvious, immediately'.
On the left side of Isabelle's abdomen were another eight injuries including ones close to the pubic area of her body.
Mr Wright asks the pathologist about the bruising to the abdomen and whether they were caused by a single incident or more than one.
He says each bruise is a singular injury, 'the impression I formed was there was forceful gripping of the abdomen' - he says those type of injuries are always concerning as signs of physical abuse.
He says there is one set of marks which are likely to have been caused by medical intervention.
The pathologist says there were four areas of bruising around the toddler's vagina, with haemorrhages in the area, he says they could be a marker of trauma but they are of no significant meaning to them.
He says he believes the bruising is separate but they are almost merging together. "They indicate there has been some blunt force trauma to the pubic area," he says.

2:12pm08/07/26
Facial injuries
Dr Hoggard tells the jury that he records all of the injuries discovered on Isabelle's body.
He says there is no relevance to the numbering of the injuries and jurors are now looking at computer generated images of the toddler's injuries.
Jurors are shown an image of the four injuries recorded on her head, including large bruises on her forehead and a scab on the left side of her scalp.
He says that the positioning of the three bruises indicates there was more than one impact.
Jurors are hearing details about further injuries to her face and neck.
The image shows five separate injuries including a large bruise on the left cheek and jawline which were orange in colour.
When asked about the bruising to Isabelle's ear, he says it is always concerning to a pathologist because it is difficult to injury your ear accidentally and could be a sign of physical abuse.
On the right side of her face, there was more bruising around her nose.
Returning to the left side of her face, the pathologist is describing further bruising and abrasions around her mouth area.
Isabelle also had red and blue bruising with further abrasions - together it could be caused by contact with a rough surface, he says.
In total there were 24 visible injuries on the toddler's head and neck.
When asked what he saw during the facial examinations, he says: "It was covered in bruises and abrasions. They were very obvious."

2:00pm08/07/26
Pathologist report
Dr Hoggard, a Home Office pathologist, carried out the post mortem of Isabelle Welsh on September 16 last year at the Sheffield Children's Hospital.
He says he didn't need to go to the scene in Thornaby but was given a lot of the toddler's medical history in the time leading up to her death.
The court hears how he listened to the police interview of Isabelle's mother, Alexandra Walker.
Mr Wright, prosecuting, is taking the pathologist through his evidence for the jury.
Dr Hoggard recorded all the marks of medical intervention as well the multiple other injuries found on the two-year-old's body.

12:28pm08/07/26
Early lunch
The trial has adjourned for an early lunch after the conclusion of Dr McPartland's evidence.
The next witness to give evidence is pathologist Dr Sam Hoggard.

12:03pm08/07/26
Report conclusion
Dr McPartland says there was no history of accidental trauma which could explain the skull fracture in this case.
She says: "There was no history provided of an accidental fall that could explain the skull fracture in this case.
"In the absence of an underlying medical cause the finding of multiple haemorrhages in both eyes, the severe optic nerve haemorrhages in both eyes and orbital soft tissue haemorrhages.
"In combination with the brain injury, it is indicative of a severe traumatic head injury. In the absence of a history of an accidental head trauma of appropriate severity - it is highly suggestive of an abusive head trauma."

11:50am08/07/26
Injury cause
Dr McPartland tells the jury she has seen the report provided by Dr Daniel Duplessis, a neuropathologist.
She says he identified two head injuries - one around four days old and a significant trauma at the time of Isabelle's death.
The doctor says the damage to Isabelle's eyes was caused during the significant trauma.
She says the injuries could have been caused by shaking but also could involve impact damage.
Dr McPartland says there is a timeframe of within 24 hours of death but cannot give a definitive time the injuries were suffered.
She says there was a tiny area on one eye which could have occurred at the same time as a previous injury.

11:41am08/07/26
Major findings
Dr McPartland says she applied a number of specialist dyes to the eyes to carry out further investigations into healing responses in an attempt to age the injuries.
She says there was no evidence that the injuries were beginning to heal.
In summary, she says Isabelle's eyes appeared to be normal prior to the injuries being suffered.
Dr McPartland concludes that the multiple haemorrhages were linked to abusive head trauma rather than accidental head trauma.

11:25am08/07/26
Microscopic examinations
Closer examination revealed that both eyes suffered multiple haemorrhages.
Dr McPartland says there was damage to her retinas and the haemorrhages were present throughout her eyeballs.
She says: "The presence in both eyes is a pattern that is seen in abusive head injury rather than accidental head injury."
Dealing with the level of force needed to cause the injuries, she says: "A forceful and repetitive movement on the neck and impact."
She confirms that the injuries could have only been caused accidentally by a fall from height, a car crash or having the head crushed.
Mr Wright asks the doctor what the consequences could have been for Isabelle is she had survived the head injury. She says it is difficult to predict unless she regained consciousness.

11:12am08/07/26
Injury details
Dr McPartland says there was evidence of haemorrhaging from the blood vessels in Isabelle's eyes.
The jury hears how the left eye had suffered bleeding to the optic nerve sheath which would not occur in a healthy person.
She says there were numerous haemorrhages in the toddler's eye - too many to count.
The doctor says there was evidence of blood clotting which indicates that there had been a survival period of some hours but it is impossible to give a definitive time period.
Dealing with Isabelle's right eye, the doctor says she found she had suffered bleeding to the optic nerve sheath and multiple retinal haemorrhages - again too numerous to count.
She says the injuries are consistent with infliction rather than accidental.

10:53am08/07/26
Eye damage
Richard Wright KC, prosecuting, is taking the witness through her evidence.
The doctor tells the jury that there are a limited number of eye specialists working in the pathology field and has carried out 150 investigations since she trained almost a decade ago.
She confirms that she has worked alongside all the other medical experts involved in the post mortem of the toddler.
The jury hears how an initial examination is carried out before dissection is carried out and microscopic examination is performed.
Dr McPartland examined both of the toddler's eyes as part her investigations.

10:42am08/07/26
First witness
Dr Jo McPartland is a pathologist who works in the Alder Hey Children’s hospital in Liverpool. She has developed a particular specialism in ophthalmic pathology.
She will be taking the jury through the eye injuries Isabelle Welsh suffered.

10:39am08/07/26
Trial resumes
The jury did not sit yesterday but here is a round up of the evidence they listened to on Monday - Thornaby mother denied murdering her two-year-old daughter
I don't have any words adequate to comment on this as it is beyond harrowing. Those injuries are absolutely horrific and as some of them were older how did the grandparents not see what was happening. That poor poor child.
 
  • Like
  • Sad
Reactions: 38

TheMiceInTheShed

VIP Member
This just defies belief. Too upsetting for her?? How the fuck did she think it was for Isabelle then?

I cannot envisage a scenario where I could see a baby in this state and not somehow find a way to remove her from the situation.
Agree.

I couldn't turn my back on a suffering rat caught in a trap, never mind a BABY - and my own grandchild at that!

If I suspected there was anything amiss (and she obviously did) I would have moved Hell and high water to get the authorities involved somehow, I would have offered to have her for a sleepover and taken her to hospital, I would have alerted the police and social services, I would have rung the NSPCC. I would have just gone in, if necessary and carried that baby out of the house away from that drunken, drug addled pair of sh*tballs.

This isn't a situation where the child's abuse has been hidden - it has been on full show - to the extent that it was "too upsetting" to look at, and she just pushed it out of her mind. Both "grandparents" did. I hope they rot.
 
  • Like
  • Heart
Reactions: 38

bigmac22

Well-known member
Sadly, I think as it doesn't have the unique 'adopted and killed by gay couple' element it just doesn't have the same shock factor for the newspapers to want to run the story.
Agreed - I also think there could be a class element to it as well.

Part of the shock in Preston’s case was because his adoptive parents were portrayed as respectable, educated and middle class – the sort of people society “expects” to provide a safe and loving home.

Isabelle’s case sadly fits a stereotype we’ve seen reported so many times before and have probably become quite desensitised to. Absent father, mum who didn’t work and was constantly drunk/high, had introduced and moved in a new drug dealer boyfriend after only a couple of weeks and despite the obvious signs of abuse, continued to prioritise that relationship over her daughter’s safety.

It’s a dreadful set of circumstances, but because it fits a familiar narrative, I think it attracts less attention. Neither child deserved what happened to them and both cases should be front page news.
 
  • Like
  • Sad
Reactions: 37

Beverliara

VIP Member
Peter Wright KC has successfully put the killer(s) of Preston Davey and now Isabelle Welsh behind bars for hopefully the rest of their sorry lives....
 
  • Like
  • Heart
Reactions: 36

TheMiceInTheShed

VIP Member
Do you know he didn't do that or wasn't trying to at least?
Why are you trying to make excuses for this sorry apology of a father? IMO He didn't care. He's milking the death of his daughter to gain attention and sympathy for himself, and is taking no responsibility for what happened to her. This didn't happen suddenly out of the blue - this was long-term sadistic abuse that people could easily see. That HE could have seen if he had given enough of a damn to visit his daughter.

That poor child didn't have a single person in the world who was looking out for her welfare. Not one.

You could just as easily say it wasn't Isabelle's mother's fault because she was a hopeless alcoholic and couldn't parent properly. It wasn't her step-father's fault because he was a drug addict and couldn't help himself. It wasn't the grandparents' fault because they thought it was only due to drink and drugs that Isabelle was being beaten, and they didn't now she was being sexually abused. You could excuse all of these people in one way or another - but every one of them is an ADULT. They could all choose their behaviour. Isabelle couldn't - she was trapped in a hell not of her own making and the adults who should have been protecting her didn't give a sh*t.

Isabelle doesn't need people weeping behind her tiny coffin now she's dead. What she needed was someone - even just one person - who cherished and cared for and protected her when she was alive. It's not a lot to ask, is it? ONE PERSON who would love a child enough to look after her? Or even love her enough to give her up for adoption if they couldn't cope. But there wasn't even one.

(I haven't been able to bring myself to read most of her case - it's too harrowing - but where was social services in this? Even hospital staff ere intimidated by the mother, so what wasn't social services looking very closely at AW's behaviour? Isabelle was a baby - and she was failed by everybody around her.)
 
  • Like
  • Heart
Reactions: 36

bigmac22

Well-known member
Hopefully this helps with the timeline, the accuracy of the available reporting is inconsistent causing confusion.

Prosecution have demonstrated a pattern of neglect and hostility towards Isabelle weeks before her final collapse.
CCTV visually shows AW growing highly annoyed and verbally frustrated with her crying child limping around the home due to a broken leg. Rather than comforting her, AW snaps at the crying toddler, aggressively “What do you want?”

Richard Wright KC said “There are a lot of incidents of the two drinking and drugs being taken, and the prosecution say, unusual and sometimes aggressive behaviour being caught on CCTV” There were instances where Walker was getting “irritated” by Isabelle's behaviour. On one occasion Walker said her daughter was “behaving like a cunt”

On the 12th of September, Isabelle was in obvious pain, whimpering, screaming, and crying for her mother. The court heard that she had developed a bruise on her forehead and had started vomiting again. CCTV evidence showed AW repeatedly telling the toddler to “sit up!”

In the afternoon, AW messaged her mother to complain that Isabelle was throwing up again and that seeing her daughter like that was causing her “stress”, she requested that her mother bring her food, nappies, and 10 cans of Stella to “help her cope” Knowing her mother was coming to drop off the shopping, AW messaged HS trying to persuade him to meet her mother. AW reassured him in the text that her mum “won't bite” but, HS refused the interaction, and AW later claimed to her mother that he couldn't meet her because he suffered from severe “anxiety”

4.46pm A telephone recording captured the sound of a whimpering Isabelle lying on top of AW, she told the person on the other end of the line that her daughter “really isn't well”

5.30pm AW’s mother and stepfather arrived at the Hartington Close property to drop off the requested shopping and alcohol. Her mother Claire later stated it had become too upsetting to see her granddaughter in that deteriorating condition.

7pm AW was alone in the house with Isabelle a neighbour reported hearing a loud thud coming from the property.

9pm HS returned to the home. At this point, the couple began a heavy session of drinking and substance use.

The couple continued drinking alcohol and smoking cannabis from a bong late into the night and until 3am on September 13th, completely ignoring the toddler's ongoing medical distress.

AW called her mother and a friend (Sarah Ayre??) while heavily under the influence of alcohol. During these recorded calls, she aggressively insisted that she had been stabbed in her arm, chest, and leg during a separate incident where cannabis was allegedly stolen from her home. When challenged by the person on the other end of the line about her drinking, AW angrily denied that she was “making a drama” before lashing out around 2am and striking her kitchen cupboard doors. Sarah told the court AW’s speech sounded unusual, she was muttering her words, leading her to believe AW was “on something” at the time.

CCTV shows AW was highly agitated, dramatic, and focused entirely on her own historical grievances while Isabelle, was severely injured in the house. The home security footage actually captured her stabbing herself with a kitchen knife during the same time frame, while her boyfriend HS, smoked cannabis nearby.

AW did not leave the house during the hours leading up to her daughter’s collapse on September 13th. AW falsely claims she briefly left the house to visit a local shop & would wake Isabelle when HS returned the prosecution say this was a

2.53pm, AW messaged HS stating she intended to wake Isabelle up when he returned from the shops. She added that if she didn't wake the toddler now, Isabelle would be “up all night” Following this exchange, HS was the one captured on CCTV leaving the property permanently shortly after 3pm.

HS had been awake and in “sole care” of Isabelle during the morning while AW remained in bed upstairs. HS told AW that he had put the toddler down to sleep.

Isabelle was neither seen nor heard on the internal home CCTV during the morning September 13th. The prosecution highlighted the lack of presence to support their argument that Isabelle was already incapacitated or critically injured early in the day.

3pm HS left the property, internal CCTV and court records show that AW remained inside the house, completely failing to check on or help her dying daughter. However AW told her family that she checked on Isabelle every 10 minutes.

Within 10 minutes of her HS leaving the house at 3pm, AW’s primary focus was not providing medical care. Instead, she was running Google searches for why her toddler was bleeding.

3.15pm Internal CCTV captured AW walking up the stairs and speaking to herself, saying, “You're scaring me” She then ran another search for “What should I do if my child has blood in his stool”

3.20pm Rather than leaving the property to seek help or calling an ambulance, AW walked into the kitchen to smoke a cigarette!

4pm Still inside the property, AW called her stepfather instead of emergency services. Knowing her stepfather, Dan Ackroyd, was on his way, AW actively took the cannabis bong out of the kitchen and discarded it next to an outdoor bin to hide the drug use.

4.14pm Her stepfather arrived at the property, found the toddler unresponsive at the bottom of the stairs, and ordered AW to call 999.
Thanks for posting this.

Something else that has stuck with me is that the mum posted photos of her freshly dyed hair on Facebook on 12th September. She found the time to dye her hair, take selfies and share them online while Isabelle had endured horrific abuse and was likely by that point, critically ill and dying.

I genuinely don’t think there’s a sentence in the English language that could adequately describe how vile that is. I’m heartbroken for Isabelle.
 
  • Sad
  • Like
  • Wow
Reactions: 35

Happytobedivorced

Well-known member
Updates from today - read from bottom up:

3:45pm16/07/26
Hearing resumes
The jury are hearing some private conversations made by Walker to friends and family.
She described Isabelle as 'a little f****** s***' and had bitten her on occasion - typical toddler tantrums she says.
Walker says she didn't mean anything when she said it during what she says was a private conversation.
She again reiterates that she has never hurt her daughter at all.

3:08pm16/07/26
Nappy change
Walker says she changed Isabelle's nappy and saw the blood in her nappy.
She says she put Isabelle in some pyjamas before putting her on the floor and calling her stepdad for help.
Mr Lumley questions her about what she told police about Isabelle's injuries to her private parts.
"I did not do that," she says. "I was frightened and was being accused of raping my own daughter. I didn't know how to explain the bruises."
The barrister asks why it frightening, she says 'it was all frightening when these police interviews occurred'.
She says she didn't know the answers to all the questions but accepts she shouldn't have told them that she had got up with Isabelle.
When asked why she didn't say anything about the bruises to her genitals, she says she didn't think anything abusive had happened and she 'lost her mind' when police came in and told her that her daughter had been raped and murdered.
"I lost my mind," she says. "I can't believe this has happened."
3:02pm16/07/26
Head injury
Mr Lumley is asking Walker about the day Isabelle suffered her fatal head injury.
He asks whether she was checking on her every 15 minutes, she says 'I panicked about what was being suggested at the time'.
Walker accepts that she lied to make herself look better.
She tells the jury that she went upstairs to wake her daughter up at around 3pm.
Walker says when she brought her daughter downstairs she didn't have pyjama bottoms on, she was only wearing a nappy on her bottom half.
Mr Lumley asks her about the statements she made about Isabelle following her death.
2:50pm16/07/26
Self-inflicted injuries
Mr Lumley asks Walker why she told police that Isabelle has inflicted some of the injuries on herself.
"I was explaining something that did happen but not on that day." she says.
Walker had told officers that her daughter could be clumsy and was prone to throwing tantrums where she could herself.
2:39pm16/07/26
Isabelle's injuries
Mr Lumley is dealing with the events of September 13, the day when Isabelle suffered her fatal injuries.
Walker says she confronted Simpson about the bruises she spotted on her daughter's body and accepts that she lied to police about putting her to bed on the morning.
The barrister asks her why she described some of Isabelle's bruises as 'fingerprint marks' - she replies 'that's what they looked like'.
Walker denies that she was responsible for causing the injuries and maintains she mentioned it to police because 'that's what they looked like'.
2:32pm16/07/26
Timeline evidence
Mr Lumley asks her if she did anything to make her cry. She says 'no' and denies doing anything to her daughter.
Walker denies that she struggled with Isabelle's behaviour. She says 'I loved her, she was the best thing in my life'.
2:21pm16/07/26
Evidence resumes
Mr Lumley has resumed cross examining Alexandra Walker following the lunch break.
He is asking her about her actions when Isabelle suffered her leg injury on August 20.
She says she cuddled her daughter and she seemed to settle down.
"I didn't know her leg was broken or I would have taken her to hospital sooner than I did," she says.
12:51pm16/07/26
CCTV footage
Walker denies that she was allowing Isabelle to care for herself after she was recorded playing in the garden on her own adding that she was probably doing housework at the time.
She tells the jury that if Isabelle woke up during the night she would go up and care for her.
Mr Lumley asks Walker whether drinking Stella made her aggressive. She denies that was the case and when she was shouting at people it was because she was justifiably angry about something and would have shouted whether she was drinking or not.
Walker admits that she had drank at least ten cans of Stella in an 'epic' session.
She describes herself as a 'lover not a fighter' after Mr Lumley asks her about a threat she made to assault someone.
Walker says it was all talk and she had never been violent in her life.
Walker accepts that the first thing on the list when her mother wanted know what she wanted from Asda - she says Stella.
The hearing has adjourned for lunch.
12:41pm16/07/26
Drinking habits
Mr Lumley asks Walker about how she described her drinking habits to police when she told them she only really drank on a weekend.
She accepts that the CCTV shows she drinks often - 'almost every night'.
He asks her whether drinking affected the way she cared for Isabelle. She says: "No, when I did drink Isabelle was always in bed."
She tells the jury that she always shut the kitchen door when she was drinking or smoking.
Mr Lumley asks her about the footage of her waving a knife around in the kitchen.
She says it was an 'embarrassing thing to do' but she couldn't really remember what she was doing because she was intoxicated.
He asks her what she would have done if Isabelle woke up. She says: "I would have a coffee and sort myself out."
She accepts that her own CCTV caught her throwing up in her kitchen sink.
12:34pm16/07/26
Simpson relationship
Walker tells the court that they had never had an argument and described Simpson as a 'very calm person'.
She accepts that there are numerous clips of Simpson playing with Isabelle in the garden of her Thornaby home.
Walker accepts that she called her daughter a 'c***' during a conversation with a friend but says it wasn't in the presence of Isabelle and there was nothing malicious about it.
"I wish I could take back what I said especially after what happened," she adds.
She says 'I did not resent my daughter' and accepts that Simpson did smoke cannabis and it made him more relaxed.
12:26pm16/07/26
Broken leg
Mr Lumley asks why she wanted her mother to take Isabelle to hospital after the doctor told her to. She explains that she had been affected when she had taken Isabelle previously.
Walker says she 'strongly believes' that Isabelle getting her leg stuck in the cot rails was the cause of her injury.
She says she would never hurt her daughter because is 'my flesh and blood'.
Mr Lumley asks her whether Simpson had a good relationship with Isabelle and she says 'yes'.
She accepts that he bought her shoes and played with her in the park.
Walker accepts that she never saw Simpson harm Isabelle in anyway.
12:20pm16/07/26
Isabelle's routine
Mr Lumley asks her about what she told police about Isabelle's usual morning routine.
Walker accepts she told lies to the officers when she told them that Isabelle woke up at 8am.
He asks her why she told 'lie after lie after lie'. She says she was frightened and in shock. "I was an idiot, I admit that. I was in a very fragile state of mind."
Walker accepts that she lied about changing Isabelle's nappy and didn't see her awake that morning.
She accepts that she didn't take Isabelle straight to hospital after she hurt her leg but says she did take her straight after the doctor told her to.
Mr Lumley asks whether she was trying to give the impression that she acted straightaway. Walker accepts that the way it could look and that it could have given a misleading impression.
He asks whether she was protecting herself, she replies: "You could say that but my head was not in the best of places."
12:13pm16/07/26
Police interviews
Mr Lumley asks Walker if she understood that she was under arrest for suspicion of murder of her own daughter, she says 'yes'.
Walker says she was telling the truth when she said she would 'do whatever it took to help them get to the truth'.
Mr Lumley asks what she did to help. She says: "yes, I lied but I was frightened - I didn't want to be called a bad parent.
"It was scary being arrested for murder and rape of my daughter."
The barrister asks her about when she told them she wanted to 'honest' throughout the police interviews.
She accepts that she told lies about getting up with Isabelle on the morning of February 13.
In her second interview, she told police that Isabelle was her usual self on the morning but now accepts that she didn't tell the truth about what happened.
She says she did go check on her twice while she was in bed and maintains that she appeared happy and was talking in her sleep.
12:04pm16/07/26
Cross examination
Mr Lumley, representing Simpson, is now cross examining Walker.
He asks her is she has told the truth in her evidence and she says 'yes'.
He queries why should told lies about looking after Isabelle on the morning she suffered her fatal head injuries. Walker accepts that she did lie to police and paramedics.
She also accepts she lied or told half-truths about her university degree, her own health and internet searches.
Walker says she decided to tell the truth 'when Isabelle died' and when 'I was sent to prison for something I didn't do'.
She says she told the truth when she started to give evidence, saying 'I didn't know that me daughter was being abused'.
When asked when was the first time she told the truth, she says 'when she sat down with her solicitor'. She explains that she was frightened before then.
11:47am16/07/26
Police lies
Walker accepts she lied to police when she told them it was her who got up with Isabelle in the morning. She says she was 'ashamed' of still being in bed at 11am because she had been drinking heavily the night before.
She tells the jury she wasn't mentally fit enough to answer some of the questions police asked her.
The 26-year-old says she never caused any injuries to Isabelle or wanted any harm to come to Isabelle.
When asked how it feels being held in custody accused of her daughter's murder. "It's like living a nightmare which you can't wake up from," she says.
And when asked how it makes her feel to be accused of sexually abusing Isabelle, she says: "I'm angry and heartbroken."
Walker has concluded her evidence in chief and will shortly be cross examined but the prosecution barrister, Richard Wright KC, and Simpson's lawyer, Nicholas Lumley KC.
11:43am16/07/26
Hearing resumes
Mr McKone has resumed taking Walker through her evidence following the fire alarm test at Teesside Crown Court.
He is asking Walker about where she got her information from about Isabelle's wellbeing on the morning she was fatally injured.
She says all the details about her having her breakfast and being put down for a sleep came from Simpson.
While speaking to the police in the hospital Walker told them that they would 'need to look' at Simpson.
She told a nurse that she was 'starting to think Simpson had done something' after she saw all of the bruising when Isabelle was in hospital.
"I was questioning why my daughter was having a heart attack," she says.
When asked when she started to think Simpson was responsible, she says while she was sitting in the hospital.
11:02am16/07/26
Court evacuated
The fire alarm has been activated in the court building and everyone is currently being evacuated.
10:59am16/07/26
Police arrive
When police arrived at the scene they asked if anybody had left the property and she told them no.
Mr McKone asks why she didn't tell then Simpson had been at the house, she says she was in shock and told them about it later.
She denies that she was trying to cover up for hew new boyfriend at the time.
The court hears how ten minutes after the police arrived she told them about Simpson had been at her home.
When asked why, she says: "I think at that point the severity of the situation had sank in."
The barrister asks her if she had seen Isabelle eating or drinking that morning after telling the paramedics that she was 'her usual self' on the morning.
She says she was just relaying what Simpson had told her had happened on the morning.

10:54am16/07/26
Fatal injuries
Walker tells the jury that she was unaware that Isabelle had been assaulted or had very serious head injuries.
When asked if she was trying to cover anything up that afternoon, she replied: "No."
She says she was 'in shock and heartbroken' when she was told her daughter had suffered a heart attack.
Walker says she didn't tell paramedics that Simpson had put her daughter to bed because she was 'ashamed' of drinking too much the night before and didn't want them the think she was a 'bad parent'.
She denies that she was covering up for Simpson when she told them she had put her daughter to bed.
10:52am16/07/26
Evidence resumes
Mr McKone is now dealing with the events on the day Isabelle suffered her fatal injuries.
Walker says she called her stepdad because she was scared when she couldn't wake her daughter up.
She says she also phoned Simpson four times in quick succession because she was panicking and wanted someone there for support.
The jury hears she took Simpson's bong out of the house as she didn't want him to see when he came round.
CCTV from inside the house captured Walker trying to wake Isabelle up because she had gone 'floppy'.
Mr McKone says her stepfather arrived at her Thornaby home and she thought Isabelle had stopped breathing shortly before.
"I think it was just before my dad walked through the door," she said. "She had gone floppy. Her eyes opened and she didn't look responsive - it was horrific," she says.
She confirms that her stepdad told her to 999 immediately.
When asked why she hadn't call earlier, she says she didn't think she needed to up until that point.
10:39am16/07/26
Mother's evidence
Alexandra Walker will continue giving evidence in her defence.
Mark McKone KC, representing the 26-year-old, will take her through the timeline of events leading up to Isabelle Welsh suffering fatal head injuries.
Yesterday, she categorically denied being responsible for inflicting injuries on her two-year-old daughter.
I don’t even know how to articulate what a disgrace this woman is. She doesn’t deserve the title of ‘mother’
The lies are layered on top of each other and it’s all about self- protection, even when her baby has been SA and killed. Negligent, selfish, cruel, heartless, inadequate…..the list would just go on.
 
  • Like
  • Heart
Reactions: 34

OGJessicaFletcher

VIP Member
Hopefully this helps with the timeline, the accuracy of the available reporting is inconsistent causing confusion.

Prosecution have demonstrated a pattern of neglect and hostility towards Isabelle weeks before her final collapse.
CCTV visually shows AW growing highly annoyed and verbally frustrated with her crying child limping around the home due to a broken leg. Rather than comforting her, AW snaps at the crying toddler, aggressively “What do you want?”

Richard Wright KC said “There are a lot of incidents of the two drinking and drugs being taken, and the prosecution say, unusual and sometimes aggressive behaviour being caught on CCTV” There were instances where Walker was getting “irritated” by Isabelle's behaviour. On one occasion Walker said her daughter was “behaving like a cunt”

On the 12th of September, Isabelle was in obvious pain, whimpering, screaming, and crying for her mother. The court heard that she had developed a bruise on her forehead and had started vomiting again. CCTV evidence showed AW repeatedly telling the toddler to “sit up!”

In the afternoon, AW messaged her mother to complain that Isabelle was throwing up again and that seeing her daughter like that was causing her “stress”, she requested that her mother bring her food, nappies, and 10 cans of Stella to “help her cope” Knowing her mother was coming to drop off the shopping, AW messaged HS trying to persuade him to meet her mother. AW reassured him in the text that her mum “won't bite” but, HS refused the interaction, and AW later claimed to her mother that he couldn't meet her because he suffered from severe “anxiety”

4.46pm A telephone recording captured the sound of a whimpering Isabelle lying on top of AW, she told the person on the other end of the line that her daughter “really isn't well”

5.30pm AW’s mother and stepfather arrived at the Hartington Close property to drop off the requested shopping and alcohol. Her mother Claire later stated it had become too upsetting to see her granddaughter in that deteriorating condition.

7pm AW was alone in the house with Isabelle a neighbour reported hearing a loud thud coming from the property.

9pm HS returned to the home. At this point, the couple began a heavy session of drinking and substance use.

The couple continued drinking alcohol and smoking cannabis from a bong late into the night and until 3am on September 13th, completely ignoring the toddler's ongoing medical distress.

AW called her mother and a friend (Sarah Ayre??) while heavily under the influence of alcohol. During these recorded calls, she aggressively insisted that she had been stabbed in her arm, chest, and leg during a separate incident where cannabis was allegedly stolen from her home. When challenged by the person on the other end of the line about her drinking, AW angrily denied that she was “making a drama” before lashing out around 2am and striking her kitchen cupboard doors. Sarah told the court AW’s speech sounded unusual, she was muttering her words, leading her to believe AW was “on something” at the time.

CCTV shows AW was highly agitated, dramatic, and focused entirely on her own historical grievances while Isabelle, was severely injured in the house. The home security footage actually captured her stabbing herself with a kitchen knife during the same time frame, while her boyfriend HS, smoked cannabis nearby.

AW did not leave the house during the hours leading up to her daughter’s collapse on September 13th. AW falsely claims she briefly left the house to visit a local shop & would wake Isabelle when HS returned the prosecution say this was a

2.53pm, AW messaged HS stating she intended to wake Isabelle up when he returned from the shops. She added that if she didn't wake the toddler now, Isabelle would be “up all night” Following this exchange, HS was the one captured on CCTV leaving the property permanently shortly after 3pm.

HS had been awake and in “sole care” of Isabelle during the morning while AW remained in bed upstairs. HS told AW that he had put the toddler down to sleep.

Isabelle was neither seen nor heard on the internal home CCTV during the morning September 13th. The prosecution highlighted the lack of presence to support their argument that Isabelle was already incapacitated or critically injured early in the day.

3pm HS left the property, internal CCTV and court records show that AW remained inside the house, completely failing to check on or help her dying daughter. However AW told her family that she checked on Isabelle every 10 minutes.

Within 10 minutes of her HS leaving the house at 3pm, AW’s primary focus was not providing medical care. Instead, she was running Google searches for why her toddler was bleeding.

3.15pm Internal CCTV captured AW walking up the stairs and speaking to herself, saying, “You're scaring me” She then ran another search for “What should I do if my child has blood in his stool”

3.20pm Rather than leaving the property to seek help or calling an ambulance, AW walked into the kitchen to smoke a cigarette!

4pm Still inside the property, AW called her stepfather instead of emergency services. Knowing her stepfather, Dan Ackroyd, was on his way, AW actively took the cannabis bong out of the kitchen and discarded it next to an outdoor bin to hide the drug use.

4.14pm Her stepfather arrived at the property, found the toddler unresponsive at the bottom of the stairs, and ordered AW to call 999.
 
Last edited:
  • Sad
  • Like
  • Angry
Reactions: 34

nothinonyou

VIP Member
Apparently she checked the sex offenders register for him a couple of times... How about you keep him away from your baby
 
  • Like
  • Angry
Reactions: 34
I know it’s not important in the grand scheme of things but it’s really irking me that AW says and also repeated in court, in the reporting “Isabelle had a heart attack”. No, she went into cardiac arrest because someone smashed her head in. A heart attack is when someone has a blood clot in their coronary artery and is usually middle aged or older, and if it’s not resolved they may go into cardiac arrest and die. Isabelle’s heart stopped because she was beaten to death. Is she so thick or disingenuous or just doesn’t care enough to know the difference?
 
  • Like
Reactions: 33

bigmac22

Well-known member
Huge red flag, he wouldn’t meet her because he had anxiety apparently. Can you imagine letting a new boyfriend move into your home and coming out with this load of twaddle.

I’m not blaming the Grandmother/Step Grandad at all but for reasons unknown they chose to ignore a lot of obvious signs something wasn’t quite right here. Grandmother agreed Isabelle should leave the hospital that night, I’m pretty sure it said that both G/parents noticed her limping.
See, I do absolutely blame the grandmother. She saw Isabelle covered in bruises on several occasions and clearly unwell the day before she died. IIRC she was also with her daughter when Isabelle was taken to hospital with the broken leg and all the safeguarding concerns and kick off that followed. Add to that, the boyfriend living in the house who her daughter had only known 5 minutes (and the grandmother had never even met) while also knowing her daughter had a history of being vulnerable to domestic abuse. Surely that combination should have set every alarm bell ringing.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 32
I’ve thought about her comment a lot. She said “Isabelle was always immaculately dressed”. I actually think she couldn’t say anything other than that, she was clutching at straws. She knew full well Isabelle wasn’t cared for. That little girl deserved to be adored and treasured. It doesn’t feel like anyone actually really cared about her.
I feel bad saying this but I always see rough families going about and their kids are in designer clothes/branded sportswear with expensive trainers. Usually being dragged along and shouted and sworn at. Doesn’t matter how you dress your kid if you treat them like crap.
 
  • Like
  • Heart
Reactions: 32

zogsmum

Active member
10:38am23/06/26
Case outline
The jury for the trial was sworn in yesterday afternoon and Richard Wright KC, prosecuting, will be opening the case against the two defendants this morning.
The barrister will be giving an outline of the prosecution case before the evidence begins after Isabelle Rose Welsh died last year.
Harrison Simpson, 22, and 25-year-old Alexandra Walker, are charged with the murder of the toddler in Thornaby on September 14.
They both pleaded not guilty to the charge when they made an appearance at Teesside Crown Court.

11:37am23/06/26
Prosecution opening
The Honourable Ms Justice Norton has spoken to the jury about their roles and responsibilities before the trial can begin.
Mr Wright is now addressing the jury as the trial gets underway.
The barrister will go through events leading up to the death of the toddler on September 13 last year and the investigations carried out to find the cause.
He says: "A 999 call was made to the emergency operator from a house at Hartington Close in Thornaby.
"The caller was the female defendant Alexandra Walker and she was calling about her two-year-old daughter Isabelle. Isabelle was in a state of collapse.
"She was gravely unwell and her heart had stopped beating.
"A call of that sort to the emergency services results in a priority response from the ambulance service and in this case a team of paramedics were at the property within a minute of being alerted to the request for an ambulance."

11:40am23/06/26
Medical evidence (warning graphic details)
He continues: "They found Isabelle on her back at the foot of the stairs. She had no pulse and was plainly gravely ill.
"Her body was covered in bruises, in particular she was very obviously bruised to her head, neck, abdomen, back, the area around her vagina and her anus.
"Her nappy contained blood and her face was contaminated with the remnants of vomit.
"She was rushed to the hospital by ambulance where she was treated by a team of specialist doctors but sadly, they could not save her, and she died in the early hours of the September 14.
"Isabelle’s death was not the result of some form of naturally occurring illness. She died because shortly before her terminal collapse somebody had inflicted a massive head injury upon her.
"Her skull had been fractured, her brain had been injured, and her heart had stopped as a result of that assault upon her.
"The mechanism of that injury involved Isabelle being violently shaken with her head and spine flexing and over extending, with her head impacting a hard and unyielding surface such as a wall or the floor.
"This was no accident. It was the deliberate infliction of injury on that little girl. It was, say the prosecution, murder."
 
  • Sad
  • Angry
  • Sick
Reactions: 32