Thanks for the insight. Yeah, I do think casual chic shoes would look better.
More generally, I wonder whether more cold-tone colors will work better for her. She seems to be some kind of Winter, maybe a Clear Winter or Cool Winter. I would like to see her try some more jewel tones like a darker purple, rich reds, and cobalt blue. Something to highlight the contrast between her hair and skin tone. The browns she chose earlier are on the warm side, not as flattering. Maybe taupe would work better. Just my two cents.