Lucy Letby Case #2

Status
Thread locked. We start a new thread when they have over 1000 posts, click the blue button to see all threads for this topic and find the latest open thread.
New to Tattle Life? Click "Order Thread by Most Liked Posts" button below to get an idea of what the site is about:
Yes, I agree. The hospital is guilty of negligence. To fail one baby is bad but 22 times in the space of a year?!
It just baffles me. Even IF she is guilty, the hospital has a LOT to answer for. Short staffed shouldn't have meant they failed 22 times.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 12
She wasn't a higher band nurse the prosecution have worded this rubbish. She's a registered nurse so higher than 3's and 4's but a band 5 , there's 6's and a 7 on duty during day shift , definitely 6's. She wasn't the most senior nurse there.
Oh ok thanks 😊
 
Oh ok fair enough. I'd love to know why they want someone on the team for the next 3 years. Asides from the obvious tragedies this is such an interesting case.
This is confusing me. Operation Hummingbird has cost millions and this job advert makes me wonder if theres more to come out. I did wonder if she was part of a 'cult' or 'ring' with other nurses worldwide but that might sound a bit far fetched and I'm overthinking this job advert.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 5
Whether she's guilty or not, that hospital FAILED. How the duck didn't they know? If babies were dying bur doctors say they were abnormally hard to resuscitate etc surely they would have known something was going on? And why weren't there others checking the medication?
Yes in some ways the hospital did fail.........except..........and this is probably where the whole case is so complicated, these were premature babies, who would/could die in any case without medical intervention, because of their extreme vulnerabilities. Which is why it took months for the hospital to see a specific pattern emerge.
60 years ago these kinds of premature babies would probably have died because we didnt have the neonatal beds and experience we do have now.

So its a bit of a chicken and egg for me, did the babies die because they were born premature? So they were in danger of dying in any case. Or did they die because something wasn't done well enough to ensure that they did survive?
 
  • Like
Reactions: 13
Yes in some ways the hospital did fail.........except..........and this is probably where the whole case is so complicated, these were premature babies, who would/could die in any case without medical intervention, because of their extreme vulnerabilities. Which is why it took months for the hospital to see a specific pattern emerge.
60 years ago these kinds of premature babies would probably have died because we didnt have the neonatal beds and experience we do have now.

So its a bit of a chicken and egg for me, did the babies die because they were born premature? So they were in danger of dying in any case. Or did they die because something wasn't done well enough to ensure that they did survive?
But doctors said that they were unusually hard to resuscitate so why didn't they investigate? Whether they were premature ir not, they should have investigate something they thought unusual.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 9
This is confusing me. Operation Hummingbird has cost millions and this job advert makes me wonder if theres more to come out. I did wonder if she was part of a 'cult' or 'ring' with other nurses worldwide but that might sound a bit far fetched and I'm overthinking this job advert.
I do think they suspect there is more to come, they've gotta do surely if she's on trial as it is what else is there to investigate? Absolutely chilling if she has done this. Still not convinced tbh but like everyone else I am waiting to see the full evidence come out.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 7
This is confusing me. Operation Hummingbird has cost millions and this job advert makes me wonder if theres more to come out. I did wonder if she was part of a 'cult' or 'ring' with other nurses worldwide but that might sound a bit far fetched and I'm overthinking this job advert.
If she's guilty, it'd a case of a murderous nurse. Not a cult I doubt.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2
It’s not people plucked from thin air, it’s people whose children have been deemed at risk of harm. It’s statutory intervention. Why would you share something publicly on social media that doesn’t match up with what you’ve said in real life?

We are here to protect you and your children, having a boyfriend is fine, having one and lying about it isn’t.
I'm sorry to pip in but I'm shocked at what you have been saying. From a sen parents point of view with experience with social workers and from a professional point of view in the same field this is not statutory intervention.

I'm assuming if you snoop on social media accounts you have obtained a RIPA warrant from a magistrate for that case? (Which wouldn't be granted for child safeguarding cases). Or you have a written agreement from the parent or carer? If not, your commiting a criminal offence which could really damage any case taken to a family court or see you personally liable for damages in a criminal court.
 
  • Like
  • Heart
Reactions: 12
So does that mean she's guilty?
You’ve quoted me twice already. I have no idea if she is guilty or not. We have heard barely anything yet.. Yes she was there but we only have the prosecution’s theory. There has been no proof so far.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 6
I studied law at uni, and work as a property lawyer, from what I remember of criminal law you basically don't ask them if they are guilty if you suspect they are.
In the UK the defense lawyers can't lie to the court (i.e. to say "no Lucy did not look them up on Facebook" when she obviously did) so it's a fine art of trying to pick holes and cast doubt without actually saying this didn't happen. Defendants obviously can lie to their layers (and often do) and are entitled to plea as they wish.
It's all a lot more balanced than in the USA.
Yes. Defendants cannot tell their solicitor they committed the offence then plead not guilty, the solicitor would have to withdraw but not divulge their guilt due to legal privilege.
A solicitor wouldn’t ask if they’ve committed the offence but provide evidence& advise on defences available.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 4
I don’t get why people are so shocked about the Facebook searching. If you put stuff on social media then it’s available for anyone to vote unless you restrict who can view your posts. I think it’s only natural to be nosy but it’s a question not of whether she should have done it but when and why she did it.

The pertinent aspect will be the timing and level of interest her searches reveal.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 38
I don’t get why people are so shocked about the Facebook searching. If you put stuff on social media then it’s available for anyone to vote unless you restrict who can view your posts. I think it’s only natural to be nosy but it’s a question not of whether she should have done it but when and why she did it.

The pertinent aspect will be the timing and level of interest her searches reveal.
Exactly. Theres a reason why teachers, etc usually use first and middle names on their fb so they can't be found by parents. I'd say the majority of people are extremely nosy. But like you say its the timings and nature of the searches are what's crucial here
 
  • Like
Reactions: 20
My little boy when he was 1 got in my bag and put an antibiotic in his mouth and chewed it. There was a rip at the bottom of my bag and I didn't know the tablet was there. It was a penicillin one, not like kids can't have that and 111 were really good. Said he would be fine amd he was. Me calling 111 triggered social services phoning me and I was terrified. The NHS hadn't called them they wanted to make sure he was safe because it sounded like he wasn't. I've never been so upset in my whole life. I made a complaint and they turned up to check his home life. He's safe and happy and looked after really well. So their visit was just because I complained, it made things worse. Getting angry and violent with them does nothing.
when I was in hospital last June, as I was in ICU with no timeframe of coming out, our local social services spoke to my daughters Dad, my immediate family over a care plan for my daughter - she was only 1.5 years old at the time. Mainly because they needed to know she was safe and her basic needs where being met whilst I was in hospital (I’m her primary carer more or less, she has an amazing relationship with her dad but I do the majority of it).. They wanted to be sure how my daughter was being looked after and even if my Dad and step mum had everything they needed at their house for when she stayed. Imagine if they didn’t check and my daughter was literally neglected by my family! Social services aren’t all bad xx
 
  • Like
Reactions: 26
It is hard to judge, because we are only basing our opinion on the first 2 hours of the opening speech. In my view, nothing appears coincidental up to now.

If she's guilty, it'd a case of a murderous nurse. Not a cult I doubt.
Of course if she is guilty, then she would be a 'murderous nurse'. But that doesn't take away from the motive and if others are committing similar crimes *worldwide* (if this occured so many times before it has been highlighted then how many other medical professionals are committing 'one offs' on the chance of never getting caught).
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2
Something doesn't add up. If multiple times in the case of one child she was ignoring instructions and was there when they child was deteriorating, WHY wasn't she pulled off duty and why didn't they look into it?

I'm sorry but that doesn't make sense. Whether they were short staffed or not, if she ignoring instructions and was around a child when they because poorly and deteriorating, they should have taken her away from her job and looked into it.

Something is very off about it all.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 20
Something doesn't add up. If multiple times in the case of one child she was ignoring instructions and was there when they child was deteriorating, WHY wasn't she pulled off duty and why didn't they look into it?

I'm sorry but that doesn't make sense. Whether they were short staffed or not, if she ignoring instructions and was around a child when they because poorly and deteriorating, they should have taken her away from her job and looked into it.

Something is very off about it all.
i wonder if they were just such short staffed, they didn’t want to lose what staff they had. People too busy to notice something was fully amiss.

I’m following live today!
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1
I can’t understand it either. Three babies should have been enough to raise alarms.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 10
Status
Thread locked. We start a new thread when they have over 1000 posts, click the blue button to see all threads for this topic and find the latest open thread.