So I've spent the last few days reading through all these threads (dedication!). I originally found this thread because I find I really can't stand lilsimsie but now I think I detest deligracy more.
I don't follow any of the simstubers on other social media so I don't get the full extent of their special brand of eccentricity nor do I have the history with their inconsistencies and poor work ethic. But here are my thoughts
Lilsimsie - her videos are BORING. I did learn how to build roofs from one of her videos, but that's about all. She churns out videos every day and they're all the same. I've watched some of her streams/videos, and they rub me the wrong way; there's a certain harshness and meanness that comes across every once in a while. Let's just say I wouldn't want to be Dan. From watching some of her older videos and streams, I think a lot of it is rooted in low self-esteem and deep anxiety issues. Also, I know she had to get married to get Dan over on for a green card, but damn - that's young. Especially when she hasn't seen anything of life besides playing Sims 4. I know people who've married really young, but they've known each other since high school and have been very involved with each other, not been in a long-distance relationship for three years. But I will give her credit for her impeccable work ethic (though I think a lot of it stems from perfectionism and control issues). Also, Dan's editing issues - I just thought they were artistic choices to leave in the repeating sentences. Lol
Plumbella - I've watched some of her latest videos and the energy in them is ALL OVER THE PLACE. In some of them she's downright manic, in others, low energy. And you guys are right - she's made being a northern, Tory-hating, autistic girl her whole identity. I like some of her older videos on the history of the Sims, but now she's just cartoonish, I find it hard to take her seriously. HOWEVER, I don't fault her for doing a collab on a kit even though she hates kits. I don't think anyone would pass up a chance to do that. I don't buy kits, I'm not a build/buy or CAS kind of gamer, but it's decent, if you like that style.
(Also, I find it really strange that lilsimsie considers plumbella her "best friend in the entire world" - they seem so different and incompatible - lilsimsie's image is VANILLA AND BORING and plumbella is just plain CHAOS. I can't imagine them having anything in common.)
Deligrancy - I had no opinion of her coming in, but OMG - watching some of her videos and her instagrams - the woman is an airhead. I haven't seen anything this personality-less/vapid in a long time. She's either very lazy or clinically depressed. And all her period and poo references - jeez - what is wrong with this 30+ year old woman
James - Never really watched him or thought about him - I start to feel sorry for him for being with deli - but then remember, he's a grown-ass man and doesn't have to stay. There's something he likes about this woman, or maybe he can't bring himself to admit he's made a HUGE mistake (cuing Gob from Arrested Development)
Didn't know much about Clare Siobhan, but see that she's married to Ali-A who has 11.7 million subscribers and his channel seems to be going strong. Now there's a YT Gaming powerhouse couple.
SatchonSims - I feel like he's still finding his way. But at least he's realistic and knows Youtube isn't going to last forever for him, and has some vague plans of going into video editing later (though at least right now his editing is awful, so he has a long way to go). He also seems to have this notion that Sims has a "challenge mode" (the Scenarios) and a "sandbox mode" (playing the game with all the cheats) but no "normal" mode like other games. And I yell everytime "The don't turn on cheats when you're playing the game"). It's like he's trying to be creative and come up with new things to criticize EA for that haven't already been done. Because let's face it - we all have the exact same gripes about the game.
Devon Bumpkin - I watched a couple of videos after reading the recommendations - and someone on here hit the nail on the head. He IS the Bob Ross of the Sims on Youtube.