Do people use my fitness pal on its own or would you suggest to use it along with Slimming World or Weight Watchers? Between SW and WW is any better?
Calorie counting is SO much better than SW, WW etc I can't even tell you. I was literally saying to my partner this morning it's been so easy for me to lose weight on calories that I regret the years I spent on and off SW/WW never reaching my target.
SW I find doesn't teach you anything about portion control and isn't realistic long term unless you're prepared to always get a jacket potato when you're out and about. It used to stress me going anywhere in case there wasn't anything I could have. Plus restricting the type of food made me binge wildly. It's also very easy to overeat on 'healthy' foods, I've sometimes eaten 2k cals on an SW day which isn't a deficit for me so I wouldn't lose weight.
WW is so little food. I added it up to around 1000 calories. And I get they're trying to push you towards eating protein as it's more filling but demonising chocolate etc is stupid. I didn't cut it out, I just ate it anyway and went over my points.
Also really hate the once a week 'weigh day' thing. I do have a 'weigh day' on calories but I tend to check my weight on a Wednesday and a Saturday. So many factors affect your weight on any given day - what you ate the night before (salty food bloat etc) if you've been to the loo, if you've slept a decent amount, if you're on your period. As long as the overall trend is heading downwards, there's really no point getting hung up on any individual weight of one day. You could drop 2 lbs the next day if it's bloat, but if you've been to SW and feel crap that you've maintained or gained you might just go home and say 'sod it' get a take away and then never get that loss anyway.
In a similar vein - I used to hate on SW/WW the whole weekly points or syns thing. Because if you do go over, what do you do all week? On calories, I know what my target is for a loss and what my maintenance is if I'm feeling hungry (then I try not to go over that). If I go wildly over, I just get up the next day and carry on. None of this 'Oh I can't have any syns or weeklies all week now'. It's so much easier.
It also really really helps on calories that all food is basically equal. You could eat 200 cals of banana or 200 of chocolate, ultimately you will lose weight regardless of what you eat as long as you count it. I find this a much healthier mindset and I find myself barely ever thinking about food anymore unlike SW where I used to sit all day thinking about my next meal. I really believe 'hunger' isn't just about if your stomach is full but also mental satiety. If you're eating stuff you don't like much all the time, you're going to be thinking about food all the time. I'm sure lots of people will know the feeling of wanting a pizza or something, but trying not to get it so you sit nibbling at other bits in the kitchen all night instead when you could've just had a couple of slices and felt satisfied mentally.
Sorry this ended up being a huge essay
I'm just so pro calorie counting compared to SW/WW, which are based on cal counting anyway - they're basically cal counting for dummies. And they're also businesses, by taking the calorie counting out of it they're taking away your control which means you're always reliant on them. Myfitnesspal is free, does the same thing, seems a lot healthier mentally. Eat what you like, just less of it. I feel like I will actually hit my target this time - currently 20lbs down, 11 to go!